SPS. MEDARDO & JOCELYN DELFINO, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLEES, VS. SPS. ALEJANDRO & LIZA NACORDA, DEFENDANTS-APPELLANTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Delfino versus Nacorda
The Case
This is an appeal by spouses Alejandro and Liza Nacorda from a decision of the Regional Trial Court of Cebu City holding them liable in damages to their neighbors, spouses Medardo and Jocelyn Delfino, after a fire that began in the Nacorda house gutted the Delfino house and six other homes. The Delfinos sued for damages on the theory of negligence, and the Nacordas defended on denial and on the theory of fortuitous event. The case matters because it is a clean teaching vehicle on three things a Bar candidate must command: the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur as a rule of evidence in quasi-delict, the requisites of a fortuitous event, and the strict requirements for awarding temperate damages and attorney's fees.
Procedural History
The Delfinos filed a complaint for damages before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 7, Cebu City. After trial, the court rendered its decision on September 23, 2011, finding the Nacordas negligent and applying the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur. It awarded the Delfinos 100,000 pesos as temperate damages, 50,000 pesos as attorney's fees, and the costs. The Nacordas appealed, assigning as errors the finding of negligence and the awards of temperate damages and attorney's fees. The appeal was elevated to the Supreme Court, which resolved it through the decision we now brief.
Facts
On January 24, 2007, a fire broke out at Lower Yati, Sabellano Street, Quiot, Pardo, Cebu City. It gutted the house of the Nacordas, the house of the Delfinos, and six other homes. The Delfinos claimed the fire started in the room of the Nacordas' son and was caused by an unplugged electric flat iron, and they put their damage at 300,000 pesos, the original cost of building their house, aside from moral damages and attorney's fees. The Nacordas maintained that the fire was purely an accident and denied that a flat iron was in their house, saying their iron was out for repair.
At trial, Jocelyn Delfino testified that the fire started in the Nacorda house and was caused by an unplugged electric flat iron, a fact she said she learned from the Nacordas' helper, Jason, and from newspaper articles. The Delfinos submitted the newspaper articles and presented the writers who identified them. They also presented fire investigator Frank Donoso as a rebuttal witness, who admitted he had no forensic evidence and did not physically investigate the debris.
For the defense, Liza Nacorda and the helper Jason Diopelo testified. Liza denied that the fire came from an unplugged iron, narrated that when she came out of the bathroom her son Pluto's room was already on fire, and denied that she was interviewed by reporters. The trial court found the Delfinos' evidence hearsay but still held the Nacordas negligent under res ipsa loquitur, awarding temperate damages and attorney's fees.
Issues
- Whether or not the proximate cause of the fire was the negligence of the Nacordas or their employees.
- Whether or not the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur may be applied in this case.
- Whether or not the award of temperate damages was proper.
- Whether or not the award of attorney's fees was proper.
Applicable Provisions
Article 2224 of the Civil Code provides:
Temperate damages must be reasonable under the circumstances and may be recovered when the court finds that some pecuniary loss has been suffered but its amount cannot, from the nature of the case, be proved with certainty.
This is the basis for the award of temperate damages in lieu of actual damages that the Delfinos could not prove with certainty.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the Nacordas' negligence was the proximate cause of the fire. It affirmed that the Delfinos' evidence was hearsay, since Jocelyn Delfino had no personal knowledge and newspaper articles are hearsay twice removed, admissible only to prove that the publication exists. Yet the Court held that the negligence of the Nacordas or their employees was the proximate cause of the fire.
On the second issue, the Court held that res ipsa loquitur applied. It laid down the three requisites: the accident was of a kind that does not ordinarily occur unless someone is negligent; the instrumentality which caused the injury was under the exclusive control of the person charged with negligence; and the injury was not due to any voluntary action or contribution of the injured person. The Court reasoned that a house or a room will not ordinarily be caught on fire by itself, and that the occurrence would not happen in the ordinary course of things if those in control used proper care. The presumption of negligence thus arose, and the Nacordas failed to rebut it. The Court also rejected the fortuitous event defense, since the Nacordas failed to prove that the cause of the occurrence was independent of human will, their negligence being a human factor.
On the third issue, the Court affirmed the award of 100,000 pesos as temperate damages, since the Delfinos suffered pecuniary loss but could not prove its exact amount with certainty, and imposed legal interest at six percent per annum from finality of judgment until fully paid.
On the fourth issue, the Court agreed with the Nacordas and deleted the award of attorney's fees, because the trial court stated no factual or legal basis for it in the body of its decision. The Court held that the trial court must state the factual, legal, or equitable justification for the award, and that attorney's fees cannot be mentioned only in the dispositive portion.
Doctrine
First, in quasi-delict the burden of proof is on the plaintiff to establish that the proximate cause of the injury was the defendant's negligence; but under res ipsa loquitur, a rule of evidence peculiar to the law of negligence, prima facie negligence may be established without direct proof, and the burden of evidence shifts to the defendant to show that due care was observed. Second, the doctrine applies where the thing which caused the injury, without fault of the injured person, is under the exclusive control of the defendant, and the injury is such as in the ordinary course of things does not occur if proper care was used. Third, a fortuitous event requires that the cause of the occurrence be independent of human will, and negligence defeats the defense. Fourth, temperate damages under Article 2224 may be recovered when pecuniary loss is suffered but its amount cannot be proved with certainty. Fifth, attorney's fees are the exception rather than the general rule and must be justified in the body of the decision.
Disposition
The appeal was denied; the trial court's decision was affirmed with modification, deleting the award of attorney's fees and imposing legal interest at six percent per annum on the 100,000 pesos temperate damages from finality of judgment until fully paid.
Remember This
Memorize the three requisites of res ipsa loquitur and the rule that a house will not ordinarily catch fire by itself, so the presumption of negligence shifts the burden of evidence to the one in control. Examiners use this case to test res ipsa loquitur in quasi-delict, the fortuitous event defense, and the requirement that attorney's fees be justified in the body of the decision.