RAYMAR MINISTRIES, INC., PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. LYDIA DELA CRUZ, RICARDO ALARCON, JONATHAN SANCHEZ, LUZVIMINDA VAGILIDAD, JERRY ELIZARDE, SAMUEL TEMPLADO, RODOLFO DELA CRUZ, DE…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Raymar Ministries versus Dela Cruz
The Case
This is Raymar Ministries versus Dela Cruz, a civil appeal in which the plaintiff, Raymar Ministries, obtained a favorable judgment below and the defendants, led by Lydia Dela Cruz, appealed. The defendants then failed to file their appellant's brief within the period fixed by the Rules of Court. The Supreme Court was asked, in effect, to decide whether an appeal may be dismissed outright for that failure. The case matters because it is a clean illustration of the appellant's brief as a mandatory requirement, and of the consequence that follows when counsel lets the period lapse.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court, where judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiff, Raymar Ministries. The defendants, dissatisfied, elevated the matter to the Court of Appeals by way of an ordinary appeal. Before the Court of Appeals, the clerk of court issued a notice directing the defendants, as appellants, to file their brief within forty-five days from receipt of the notice. That notice was sent to their counsel, and it was received on March 3, 2014. As of June 2, 2014, no brief had been filed, as reflected in the docket of the Cebu station of the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals, acting on that failure, issued a resolution dismissing the appeal. The matter then reached the Supreme Court, which resolved it in a short resolution penned by Justice Lagura-Yap, with Justices Ingles and Lopez concurring.
Facts
Raymar Ministries sued the defendants and won before the trial court. The defendants appealed to the Court of Appeals, which is their right. Once the appeal was pending, the clerk of court sent a notice to the defendants' counsel, Atty. Pietro Villarin, requiring the filing of the appellant's brief within forty-five days from receipt.
The notice was received on March 3, 2014. The forty-five day period therefore began to run from that date. The record shows proof of service of the notice.
By June 2, 2014, the docket of the Court of Appeals showed that no brief had been filed. The defendants simply did not comply. There is nothing in the decision to suggest that they asked for an extension, or that they offered any explanation for the delay. On that record, the Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal, and the Supreme Court upheld that dismissal.
Issues
- Whether or not an appeal may be dismissed when the appellant fails to file the appellant's brief within the forty-five day period fixed by the Rules of Court.
- Whether or not the dismissal of the appeal in this case was proper given that the notice was received by counsel and no brief was filed as of the date shown in the docket.
Applicable Provisions
Section 7 of Rule 44 of the Revised Rules of Court provides:
Section 7. Appellant's brief. It shall be the duty of the appellant to file with the court, within forty-five (45) days from receipt of the notice of the clerk that all the evidence, oral and documentary, are attached to the record, seven (7) copies of his legibly typewritten, mimeographed or printed brief, with proof of service of two (2) copies thereof upon the appellee.
This is the provision the Court applied, and it fixes both the duty to file the appellant's brief and the period within which that duty must be discharged.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the filing of the appellant's brief is not optional but a duty. Section 7 of Rule 44 states that it shall be the duty of the appellant to file the brief within forty-five days from receipt of the notice of the clerk. Because the rule speaks of a duty, noncompliance carries a consequence, and that consequence is dismissal of the appeal.
On the second issue, the Court found the factual premise established. The notice to file brief was sent to the defendants' counsel, Atty. Pietro Villarin. It was received on March 3, 2014, and proof of service was on record. As of June 2, 2014, no brief had been filed, as shown by the docket of the Court of Appeals. The period had plainly lapsed without compliance.
The Court therefore concluded that the appeal must be dismissed for failure to comply with the rule, and it disposed of the case accordingly.
Doctrine
An appellant bears a duty to file the appellant's brief within forty-five days from receipt of the notice of the clerk that all the evidence, oral and documentary, are attached to the record. The appellant must file seven copies of the brief, with proof of service of two copies upon the appellee. Failure to comply with this duty warrants dismissal of the appeal. The period runs from receipt of the notice by counsel, and counsel's receipt binds the client. A bar candidate should state the rule as a rule: the appellant's brief is mandatory, the period is mandatory, and the sanction for noncompliance is dismissal of the appeal.
Disposition
The Supreme Court upheld the dismissal of the defendants' appeal for failure to file the appellant's brief, so Raymar Ministries prevailed and the judgment in its favor stood.
Remember This
Memorize this line: the appellant's brief is a duty under Section 7 of Rule 44, and failure to file it within forty-five days from receipt of the notice results in dismissal of the appeal. Examiners use this case in remedial law to test the periods and the sanctions for noncompliance with the rules on briefs, and to test whether receipt of notice by counsel binds the client.