GOLDEN STAR MANNING AND SHIP MANAGEMENT CORP. AND ANTONIO SULAY III, PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION SEVENTH DIVISION AND CIPRIANO P. CONSAD, JR., RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Golden Star Manning and Ship Management versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 filed by Golden Star Manning and Ship Management Corporation and Antonio Sulay III against the National Labor Relations Commission, Seventh Division, and Cipriano P. Consad, Junior. The petitioners ask the Supreme Court to annul the Commission's decision and resolution awarding the private respondent wage differentials, thirteenth month pay, and service incentive leave pay. The case matters because it tests how far the labor tribunals may go in admitting evidence offered for the first time on appeal, and because it shows that a worker's signature on payroll sheets is the best evidence of actual payment of wages.
Procedural History
The private respondent filed a complaint for illegal dismissal and money claims before the Labor Arbiter. The Labor Arbiter ruled that there was no illegal dismissal, but ordered the petitioners to pay thirteenth month pay and service incentive leave pay amounting to nine thousand four hundred fifty-five pesos. On appeal, the National Labor Relations Commission affirmed with modification and ordered the payment of wage differentials, thirteenth month pay, and service incentive leave pay in the aggregate amount of one hundred one thousand nine hundred ten pesos and forty-nine centavos. On the petitioners' motion for reconsideration, the Commission denied the motion as to the salary differentials but reduced the thirteenth month pay, leaving a total award of ninety-one thousand eight hundred five pesos and forty-nine centavos. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari under Rule 65, imputing grave abuse of discretion to the Commission.
Facts
Cipriano P. Consad, Junior was employed by Golden Star Manning and Ship Management Corporation as a welder beginning July 9, 2008. He worked from eight in the morning to five in the afternoon, Mondays through Saturdays, and was paid a monthly salary of six thousand pesos, or two hundred eighty-five pesos per day. He claimed that this was below the prescribed minimum wage of three hundred five pesos per day, that he never received overtime pay, service incentive leave pay, or thirteenth month pay, and that the company automatically deducted food and medical allowances from his pay without his written consent.
The company answered that the private respondent had agreed, under a Salary and Benefits Agreement for the years 2008, 2009, and 2010, to the payment of his thirteenth month pay and service incentive leave pay on a pro-rata monthly basis. It also alleged that beginning around December 2011 he became difficult to handle, left the workplace without permission, and ignored his supervisor, Henry Regner. After a memorandum and a last warning, the company issued a written notice of fifteen-day suspension from May 16 to June 1, 2012 for continuous insubordination. The private respondent refused to receive the notice and insisted on reporting for work. After the suspension lapsed, the company sent him several return to work orders by registered mail, which he refused. He then filed the complaint on July 9, 2012.
Before the Labor Arbiter, the company did not present payroll sheets. Only after the Commission modified the Labor Arbiter's decision by awarding salary differentials did the company submit payroll sheets covering January 2009 to May 2012, to show that the food and medicine allowances formed part of the private respondent's salary and were actually received by him in cash every payday.
Issues
- Whether or not the payroll sheets submitted by the petitioners for the first time on reconsideration before the National Labor Relations Commission may still be considered as evidence of payment.
- Whether or not the monetary award granted to the private respondent, particularly the wage differentials, has legal and factual basis.
Applicable Provisions
Article 221 of the Labor Code, as amended, provides:
In any proceeding before the Commission or any of the Labor Arbiters, the rules of evidence prevailing in courts of law or equity shall not be controlling and it is the spirit and intention of this Code that the Commission and its members and the Labor Arbiters shall use every and all reasonable means to ascertain the facts in each case speedily and objectively and without regard to technicalities of law or procedure, all in the interest of due process.
This provision is the foundation of the Court's ruling that the Commission erred in rejecting the payroll sheets on technical grounds.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled in favor of the petitioners. The Labor Arbiter and the National Labor Relations Commission are not bound by the technical rules of procedure observed in the regular courts. The Court held that the Commission committed grave abuse of discretion when it strictly applied procedural technicalities and disregarded the payroll sheets, in complete disregard of the established policy of the Labor Code. The Court stressed that rules of procedure and evidence should not be applied in a very rigid and technical sense in labor cases, and that technicality should not be allowed to stand in the way of equitably and completely resolving the rights and obligations of the parties. The Court also held that the fact that the payroll sheets were not certified true copies of the originals did not weaken the petitioners' case, because the private respondent did not question the authenticity of his signature appearing on them.
On the second issue, the Court again ruled for the petitioners. The payroll sheets speak for themselves. The private respondent's signature appears opposite the amount of his net pay for each period, and the Court recalled the rule that ideally the signatures of employees should appear in the payroll as evidence of actual payment. The Court held that the private respondent's self-serving and unsubstantiated allegation that he did not receive the cash equivalent of the medicine and food allowances cannot overturn the evidentiary weight of his signature on the payroll sheets and on the payslips he himself submitted. The payrolls showed that his gross salary consisted of basic salary plus forty pesos medicine allowance and one thousand one hundred forty-seven pesos and fifty centavos victualling allowance, so that his net pay was already over and above the statutory wage rate. There was therefore no reason to grant wage differentials. The Court closed with the maxim that no one shall unjustly enrich oneself at the expense of another.
Doctrine
First, labor tribunals are not bound by the technical rules of evidence prevailing in courts of law or equity. They may consider documentary evidence submitted for the first time on appeal, and procedural lapses may be relaxed in the interest of substantial justice, because labor cases must be decided according to justice and equity and the substantial merits of the controversy.
Second, payroll sheets bearing the signatures of employees are the primary and best evidence of actual payment of wages. A worker's bare, self-serving assertion that he did not receive the amounts reflected in the payroll cannot prevail over his own signature, especially where he does not question its authenticity.
Third, where the payroll shows that the employee's net pay, including allowances forming part of his salary, is over and above the statutory minimum wage, there is no basis for an award of wage differentials.
Disposition
The petition was granted, and the decision and resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission were modified by deleting the award of salary differentials.
Remember This
Memorize this line: payroll sheets bearing the employee's signature are the best evidence of payment, and labor tribunals may admit evidence first offered on appeal in the interest of substantial justice. Examiners like to use this case on the liberal application of the rules of evidence in labor proceedings and on the evidentiary weight of payrolls against a worker's self-serving claim of underpayment.