🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ABNER DE GUIA, REPRESENTED BY HIS ATTY.-IN-FACT NOMERIANO DE GUIA, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. SELENI REGALA AND THE ASSESSOR OF THE CITY OF PROMULGATED: OLONGAPO, DEFENDANTS-APPELL…

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

De Guia versus Regala

The Case

This is a case about a parcel of land in Olongapo City and two persons claiming it. Abner De Guia, represented by his attorney in fact Nomeriano De Guia, sued Seleni Regala and the Assessor of the City of Olongapo for recovery of possession and ownership of real property, cancellation of documents, and a writ of preliminary injunction. De Guia says he bought the land in 1968 and has owned it since; Regala says she bought a portion of it years later from a woman who, on the witness stand, denied ever selling her anything. The case matters because it shows how the Supreme Court treats the factual findings of a trial court, and because it shows what happens to a buyer who takes her title from a seller who never really sold.

Procedural History

De Guia filed the complaint for recovery of possession and ownership, cancellation of documents, and preliminary injunction before the Regional Trial Court. After trial, the court rendered judgment in favor of De Guia. It ordered Regala to vacate and restore possession of the property covered by Tax Declaration Number 9400104661, with an area of 885 square meters; ordered the City Assessor to cancel that tax declaration; and ordered Regala to pay 50,000 pesos as attorney's fees and the costs. Regala appealed to the Court of Appeals, assigning as errors the order to vacate and restore possession, the order to cancel the tax declaration, and the award of attorney's fees and costs. The Court of Appeals denied the appeal and affirmed the decision of the trial court. Hence this appeal to the Supreme Court.

Facts

In 1968, Abner De Guia purchased a parcel of land at Sitio Maquinaya, now known as Abra Extension, Barangay Barretto, Olongapo City. At the time of purchase the land had an area of 18,000 square meters, as stated in a 1971 tax declaration. De Guia enclosed the whole area with a high concrete fence. When Mount Pinatubo erupted, the area became elevated and dwarfed the fence. Some portions of the land were later sold, and a new tax declaration was issued in place of the old one.

Sometime in 1998, De Guia learned that Regala had also declared a portion of the land for taxation purposes and had even submitted a Miscellaneous Sales Application before the Bureau of Lands. He investigated and found that a Waiver of Possessory Rights had supposedly been executed by a certain Beatriz Sabangan in favor of Regala. When De Guia confronted Sabangan, she was surprised to see the document and denied having executed it. The matter was brought before the barangay, but no settlement was reached, so De Guia filed suit.

Regala's version is that she saw the lot vacant, was told by neighbors that it belonged to Beatriz Sabangan, and went with a certain Teofilo Español to Sabangan's residence in Cabangan, Zambales, where she convinced Sabangan to sell. The property was allegedly sold to her for 180,000 pesos under a Deed of Transfer and Possessory Right with waiver and quitclaim. She had the lot surveyed, and what was supposed to be 600 square meters turned out to be 885 square meters. She applied for a Miscellaneous Sales Application, declared the lot for taxation, secured a fencing permit, and began enclosing the property. At trial, however, Beatriz Sabangan denied knowing Regala or having any transaction with her, and affirmed that she and her husband had sold the property only to De Guia. The testimony showed that it was Teofilo Español, the former City Assessor of Olongapo, who manipulated the supposed sale to Regala, making Sabangan believe that the portion sold was outside the lot already sold to De Guia.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court erred in ordering Regala to vacate and restore possession of the property in question to De Guia.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in ordering the City Assessor to cancel Tax Declaration Number 9400104661.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in ordering Regala to pay attorney's fees in the sum of 50,000 pesos and to pay the costs.

Applicable Provisions

This decision does not quote or construe any statutory provision. It rests on case law regarding the weight given to the factual findings of the trial court, which the Court states as follows:

Case law has it that the findings of facts of the trial court, its calibration of the evidence of the parties and its conclusions anchored on its findings are accorded by the appellate court high respect if not conclusive effect.

This principle bears on the case because the appeal turns entirely on questions of fact, namely who really owned and possessed the land, and the Court declines to disturb the trial court's findings.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that there is no merit in the appeal. Regala roots her ownership in the alleged sale by Beatriz Sabangan, but her supposed seller herself denied knowing Regala or having any sale transaction with her. Sabangan testified that she did not know Regala, had never met her personally, and had no transaction with her. On the other hand, Sabangan positively affirmed the sale of the property to De Guia, declaring that she and her husband sold it only to Abner De Guia and to nobody else. The Court also found that it was Teofilo Español, the former City Assessor, who manipulated the sale to Regala, making Sabangan believe that the portion sold to Regala was outside the lot already sold to De Guia. Even the testimony of Sofronio Mendoza, Regala's own father, confirmed that it was Español who had a hand in the sale and that the acquisition was entrusted to him. From these testimonies and the documentary evidence, the Court concluded that there is no doubt that what was sold to Regala was a lot already belonging to De Guia since 1968. Since the findings of the trial court are accorded high respect if not conclusive effect, the Court found no reason to rule otherwise.

On the second issue, the order to cancel Tax Declaration Number 9400104661 stands, because that declaration was issued in Regala's name over property that was never validly sold to her. On the third issue, the award of 50,000 pesos in attorney's fees and the costs likewise stands, as part of the affirmed judgment.

Doctrine

A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, the findings of fact of the trial court, its calibration of the evidence of the parties, and its conclusions anchored on those findings are accorded by the appellate court high respect, if not conclusive effect. Second, a buyer acquires no right from a seller who never sold; where the supposed seller denies the sale, the buyer's claim of ownership collapses. Third, a tax declaration does not by itself confer ownership, and one issued over land already belonging to another may be ordered cancelled.

Disposition

The appeal was denied and the decision of the trial court was affirmed, so De Guia won: Regala must vacate and restore possession of the property to him, the City Assessor must cancel Tax Declaration Number 9400104661, and Regala must pay 50,000 pesos in attorney's fees and the costs.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the findings of fact of the trial court, its calibration of the evidence, and its conclusions anchored on those findings are accorded by the appellate court high respect if not conclusive effect. Examiners use this case to test the conclusiveness of trial court findings on appeal and the rule that a tax declaration is not proof of ownership.