PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, V. RONNIE BOY NIÑO Y PASION, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Niño
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against Ronnie Boy Niño y Pasion, a criminal case in which the accused was convicted by the trial court and then brought his conviction up on appeal to the Supreme Court. What makes the case worth our time is not any disputed question of criminal liability, but a procedural turn: the accused himself, through counsel, asked to take back the very appeal he had filed. The Court's brief resolution is therefore a compact lesson on the withdrawal of an appeal in a criminal case, and on what happens to the judgment of conviction once that withdrawal is granted.
Procedural History
The accused was convicted by the Regional Trial Court, Branch 68, Camiling, Tarlac, and from that judgment he filed an appeal before the Supreme Court. While the appeal was pending, the accused filed an urgent motion to withdraw appeal, praying that the appeal be considered withdrawn. The Supreme Court issued a resolution directing the Public Attorney's Office, as counsel for the accused, to file a comment on the motion within ten days from notice. Counsel filed its comment, stating that after exerting efforts to confer with the accused and after explaining to him the legal implications of his intended withdrawal, the accused had reiterated his intention not to appeal his case, and that counsel interposed no objection to the withdrawal. The Court then resolved the motion.
Facts
The accused, Ronnie Boy Niño y Pasion, was prosecuted and convicted by the Regional Trial Court, Branch 68, Camiling, Tarlac. Aggrieved, he filed an appeal with the Supreme Court, which was docketed and remained pending before the Court.
While the appeal was pending, the accused changed course. He filed an urgent motion to withdraw appeal, asking in terms that the appeal at bench be considered withdrawn, and that his appeal from the judgment of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 68, Camiling, Tarlac, be withdrawn.
The Court did not act on the motion at once. It directed the Public Attorney's Office, the accused's counsel, to comment within ten days from notice. Counsel complied and confirmed that it had exerted efforts to confer with the accused and had explained to him the legal implications of his intended withdrawal, and that the accused had reiterated his intention not to appeal his case. Counsel accordingly interposed no objection to the withdrawal.
Issues
- Whether or not the accused may withdraw the appeal he himself filed before the Supreme Court while that appeal remains pending.
- Whether or not the withdrawal of the appeal should be granted where both the accused and his counsel of record pray for it.
- Whether or not the grant of the withdrawal renders the case closed and terminated, leaving the judgment of conviction to stand.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote any statute or rule. It rests entirely on the accused's own motion and on the comment of his counsel. The operative language of the motion, as reproduced in the resolution, reads:
The undersigned accused appellant/s in the above-entitled case, unto this Honorable Court, most respectfully move/s to withdraw his/her appeal from the judgment of the Regional Trial Court Branch 68, Camiling, Tarlac.
That prayer is the act of the accused himself, and it is what the Court grants.
The comment of the Public Attorney's Office, likewise reproduced, states the basis for counsel's conformity:
After exerting efforts to confer with the accused-appellant and after explaining the legal implications of his intended withdrawal of appeal, the latter has reiterated his intention not to appeal his case.
This shows that the withdrawal was the accused's informed and reiterated choice, not a mere technical lapse by counsel.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the accused may withdraw his appeal. The appeal is his own remedy, and he may relinquish it while it remains pending before the Court. The Court acted on his urgent motion precisely because the motion was his own prayer.
On the second issue, the Court granted the withdrawal because both the accused and his counsel sought it. The Court reasoned in these words:
Given that both accused-appellant and his counsel sought the withdrawal of the very Appeal that accused-appellant filed, then the withdrawal of accused-appellant's Appeal is justified.
The concurrence of the accused and his counsel removed any doubt about the voluntariness of the step, especially since counsel had conferred with the accused and explained the legal implications before reiterating the accused's intention not to appeal.
On the third issue, the Court treated the withdrawal as the end of the litigation. With the appeal withdrawn, there was nothing left for the Court to review, and the judgment of conviction stood. The Court accordingly deemed the case closed and terminated.
Doctrine
An accused who has appealed a judgment of conviction may withdraw that appeal while it is pending before the Supreme Court. The appeal is the accused's own remedy, and the Court will honor a clear and reiterated intention to abandon it.
A withdrawal of appeal is justified where both the accused and his counsel of record seek it. Counsel's comment should show that the accused was conferred with and that the legal implications of the withdrawal were explained to him, so that the withdrawal appears informed and voluntary.
Once the withdrawal is granted, the appeal is considered withdrawn and the case is deemed closed and terminated. The judgment of conviction of the trial court then stands, because the appellate court has been asked, and has agreed, not to review it.
Disposition
The Court granted the accused's prayer, considered his appeal withdrawn, and deemed the case closed and terminated, leaving his conviction by the Regional Trial Court, Branch 68, Camiling, Tarlac, to stand.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: where both the accused and his counsel seek the withdrawal of the very appeal the accused filed, the withdrawal is justified, and the case is deemed closed and terminated. Examiners use this case to test the withdrawal of appeals in criminal cases and the finality that follows when an accused abandons his own appeal.