🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CORAZON B. JOSON, COMPLAINANT, VS. STENOGRAPHER III RUTH A. MACAPAGAL AND STENOGRAPHER III TERESITA C. BURKLEY, RESPONDENTS.

A.M. No. P-02-1591 (Formerly A.M. No. IPI-00-871-P). June 21, 2002 June 21, 2002

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Joson versus Macapagal

The Case

This is an administrative case filed by Corazon B. Joson against Ruth A. Macapagal and Teresita C. Burkley, both Stenographer III at the Regional Trial Court in Cabanatuan City, for conduct unbecoming of government employees. The complainant is a private individual who entrusted her documents to the respondents; the respondents are court personnel whose conduct in their private dealings became the subject of the complaint. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct demanded of everyone connected with an office charged with the dispensation of justice, and because it shows how the Supreme Court treats the private dealings of judicial employees when those dealings betray the trust of the public.

Procedural History

The complaint began as a letter-complaint received by the Office of the Chief Justice. It was referred to the Office of the Court Administrator, which investigated the matter and recommended that both respondents be reprimanded and warned that the commission of the same or similar act would be dealt with more severely. The case then reached the Supreme Court as an administrative matter, and the Court rendered its decision, agreeing with the findings of the Office of the Court Administrator.

Facts

Sometime in 1995, Corazon Joson obtained a housing loan from the Government Service Insurance System for the purchase of a house and lot in Villa Emilia Subdivision, Cabanatuan City. Due to financial difficulties, she could not meet her monthly amortizations. On 2 May 1996, she decided to transfer her rights over the property to Noemi V. Alomia, the sister of respondent Macapagal. The signing of the documents was witnessed by Macapagal herself, by respondent Burkley, and by a certain Elma Ramos.

After the signing, Macapagal volunteered to have the documents notarized in her office for free and to submit them to the Government Service Insurance System in Cabanatuan City for processing. Having developed trust in Macapagal, Joson delivered her copies of the documents to her. On 19 January 2000, Joson was surprised to receive a letter from the Government Service Insurance System reminding her of her accountabilities and warning that the monthly amortizations would be deducted from her retirement benefits if she failed to pay. She immediately went to the house of Macapagal to inquire about the status of the documents, and it was only then that she found out that Macapagal had never endorsed the papers to the Government Service Insurance System. Instead, the property had been sold to Carmelita Cabigas, the sister of respondent Burkley. In the new set of documents, the name of Noemi V. Alomia was erased and the name of Carmelita Cabigas was superimposed in its place. Joson also learned that Cabigas and her family had been staying in the premises for quite some time without paying a single centavo to the Government Service Insurance System.

Macapagal admitted that her sister Alomia bought the rights for 16,000 pesos and that after the signing, Joson delivered the keys to Alomia. Alomia later went back to Dubai, where she was working, and informed her sister that she was no longer interested in buying the property, instructing her to look for a new buyer. Macapagal offered the property to Cabigas, who paid her 25,000 pesos upon her arrival from abroad in December 1997, after which Macapagal turned over the keys to Cabigas. Macapagal claimed that the new documents were notarized before Atty. Jose Manuel Calderon on 12 January 1999, with Joson present, and that the erasures were made with the knowledge and consent of Joson. Burkley denied forging the signature of her sister Cabigas and insisted that Cabigas was in the Philippines in December 1997 for the signing. During the pendency of the case, Burkley manifested that Cabigas was willing to pay the amortizations in arrears and all future monthly amortizations.

Issues

  • Whether or not respondents Macapagal and Burkley are guilty of conduct unbecoming of government employees.
  • Whether or not the acts of the respondents in their dealings with the complainant warrant the imposition of administrative sanctions.

Applicable Provisions

The decision does not quote a specific statutory provision. It applies the settled standard of conduct for court personnel, which the Court states as follows:

The conduct and behavior of every one connected with an office charged with the dispensation of justice, from the presiding judge to the lowliest clerk, should be circumscribed with the heavy burden of responsibility.

This standard bears on the case because the respondents, as stenographers of the Regional Trial Court, are covered by it even in their personal and private dealings with other people.

The Court also states the duty of a court employee as a public servant:

A court employee, being a public servant, must exhibit the highest sense of honesty and integrity not only in the performance of his official duties but in his personal and private dealings with other people, to preserve the court's good name and standing.

This bears on the case because the respondents' dealings with the complainant were precisely private dealings, and the Court measured them against this duty.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court agreed with the Office of the Court Administrator that the respondents are guilty of committing acts unbecoming of government employees. After the signing of the documents on 2 May 1996, Macapagal never caused their notarization nor endorsed them to the developer and the Government Service Insurance System as promised. She did not give Joson her copy of the signed documents. Instead, she held on to the documents after their signing and even after conveying the property to Cabigas. Consequently, and unknown to Joson, the property remained in her name. The Court found that Macapagal reconveyed the property to Cabigas without first informing Joson, in an act tainted with malice and bad faith, and that she informed Joson of Alomia's withdrawal only after Joson went to her house upon receipt of the demand letter.

The Court refused to lend credence to the claim that the documents were submitted to the developer and the Government Service Insurance System, because had they been submitted, the transfer in the name of Alomia would have been caused even before the reconveyance to Cabigas. It found it hardly credible that a new set of documents would be signed between Joson and Cabigas when there was already a valid transfer of rights between Joson and Alomia, and it noted that Macapagal presented no power of attorney from Alomia authorizing her to cancel the original contract. The Court also found it improbable that the developer had run out of forms, since these are basic forms for a realty business, and observed that the respondents, being court stenographers, could have easily reproduced those forms by retyping them. These circumstances bolstered the Court's suspicion that the respondents erased the name of Noemi V. Alomia and superimposed the name of Carmelita Cabigas. The Court likewise found it implausible that Joson would voluntarily succumb a second time to the same ploy, and this strengthened its belief that the second transfer was done without her prior knowledge and consent.

On the second issue, the Court held that the belated letters of Cabigas and her husband to the Government Service Insurance System, asserting their intention to assume the outstanding obligations, indicated that they tacitly admitted being remiss in the performance of their obligations. Nonetheless, this did not obliterate the fact that the respondents committed acts prejudicial to the interests of Joson; at most, it served only to mitigate the penalty to be imposed upon them.

Doctrine

A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, the conduct and behavior of every one connected with an office charged with the dispensation of justice, from the presiding judge to the lowliest clerk, is circumscribed with the heavy burden of responsibility, and the strictest standard of honesty and integrity in the public service is required of those involved in the administration of justice. Second, a court employee, being a public servant, must exhibit the highest sense of honesty and integrity not only in the performance of official duties but in personal and private dealings with other people, to preserve the court's good name and standing. Third, every employee of the judiciary should be an example of integrity, uprightness, and honesty. These rules are tied to the standard quoted above, which governs the respondents even in their private transactions, and a violation of that standard constitutes conduct unbecoming of a government employee.

Disposition

The Court found the respondents guilty of committing acts unbecoming of government employees and reprimanded both of them, with a stern warning that the commission of the same or similar act would be dealt with more severely.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that a court employee must exhibit the highest sense of honesty and integrity not only in the performance of official duties but in personal and private dealings with other people. Examiners like to use this case to test the administrative liability of judicial employees for private dealings that tarnish the good name of the judiciary, and to test the distinction between conduct unbecoming of a government employee and the mitigating effect of subsequent acts of reparation.