🎧 Case Brief Lecture

FELIPE ALIDO, PETITIONER, V. GARRY C. DOMINGO, RODULFO DIMAISIP, AND MAMERTO VILLANUEVA, RESPONDENTS.

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Alido versus Domingo

The Case

This is Alido versus Domingo, a petition for mandamus brought by Felipe Alido against Garry Domingo, Rodulfo Dimaisip, and Mamerto Villanueva, who sit as officers of the Business Permits and Licensing Office of Quezon City. Alido asked the Court to compel these public officers to cancel or revoke the business permit of a restaurant that he says failed to honor the discounts and privileges owed to senior citizens under the Expanded Senior Citizen Act of 2003. The case matters because it draws the line every bar candidate must know: mandamus reaches only a ministerial duty, never a discretionary one. It is the cleanest illustration of why a statutory power to cancel a permit, exercised only after notice and hearing, cannot be commanded by a writ of mandamus.

Procedural History

The case began in the Supreme Court itself. Alido filed a petition for mandamus under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court directly against the licensing officers, seeking two things: an order compelling them to cause the cancellation or revocation of the business permit, franchise, and other privileges of Kowloon House Restaurant, and an award of damages and costs in his favor. There was no trial court and no intermediate appellate ruling, because the action was an original petition invoking the Court's power to command a public officer. The Court, through the division that heard it, resolved the petition on the threshold question of whether mandamus was the proper remedy at all, and dismissed it.

Facts

Felipe Alido believed that a business establishment, Kowloon House Restaurant on Matalino Street in Central Diliman, Quezon City, had failed to abide by the provisions of the Expanded Senior Citizen Act of 2003. That law grants senior citizens certain privileges, and it also arms the proper authorities with a remedy against establishments that do not comply.

Rather than file an appropriate complaint before the licensing office, Alido went straight to the Supreme Court. He filed a petition for mandamus against the officers of the Business Permits and Licensing Office of Quezon City, asking the Court to order them to cancel or revoke the restaurant's business permit, its permit to operate, its franchise, and similar privileges. He also asked for damages and the cost of suit.

The respondents had not yet acted on any complaint. No notice had been issued and no hearing had been held. The question therefore became whether the Court could compel them to impose the penalty of cancellation at all, or whether the decision to do so belonged to them in the first place.

Issues

  • Whether or not a petition for mandamus under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court is the proper remedy to compel the Business Permits and Licensing Office to cancel or revoke the business permit of an establishment that allegedly violated the Expanded Senior Citizen Act of 2003.
  • Whether or not the duty to cancel or revoke a business permit under Section 10 of Republic Act Number 9257 is a ministerial act that mandamus may command, or a discretionary act that mandamus cannot touch.

Applicable Provisions

Section 10 of Republic Act Number 9257, the Expanded Senior Citizen Act of 2003, provides:

SEC. 10. Penalties. – Any person who violates any provision of this Act shall suffer the following penalties: xxx Upon filling an appropriate complaint, and after due notice and hearing, the proper authorities may also cause the cancellation or revocation of the business permit, permit to operate, franchise and other similar privileges granted to any business entity that fails to abide by the provisions of this Act.

This is the provision Alido invoked, and it defeats him: the word "may," conditioned on an appropriate complaint and due notice and hearing, gives the authorities the right to decide whether to cancel, which makes the act discretionary and beyond mandamus.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the petition was dismissible at the outset for being an improper remedy. Mandamus under Rule 65 lies only to compel a ministerial act, and the acts Alido sought to compel were not of that kind.

On the second issue, the Court held that the duty to cancel or revoke a business permit under Section 10 of Republic Act Number 9257 is discretionary, not ministerial. The Court reasoned that the provision gives the respondents the right to decide whether or not to impose the penalty of cancellation or revocation, and only after due notice and hearing. Because the officers are given the right to decide whether to perform the duty, the duty is discretionary. The Court quoted its own teaching from Philippine Coconut Authority versus Primex Coco Products, Incorporated:

Mandamus lies to compel the performance, when refused, of a ministerial duty, but not to compel the performance of a discretionary duty. A purely ministerial act or duty is one which an officer or tribunal performs in a given state of facts, in a prescribed manner, in obedience to the mandate of a legal authority, without regard to or the exercise of his own judgment upon the propriety or impropriety of the act done. The duty is ministerial only when the discharge of the same requires neither the exercise of official discretion or judgment. When an official is required and authorized to do a prescribed act upon a prescribed contingency, his functions are ministerial only, and mandamus may be issued to control his action upon the happening of the contingency. For a writ of mandamus to be issued, it is essential that petitioner should have a clear legal right to the thing demanded and it must be the imperative duty of the respondent to perform the act required. The writ neither confers powers nor imposes duties. It is simply a command to exercise a power already possessed and to perform a duty already imposed. Mandamus applies as a remedy only where petitioner's right is founded clearly in law and not when it is doubtful. The writ will not be granted where its issuance would be unavailing, nugatory, or useless. If the law imposes a duty upon a public officer and gives him the right to decide how or when the duty shall be performed, such duty is discretionary and not ministerial.

The Court also defined a ministerial act as one which an officer or tribunal performs in a given state of facts, in a prescribed manner, in obedience to the mandate of legal authority, without regard to or the exercise of his own judgment upon the propriety or impropriety of the act done. Measured against that definition, the cancellation of a permit after notice and hearing plainly requires judgment, and so mandamus will not lie.

Doctrine

Mandamus lies to compel the performance, when refused, of a ministerial duty, but not to compel the performance of a discretionary duty. A duty is ministerial only when its discharge requires neither the exercise of official discretion nor judgment. Where the law imposes a duty upon a public officer and gives that officer the right to decide how or when the duty shall be performed, the duty is discretionary and not ministerial.

Section 10 of Republic Act Number 9257 uses permissive language. It provides that, upon filing an appropriate complaint and after due notice and hearing, the proper authorities may cause the cancellation or revocation of the business permit. That power to decide whether or not to impose the penalty is the hallmark of discretion, and it places the act beyond the reach of mandamus.

For a writ of mandamus to issue, the petitioner must have a clear legal right to the thing demanded, and it must be the imperative duty of the respondent to perform the act required. The writ neither confers powers nor imposes duties; it is simply a command to exercise a power already possessed and to perform a duty already imposed. It will not be granted where its issuance would be unavailing, nugatory, or useless.

Disposition

The Supreme Court dismissed the petition for mandamus, and the respondents prevailed.

Remember This

Memorize the line: if the law gives the officer the right to decide how or when the duty shall be performed, the duty is discretionary and mandamus will not lie. Examiners use this case to test the ministerial versus discretionary distinction, and to see whether you can spot that the word "may" in a penal or licensing provision, coupled with notice and hearing, signals discretion rather than command.