TERESA ELORIAGA ADOLFO, PETITIONER, VS. JOVITA EMPESTAN, FELIPE EMPESTAN AND BENJAMIN ELUMBA, RESPONDENTS
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Adolfo versus Empestan
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Teresa Eloriaga Adolfo against Jovita Empestan, Felipe Empestan, and Benjamin Elumba, arising from a complaint for recovery of ownership and possession and annulment of tax declaration and transfer certificate of title over four parcels of land in Igbaras, Iloilo. The petitioner lost before the Municipal Circuit Trial Court and won nothing before the Regional Trial Court, which annulled the trial court's decision for lack of jurisdiction. The case matters because it fixes the test for jurisdiction over real actions: the assessed value of the property must be alleged in the complaint, and the failure to allege it is fatal to the action.
Procedural History
The petitioner filed a complaint for recovery of ownership and possession and annulment of tax declaration and transfer certificate of title before the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Guimbal, Iloilo. On May 4, 2007, that court ruled in her favor, cancelled the tax declarations and certificates of title in the respondents' names, ordered them to vacate and deliver possession, and awarded attorney's fees, exemplary damages, and costs.
The respondents appealed to the Regional Trial Court. On March 28, 2008, the Regional Trial Court issued an order annulling and setting aside the decision of the Municipal Circuit Trial Court for lack of jurisdiction, holding that the case was one incapable of pecuniary estimation and therefore within its own exclusive jurisdiction. The petitioner's motion for reconsideration was denied on June 13, 2008.
The petitioner then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 42 of the Rules of Court, although styled as a petition for review on certiorari, assigning as error the annulment of the trial court's decision on the ground of lack of jurisdiction.
Facts
The petitioner is the granddaughter of the late Simeon Eloriaga, who during his lifetime was the declared owner of four parcels of land in Igbaras, Iloilo. Simeon died in 1932 and was succeeded by his two sons, Pedro and Francisco. Pedro died without issue, leaving Francisco as the sole heir of Simeon.
Upon the death of her parents, the petitioner and her husband were approached by Salvador Empestan, who asked to administer the four lots. The petitioner agreed on condition that Salvador pay the real estate taxes and give her ten percent of his harvest. Salvador died on November 11, 1983, and his wife, respondent Jovita Empestan, took over as administrator and commissioned respondent Felipe Empestan to cultivate the lands.
In 1996, Jovita failed to deliver the petitioner's ten percent share. The petitioner visited the lands and demanded their return, but Jovita's daughter Yolanda replied that they could no longer recover the lots because these were already owned by the respondents. The petitioner then discovered that Salvador had managed to have three lots declared under his name, and that another lot was now declared in the name of Benjamin Elumba. The respondents denied acting as administrators and claimed that two lots were sold to them by the petitioner under a deed of absolute sale that could no longer be produced because it had been eaten by termites, that one lot was acquired from a certain Alfredo Espanola, and that Jovita inherited the property from her parents.
Issues
- Whether or not the Municipal Circuit Trial Court or the Regional Trial Court has jurisdiction to take cognizance of the case.
Applicable Provisions
Section 33 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended by Republic Act No. 7691, provides:
Section 33. Jurisdiction of Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts and Municipal Circuit Trial Courts in Civil Cases. — Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts, and Municipal Circuit Trial Courts shall exercise: x x x (3) Exclusive original jurisdiction in all civil actions which involve title to, or possession of, real property, or any interest therein where the assessed value of the property or interest therein does not exceed Twenty Thousand Pesos (P20,000.00) or, in civil actions in Metro Manila, where such assessed value does not exceed Fifty Thousand Pesos (P50,000.00) exclusive of interest, damages of whatever kind, attorney's fees, litigation expenses and costs: Provided, That in cases of land not declared for taxation purposes, the value of such property shall be determined by the assessed value of the adjacent lots.
This provision fixes the jurisdictional threshold for first level courts in real actions, measured by the assessed value of the property.
Section 19 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended, provides:
Section 19. Jurisdiction in Civil Cases. — Regional Trial Courts shall exercise exclusive original jurisdiction: x x x (2) In all civil actions which involve the title to, or possession of, real property, or any interest therein, where the assessed value of the property involved exceeds twenty thousand pesos (P20,000.00) or for civil actions in Metro Manila, where such value exceeds Fifty thousand pesos (P50,000.00) except actions for forcible entry into and unlawful detainer of lands or buildings, original jurisdiction over which is conferred upon the Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts, and Municipal Circuit Trial Courts.
This provision gives the Regional Trial Courts jurisdiction over real actions only where the assessed value exceeds the threshold.
Section 1 of Rule 4 of the Rules of Court provides:
Section 1. Venue of real actions. — Actions affecting title to or possession of real property, or interest therein, shall be commenced and tried in the proper court which has jurisdiction over the area wherein the real property involved, or a portion thereof, is situated.
This provision confirms that an action affecting title to or possession of real property is a real action.
Ruling
The Court denied the petition. It first held that what determines the nature of the action and which court has jurisdiction are the allegations of the complaint and the character of the relief sought. The respondents' argument rested on the 2002 case of Copioso against Copioso, but the Court declared that ruling no longer controlling, having been superseded by the case of Heirs of Generoso Sebe against Heirs of Veronico Sevilla.
Based on the allegations and the reliefs prayed for, the Court found the controversy to be a real action, since the petitioner sought the cancellation of the tax declarations and certificates of title, the delivery of possession, and damages. The Court distinguished title from a certificate of title, explaining that while title is the claim, right, or interest in real property, a certificate of title is merely the evidence of such claim, and its issuance does not give the owner any better title than what he actually has in law.
Since the action involved title to and possession of real property, jurisdiction depended on the assessed value of the property. But the Court found that the complaint was bereft of any assertion of the assessed values of the subject properties. Relying on Quinagoran against Court of Appeals and Heirs of Jose Fernando against Reynaldo De Belen, the Court held that a complaint must allege the assessed value of the real property to determine which court has jurisdiction. The attached annexes to the complaint could not cure the defect, because they were meant only to describe the lots and were never alleged to show assessed values. The Court concluded that neither the Municipal Circuit Trial Court nor the Regional Trial Court acquired jurisdiction, and the petitioner's failure to allege the assessed values proved fatal to her cause.
Doctrine
The nature of the action and the court with jurisdiction over it are determined by the material allegations of the complaint, the relief prayed for, and the law in effect when the action is filed. An action affecting title to or possession of real property, or any interest therein, is a real action. In a real action, jurisdiction is determined by the assessed value of the property, as fixed by Section 33 and Section 19 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended by Republic Act No. 7691. The complaint must allege the assessed value of the property; absent such allegation, neither the first level court nor the Regional Trial Court acquires jurisdiction, and the complaint is vulnerable to dismissal.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition for lack of merit, leaving the Regional Trial Court's order annulling the trial court's decision undisturbed, so that neither court was held to have acquired jurisdiction over the petitioner's complaint.
Remember This
Memorize this line: in a real action, the assessed value of the property must be alleged in the complaint, and its omission is a jurisdictional defect that no annex can cure. Examiners use this case to test the real action rule, the assessed value requirement, and the distinction between title and a certificate of title.