🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MARITONI M. NIEVA, COMPLAINANT, VS. SATURNINA ALVAREZ-EDAD, BRANCH CLERK OF COURT, METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 32, QUEZON CITY, RESPONDENT.

A.M. NO. P-01-1459. January 31, 2005 January 31, 2005

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Nieva versus Alvarez-Edad

The Case

This is an administrative complaint filed with the Supreme Court by Maritoni Nieva, a former legal researcher of the Metropolitan Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 32, against Saturnina Alvarez-Edad, the Branch Clerk of Court of the same branch. Nieva charged her with falsification of daily time records, dishonesty, demanding and receiving a commissioner's fee for the reception of evidence ex parte, conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service, issuing certified true copies of warrants of arrest without payment of fees, and discourtesy in the conduct of official business. The case matters because it fixes the rule that a branch clerk of court, being a court employee, may never demand or receive a commissioner's fee for receiving evidence ex parte, and it shows how the Court classifies and penalizes that offense.

Procedural History

The complaint was filed with the Supreme Court, which referred it to the Executive Judge of the Metropolitan Trial Court of Quezon City for investigation, report, and recommendation. The investigating judge exonerated the respondent on all charges except dishonesty, finding that she demanded a commissioner's fee and received money in the guise of payment for stenographic notes, and recommended suspension for one year without pay with disqualification from promotion and salary increase. The Court then referred that report to the Office of the Court Administrator for evaluation. The Deputy Court Administrator recommended exoneration on the other charges but disagreed that the act was dishonesty, treating it instead as a violation of the Manual for Clerks of Court, and recommended a fine of 1,000 pesos with severe reprimand. The Court sustained the evaluation but rejected the recommended penalty as too light, and resolved the case by its own Resolution.

Facts

Nieva alleged that the respondent's daily time records did not match the entries in the office logbook on several dates in 1998, and that the respondent harassed her and a stenographer by marking her half day, prematurely closing the logbook, and issuing a memorandum demanding an explanation. She also alleged that the respondent allowed a celebrity accused to post bail without personal appearance, and issued certified true copies of warrants of arrest without collecting the corresponding fees.

The central charge concerned a hearing in an ex parte proceeding held in July 1998. The respondent demanded 1,500 pesos as a commissioner's fee from a messenger of a litigant. When he tried to hand her 500 pesos, she rejected it because she expected the full amount, and in the presence of other employees she shouted that what she was asking for was legal while the litigant's business was illegal for charging high interest, and she threatened to delay the case. She eventually received 500 pesos, and upon her instruction a stenographer prepared a receipt describing the amount as payment for stenographic notes. The respondent signed the receipt, kept 300 pesos for herself, and gave only 200 pesos to the stenographer.

In her comment, the respondent denied all the charges and submitted her own records. The investigating judge found that she had demanded the commissioner's fee and received the 500 pesos in the guise of payment for stenographic notes, keeping 300 pesos without the stenographer's consent. The Office of the Court Administrator agreed that she collected a commissioner's fee, but found no intent to gain because she shared part of the amount with the stenographer under an existing arrangement, and it recommended a fine and severe reprimand.

Issues

  • Whether or not the respondent is administratively liable for demanding and receiving a commissioner's fee for the reception of evidence ex parte.
  • Whether or not the respondent's act constitutes dishonesty, or simple misconduct classified as a less grave offense.
  • Whether or not the penalty recommended by the Office of the Court Administrator is the correct penalty under the facts.

Applicable Provisions

Section B, Chapter II of the Manual for Clerks of Court provides:

No Branch Clerk of Court shall demand and or receive commissioner's fees for the reception of evidence ex parte.

This is the very rule the respondent violated, and it is the basis of her liability.

Section D, paragraph 7, Chapter IV of the same Manual provides:

The Court shall allow the commissioner, other than an employee of the court, such reasonable compensation as the circumstances of the case warrant to be taxed as costs against the defeated party, or apportioned, as justice requires.

This shows that only a commissioner who is not an employee of the court may receive compensation, so the respondent, a court employee, had no authority to collect any fee.

Section 52, Rule IV of the Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service provides:

Administrative offenses with corresponding penalties are classified into grave, less grave or light, depending on their gravity or depravity and effects on the government service.

Under the same section, simple misconduct is a less grave offense punishable on first offense by suspension of one month and one day to six months. This classification governs the penalty the Court imposed.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held the respondent liable. The records convincingly showed that she demanded and received a commissioner's fee from a litigant in an ex parte proceeding, which violates Section B, Chapter II of the Manual for Clerks of Court. The Court stressed that clerks of court are important officers in the judicial system, that their office is the hub of adjudicative and administrative orders, and that they must be persons of competence, honesty, and probity. It held that a commissioner must not be an employee of the court to be entitled to reasonable compensation, and that the respondent, as a court employee, had no authority to demand or receive any commissioner's fee.

On the second issue, the Court agreed with the Office of the Court Administrator that the act was not dishonesty, since the intent to gain was absent, but held that the transgression constitutes simple misconduct, a less grave offense under Section 52, Rule IV of the Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service.

On the third issue, the Court rejected the recommended fine of 1,000 pesos and severe reprimand as too light. It held that for simple misconduct on first offense, the penalty is suspension, and imposed suspension for two months without pay.

Doctrine

A branch clerk of court, being an employee of the court, may not demand or receive a commissioner's fee for the reception of evidence ex parte. Only a commissioner who is not an employee of the court may be allowed reasonable compensation, to be taxed as costs. Demanding and collecting such a fee is not dishonesty where the intent to gain is absent, but it is simple misconduct, a less grave offense under the Revised Uniform Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service, punishable on first offense by suspension of one month and one day to six months. Court personnel must live up to the strictest standards of competence, honesty, and integrity, and their conduct must be above suspicion.

Disposition

The Court found the respondent guilty of demanding and receiving a commissioner's fee in violation of the Manual for Clerks of Court, suspended her for two months without pay, warned her that a repetition would be dealt with more severely, and ordered that a copy of the Resolution be attached to her service records.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that a branch clerk of court is a court employee and can never collect a commissioner's fee for receiving evidence ex parte. Examiners use this case to test the classification of the offense as simple misconduct and the rule that only a commissioner who is not a court employee may receive compensation.