🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PCI LEASING AND FINANCE, INC., (NOW BDO LEASING AND FINANCE, INC.), PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, VS. SPOUSES LAMBERTO P. CRUZ AND CARMELITA C. CRUZ, AND JOHN DOE DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES.

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

PCI Leasing and Finance versus Cruz

The Case

This is a case about a creditor who sued to recover mortgaged heavy equipment, and a trial court that dismissed the suit before the debtor ever presented a single witness. PCI Leasing and Finance, now BDO Leasing and Finance, sued the spouses Lamberto Cruz and Carmelita Cruz, who did business as L. Cruz Enterprises, in a complaint for replevin with damages. The creditor wanted possession of the mortgaged machinery, or in the alternative, payment of the unpaid balance of the loan. The spouses answered that their obligation was already extinguished because they had surrendered the mortgaged chattels and because the real estate mortgages had been foreclosed. The case matters because it teaches two things at once: how a demurrer to evidence must be resolved, and who carries the burden of proving that an obligation has been extinguished.

Procedural History

The complaint for replevin with damages was filed before the Regional Trial Court of Dagupan City, Branch 40. The spouses first moved to dismiss, and that motion was denied. They then filed an answer with counterclaim. The creditor presented its evidence through its officer in charge, Michael Jun Ugto, and then rested its case. At that point the spouses moved to dismiss on the ground that the obligation had been extinguished. The trial court granted the motion and dismissed the case for extinguishment of obligation and for lack of cause of action. The creditor moved for reconsideration, and the trial court denied it, adding that the creditor could not ask for a deficiency judgment because the action was one for replevin and not for deficiency judgment. The creditor then appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning as errors the dismissal on those two grounds and the finding that it had failed to prove its claim.

Facts

The spouses obtained loans from the creditor and executed promissory notes on several dates in 1996 for a total of 70,922,160 pesos. To secure payment, they executed chattel mortgages in favor of the creditor over various heavy equipment and machinery. By the end of July 1998 their outstanding obligation was 43,606,810 pesos, exclusive of interest. The loan was restructured to 49,749,005 pesos, inclusive of interest, payable in monthly amortizations under a Memorandum of Agreement. The spouses defaulted on the restructured loan.

In July 2000 the creditor filed its complaint for replevin with damages. It alleged that it had demanded payment of the entire balance of 38,171,138 pesos, excluding interests and penalties, or the delivery of the mortgaged motor vehicles for foreclosure, and that the spouses refused. It prayed for possession of the vehicles, or in the alternative, payment of the outstanding balance with interest and penalties, plus attorney's fees and liquidated damages.

In their answer the spouses claimed that their obligation was already extinguished because they had voluntarily surrendered the mortgaged vehicles and the real estate mortgages had been foreclosed. The creditor admitted that nine mortgaged chattels were surrendered, but said the spouses refused to execute a dacion en pago over them, and that the appraised value of those nine chattels was only 3,180,000 pesos while the foreclosed real estates sold for only 5,715,000 pesos, leaving a substantial unpaid balance. After the creditor rested its case, the spouses moved to dismiss, and the trial court granted the motion, relying on documents that were merely attached to the motion and the reply and never offered in evidence.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court erred in granting the motion to dismiss filed after the plaintiff rested its case, which is in truth a demurrer to evidence, by resolving it on the basis of the defendants' evidence.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in holding that the obligation of the spouses had been extinguished.
  • Whether or not the trial court erred in holding that the complaint stated no cause of action.
  • Whether or not the creditor is entitled to a writ of replevin and to the damages it prayed for.

Applicable Provisions

Section 1 of Rule 33 of the Rules of Court provides:

Section 1. Demurrer to evidence. After the plaintiff has completed the presentation of his evidence, the defendant may move for dismissal on the ground that upon the facts and the law the plaintiff has shown no right to relief. If his motion is denied, he shall have the right to present evidence. If the motion is granted but on appeal the order of dismissal is reversed he shall be deemed to have waived the right to present evidence.

