EMMA MAXIMA T. DECLINES, PETITIONER, VS. HON. PRESIDING JUDGE, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT OF BAROTAC NUEVO AND BEATRIZ B. NADALA, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Declines versus Presiding Judge, Municipal Trial Court of Barotac Nuevo
The Case
This is Declines versus the Presiding Judge of the Municipal Trial Court of Barotac Nuevo and Nadala. The petitioner, Emma Maxima T. Declines, went straight to the Supreme Court by a petition for review under Rule 42, asking it to reverse a ruling of the municipal trial court, while her motion for reconsideration of that very ruling was still unresolved below. The case matters far less for the merits of the land dispute than for two procedural lessons every reviewee must carry: a petition for review filed before the trial court acts on a pending motion for reconsideration is premature, and a certification against forum shopping that conceals a pending motion is itself a ground for dismissal, distinct from forum shopping.
Procedural History
The case began in the Municipal Trial Court of Barotac Nuevo, which rendered a decision adverse to the petitioner. The petitioner moved for reconsideration of that decision on the first of October, 2014. Without waiting for the trial court to resolve her motion, she filed a petition for review directly with the Supreme Court, with a prayer for a temporary restraining order and a writ of preliminary injunction. The Supreme Court noted that the motion for reconsideration remained unresolved, that the docket and other legal fees paid were in excess of 850 pesos, and then resolved the petition itself.
Facts
The petitioner, Emma Maxima T. Declines, was a party in a case before the Municipal Trial Court of Barotac Nuevo, where the respondent Beatriz B. Nadala was the opposing party. The trial court ruled against the petitioner.
On the first of October, 2014, the petitioner filed a motion for reconsideration of that ruling. That motion had not yet been resolved by the trial court when the petitioner filed her petition for review with the Supreme Court.
In her petition, the petitioner signed and filed a certification against forum shopping, swearing that to the best of her knowledge no other action or proceeding was pending before the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals, or any other tribunal or agency. The records, however, showed that her motion for reconsideration was still pending with the trial court.
Issues
- Whether or not the petition for review was prematurely filed with the Supreme Court, the petitioner's motion for reconsideration in the trial court being still unresolved.
- Whether or not the petitioner violated her certification against forum shopping, and whether or not that violation warrants dismissal of the petition.
Applicable Provisions
Section 1 of Rule 42 of the Rules of Court provides:
Petition for Review shall be filed within fifteen (15) days from notice of decision sought to be reviewed or of the denial of petitioner's motion for new trial or reconsideration filed in due time after judgment.
This fixes the point from which the fifteen-day period runs, and it presupposes that the motion for reconsideration has already been acted upon, which is why a petition filed while the motion is pending is premature.
Section 5 of Rule 7 of the Rules of Court, the source of the certification the petitioner signed, provides:
to the best of her knowledge, no such action or proceeding is pending in the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals, or any other tribunal or agency; that if there is any such other action or proceeding which is either pending or may have been terminated, she shall state the status thereof.
This is the sworn undertaking the petitioner breached, because her pending motion for reconsideration was an action or proceeding she was bound to disclose.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition was premature. Section 1 of Rule 42 requires that the petition be filed within fifteen days from notice of the decision sought to be reviewed or of the denial of the petitioner's motion for reconsideration filed in due time after judgment. Without awaiting the trial court's resolution of her motion for reconsideration, the petitioner filed her petition directly with the Supreme Court. The Court stressed that the trial court must be given a chance to rectify such errors or mistakes it may have committed before resort to the Supreme Court can be had.
On the second issue, the Court held that the petitioner violated her certification against forum shopping. She was bound by her certification that to the best of her knowledge no other action or proceeding was pending in the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals, or any other tribunal or agency, and that if any such action or proceeding was pending or may have been terminated, she would state its status. The records were clear, however, that she had a pending motion for reconsideration with the trial court. The Court held that this violation of the certification against forum shopping is a ground for dismissal of an action, distinct from forum shopping itself.
Doctrine
First, under Section 1 of Rule 42, a petition for review is premature when filed while a motion for reconsideration of the judgment below is still pending before the trial court. The trial court must first be given the chance to correct itself.
Second, a certification against forum shopping under Section 5 of Rule 7 must truthfully disclose every pending action or proceeding, including a motion for reconsideration still awaiting resolution. A false certification is a ground for dismissal of the action, and that ground is distinct from forum shopping itself.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition for review and directed its Accounting Office to return to the petitioner the excess payment of docket and other legal fees amounting to 850 pesos.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a petition for review filed while a motion for reconsideration is still pending below is premature, and a certification against forum shopping that conceals that pending motion is a separate ground for dismissal. Examiners use this case to test the reckoning of the fifteen-day period under Rule 42 and the consequences of a false certification against forum shopping.