🎧 Case Brief Lecture

LICERIO P. NIQUE, PETITIONER, VS. PRISCILLA T. HERNANDEZ, CLERK OF COURT AND JOSE C. PENAS, DEPUTYSHERIFF OF RTC, BRANCH 16, TANGUB CITY, RESPONDENTS.

A.M. No. MTJ-94-965. April 02, 1996 April 2, 1996

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Nique versus Hernandez

The Case

This is an administrative complaint filed directly with the Supreme Court by Licerio P. Nique against Judge Priscilla T. Hernandez, then Clerk of Court and Ex-Officio Sheriff of the Regional Trial Court of Tangub City, and Jose C. Penas, Deputy Sheriff of Branch 16 of that court. The complainant charged both respondents with ignorance of the law, partisanship in the enforcement of a court order, dereliction of duty, and failure to account for a deposit of 1,000 pesos, all arising from the enforcement of a writ of preliminary injunction over a fishpond. The case matters because it fixes the working rules on delegation of writ service to deputy sheriffs, on the clerk of court's duty over legal fees, and on the evidentiary weight of a sheriff's Return of Service — matters examiners test in administrative law and in the law on sheriffs.

Procedural History

The complainant filed an affidavit-complaint dated May 22, 1993 directly with the Supreme Court. Because the Office of the Court Administrator saw factual issues that could not be resolved on the pleadings alone, the Court referred the case to then Acting Executive Judge Vicente T. Baz of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 14, Tangub City, for investigation, report, and recommendation. Judge Baz received testimonial and documentary evidence from the respondents; the complainant did not appear to cross-examine them despite due notice, so their statements stood uncontroverted. On the complainant's motion, his oral deposition was taken before Judge Narciso M. Bumanglag, Sr. of the Municipal Trial Courts in Cities, Branch 1, Davao City. The Investigating Judge recommended dismissal of all charges for lack of substantial evidence. The case then returned to the Supreme Court, which resolved it by this decision.

Facts

On August 16, 1991, Presiding Judge Vicente T. Baz, Jr. of Branch 16, Tangub City, issued a writ of preliminary injunction in a petition for certiorari filed by Nique. The writ concerned a fishpond in Baybay Sumirap. The complainant deposited 1,000 pesos as sheriff's expenses for its implementation.

Deputy Sheriff Penas served the writ. On March 3, 1992, he hired a private car and paid 200 pesos in a first attempt. The next day, with police escorts and on board a Philippine National Police vehicle, he turned over possession of the fishpond from Jimmy Chan, overseer of the private respondents, to Cesar Canones, the complainant's overseer and attorney-in-fact. Canones admitted being placed in possession, but refused to sign a receipt for the sacks of fish feeds, lime, and equipment, saying he was authorized to sign only for the fishpond. Penas submitted a Return of Service and an Itinerary of Travel approved by the presiding judge, itemizing the expenses. Later, a supersedeas bond of 200,000 pesos was filed by the other party to stay execution.

The complainant then charged that the writ was rendered worthless, that the clerk of court improperly delegated its service, and that the 1,000 pesos was not accounted for. In a reply, he added a charge of falsification of public document, because the Itinerary of Travel listed "Car Hire" for March 4, 1992, when a police car was used. Penas explained that the 200 pesos covered gasoline and repair of the police car, and a police escort corroborated his payment.

Issues

  • Whether or not the clerk of court, as ex-officio sheriff, may delegate the service and execution of writs to her deputy sheriff.
  • Whether or not the clerk of court may be held liable, under a theory of command responsibility, for the deputy sheriff's handling of the 1,000 peso deposit as sheriff's fees.
  • Whether or not Deputy Sheriff Penas faithfully discharged his ministerial duty to execute the writ of preliminary injunction.
  • Whether or not Deputy Sheriff Penas is guilty of falsification for entering "Car Hire" in his Itinerary of Travel.

Applicable Provisions

The Guidelines and Procedure in the Service and Execution of Court Writs and Processes, found in the Manual for Clerks of Court, provide:

All Clerks of Court, who are also ex-officio sheriffs, and/or their deputy sheriffs shall serve all court processes and execute all writs of their respective Courts within their territorial jurisdiction.

This is the provision that authorizes the delegation challenged by the complainant and defines the territorial reach of the sheriff's authority.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the delegation was not improper. As Clerk of Court of the Regional Trial Court of Tangub City, Judge Hernandez was an ex-officio sheriff within her territorial jurisdiction, and the Guidelines expressly allow clerks of court and their deputy sheriffs to serve processes and execute writs. The Court found no cogent reason to disturb the Investigating Judge's findings.

On the second issue, the Court acknowledged that the collection of legal fees is a delicate function of clerks of court as judicial officers entrusted with the correct implementation of the regulations. But the theory of command responsibility must fail, because Deputy Sheriff Penas accounted for the amount in his Itinerary of Travel, which contained an itemized list of expenses.

On the third issue, the Court was persuaded that possession of the fishpond was turned over to Canones. Canones himself admitted it in his affidavit, and the Return of Service deserved great evidentiary weight absent contrary evidence. The duty to execute the writ is purely ministerial, and the deputy sheriff was not remiss in it.

On the fourth issue, the Court found Penas's explanation satisfactory and substantially corroborated by a police escort who saw him pay 200 pesos for gasoline and repair of the police car. The Court reminded that sheriffs are officers of the court and agents of the law:

Sheriffs and Deputy Sheriffs are officers of the court, and considered agents of the law. They form an integral part of the administration of justice because they are called upon to serve court writs, execute all processes, and carry into effect the orders of the Court, as such, they should discharge their duties with due care and utmost diligence.

The Court was fully convinced the respondents had not failed in this regard.

Doctrine

First, a clerk of court who is an ex-officio sheriff may delegate the service of writs and processes to the deputy sheriffs, for the Guidelines expressly vest that function in the clerks and their deputies within their territorial jurisdiction. Second, the collection of legal fees is a delicate function of clerks of court as judicial officers, but a clerk cannot be held under command responsibility where the deputy sheriff renders an itemized accounting of the deposit. Third, the execution of a writ is a purely ministerial duty, and the sheriff's Return of Service is entitled to great evidentiary weight absent contrary evidence. Fourth, sheriffs are officers of the court and agents of the law who must discharge their duties with due care and utmost diligence.

Disposition

The complaint was dismissed for lack of merit, and both respondents, Judge Priscilla T. Hernandez and Deputy Sheriff Jose C. Penas, were exonerated from all charges.

Remember This

Memorize the line that the clerk of court as ex-officio sheriff may delegate writ service to the deputy sheriff, whose Return of Service carries great evidentiary weight. Examiners use this case on the ministerial duty of sheriffs, on the clerk's delicate function over legal fees, and on command responsibility in administrative complaints against court personnel.