This is the provision that governs the motion filed by the spouses after the creditor rested, and it fixes both the test to be applied and the consequence of a reversal on appeal.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the motion to dismiss filed after the plaintiff completed its evidence is a demurrer to evidence governed by Rule 33. What the court resolves is whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief upon the facts and the law, and the defendant's evidence must be excluded. The trial court violated this rule when it considered the transfer certificates of title, the releases of chattel mortgage, and the deeds of dacion that were merely attached to the motion and the reply and never offered in evidence. By taking that evidence into account, the trial court should have allowed the spouses to present their evidence formally, so that the creditor could object to it. The Court also found that the dismissal order contained no real discussion of whether the creditor had shown a right to relief; it merely narrated the arguments and concluded that the defendants' arguments prevailed.

On the second issue, the Court held that the debtor bears the burden of showing with legal certainty that the obligation has been discharged by payment. The spouses failed to discharge that burden. The foreclosure of the real estate mortgages did not bar the foreclosure of the chattel mortgages, because the amount realized from the auction sale of the real estates was insufficient to cover the unpaid loan, and a mortgage creditor may still recover any deficiency. The releases of chattel mortgage and the deeds of dacion covered only some chattels and extinguished only a portion of the obligation, the total dacion price being only 2,814,000 pesos against an unpaid principal of 38,182,817 pesos. And the mere surrender of the mortgaged chattels did not extinguish the loan, because delivery of possession to the mortgagee operates to extinguish the mortgagor's liability only if the mortgagee actually caused the foreclosure sale of the property.

On the third issue, the Court held that the existence of a cause of action is determined by the allegations of the complaint. If those allegations, admitted to be true, would entitle the plaintiff to the relief prayed for, the complaint must not be dismissed regardless of the defenses averred. The complaint alleged the loans, the chattel mortgages, the restructuring, the outstanding obligation, and the refusal to pay or deliver, and those allegations warranted the reliefs sought.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that because the demurrer is dismissed on appeal, the defendants lose the right to present their evidence, and the appellate court proceeds to render judgment on the merits on the basis of the plaintiff's evidence. Replevin is primarily possessory in nature and generally determines nothing more than the right of possession. Since the spouses defaulted on the restructured loan secured by chattel mortgages, the issuance of a writ of replevin, after the creditor posted the required bond, was in order. The Court also found the spouses liable for liquidated damages, attorney's fees, and the replevin bond premium under the terms of the chattel mortgage.

Doctrine

A motion to dismiss filed by the defendant after the plaintiff has completed the presentation of its evidence is a demurrer to evidence under Rule 33. The court resolves it only on the plaintiff's evidence, together with judicial admissions, matters of judicial notice, stipulations, admissions, and presumptions, and never on the defendant's evidence. If the court considers the defendant's evidence, it violates the plaintiff's right to due process, and it should instead allow the defendant to present evidence formally.

The debtor who alleges that an obligation has been extinguished must prove the facts or acts giving rise to the extinction. Foreclosure of a real estate mortgage does not bar foreclosure of a chattel mortgage securing the same debt, and a mortgage creditor may recover any deficiency. A deed of dacion extinguishes the obligation only up to the extent of the dacion price. The surrender of mortgaged chattels to the mortgagee extinguishes the mortgagor's liability only if the mortgagee actually caused the foreclosure sale of those chattels.

Cause of action is determined solely by the allegations of the complaint. If those allegations, admitted to be true, would entitle the plaintiff to the relief prayed for, the complaint states a cause of action and must not be dismissed. When a demurrer to evidence is dismissed on appeal, the defendant is deemed to have waived the right to present evidence, and the appellate court renders judgment on the merits on the basis of the plaintiff's evidence.

Disposition

The Supreme Court reversed and set aside the orders of the trial court, granted the issuance of a writ of replevin against the properties subject of the subsisting chattel mortgage, and ordered the spouses to pay the creditor 50,000 pesos as attorney's fees, 100,000 pesos as liquidated damages, and 50,000 pesos as replevin bond premium and other costs of seizure.

Remember This

The single line to memorize: on a demurrer to evidence the court looks only at the plaintiff's evidence, and the debtor who claims extinction must prove it. Examiners use this case to test the Rule 33 demurrer, the burden of proving payment, and the rule that foreclosure of one mortgage does not bar foreclosure of another securing the same debt.