CLEMENTE SY, COMPLAINANT, VS. JAIME B. YERRO, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Sy versus Yerro
The Case
This is an administrative case in which Clemente Sy, a tenant of the House International Building in Sta. Cruz, Manila and president of its tenants association, charged Jaime Yerro, a Records Officer of the Court of Appeals, with grave misconduct, usurpation of official function, and violation of the Civil Service Rules and Regulations. The complaint grew out of the enforcement of a writ of execution in an ejectment case, where the respondent was seen acting as though he were a sheriff of the trial court. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct demanded of every person connected with the dispensation of justice, and because it shows how dishonesty in the matter of leave, and unwarranted intervention in the proceedings of another court, are punished.
Procedural History
The affidavit-complaint was filed with the Supreme Court on January 7, 1994. In a Resolution dated January 18, 1995, the Court referred the complaint to the Clerk of Court of the Court of Appeals for investigation, report, and recommendation. The parties and their witnesses were heard before the investigating officer, who submitted her report on November 16, 1995, finding the respondent guilty as charged and recommending suspension for one year with a warning. The matter then came back to the Supreme Court, which rendered its own judgment on the report.
Facts
A third alias writ of execution dated November 22, 1993 was issued by the Regional Trial Court, Branch 16, Manila, in a civil case ordering the eviction of tenants at the House International Building at Ongpin Street, Sta. Cruz, Manila. The complainant was one of those tenants. On November 25, 1993, the respondent appeared at the building representing himself as a sheriff of the court that issued the writ, posted notices of the writ, and served copies on the tenants. In doing so, he allegedly kicked the doors of each unit, hurled invectives at the tenants, shouted at them, and threatened them with forcible closure of their units.
On December 2, 1993, the day of actual implementation, the complainant brought his lawyer, who saw Sheriff Abel Sta. Ana of the trial court and his team implementing the writ. They also saw the respondent harassing the tenants, giving orders, and acting like a team leader overseeing the eviction and the levying on their properties. When confronted, the respondent admitted he was an employee of the Court of Appeals but claimed he was on leave that day, and said he was the representative of the Manila Towers Development Corporation, a prevailing party, and a relative of its counsel. The events were witnessed by the sheriff and members of his team, including a patrolman of the Western Police District, a barangay captain, and a barangay secretary. Verification showed that the respondent was a regular employee of the Court of Appeals, that he was officially absent on November 25, 1993, and that he was on sick leave from December 2 to 3, 1993.
In his defense, the respondent denied the allegations and claimed that it was the complainant and his lawyer who harassed the sheriff and created scenes to forestall the eviction. He said he was merely waiting for the arrival of the corporation's counsel. To support his claim that he was at his office on December 1, 1993, he presented his time card showing an entry at 7:50 in the morning and a departure at 6:38 in the evening.
Issues
- Whether or not the respondent is guilty of grave misconduct and dishonesty for his acts at the House International Building during the posting and implementation of the writ of execution.
- Whether or not the respondent's claim that he was a mere silent observer, and his time card for December 1, 1993, can overcome his positive identification by the witnesses.
- Whether or not the respondent's application for sick leave shields him from liability for acts done while he was supposedly on leave.
- Whether or not the penalty recommended by the investigating officer, suspension for one year, is the correct penalty.
Applicable Provisions
The decision applies the Civil Service law and rules on misconduct and dishonesty, which the investigating officer identified as Presidential Decree Number 807 and Executive Order Number 292, together with existing Civil Service rules and regulations. The Court's finding rests on the rule that the conduct of everyone connected with the dispensation of justice must be beyond reproach:
The conduct and behavior of everyone connected with the dispensation of justice from the presiding judge to the lowliest clerk must always be beyond reproach and circumscribed with the heavy burden of responsibility.
This standard bears directly on the case because the respondent, an employee of the Court of Appeals, used his position and misrepresented himself in the enforcement of another court's writ.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found the respondent guilty of grave misconduct. He admitted being at the building on November 25 and December 2, 1993, and his claim that he was a mere silent observer was self-serving and belied by the testimonies of the complainant, the lawyer, and the patrolman. He was positively identified as actively assisting the sheriff in posting the notices and in evicting the tenants himself, and the photographs showed him with a flashlight walking around the building with the sheriff's team. His denials cannot prevail over his positive identification.
On the second issue, the Court held that the time card merely shows that the respondent was at the Court of Appeals at the exact times stated, 7:50 in the morning and 6:38 in the evening. It does not conclusively prove that he was physically present at his office the whole day of December 1, 1993, and in any event the Court of Appeals is not far from Sta. Cruz, Manila. Even granting that he was there the whole day, the undisputed fact remained that he was seen at the building on November 25 and December 2, 1993. The sheriff's partial report, which did not mention him, could not help him, because a sheriff's report states the acts done under the writ and does not usually state the irregularities accompanying the manner of execution.
On the third issue, the Court held that applying for sick leave for a prolonged period when in fact he was physically up and about at the building performing another activity made the respondent liable for dishonesty. He could not claim that the acts were done outside his work as a court employee. He deliberately misrepresented himself as a sheriff and an officer of another court, and his acts constituted not mere dishonesty but a clear case of intervention. The Court warned that this practice of interfering in the proceedings of another court should not be tolerated, for it would involve his official position when his office might eventually be called upon in a later litigation.
On the fourth issue, the Court agreed with the findings of the investigating officer but held that the penalty should be dismissal, not suspension.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, the conduct of everyone connected with the dispensation of justice, from the presiding judge to the lowliest clerk, must always be beyond reproach and circumscribed with the heavy burden of responsibility. Second, an employee of the judiciary who misrepresents himself as a sheriff of another court and interferes in the enforcement of that court's writ is guilty of grave misconduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service. Third, applying for sick leave while physically performing other activities is dishonesty, and the employee cannot escape liability by claiming the acts were done outside his work. Fourth, positive identification by witnesses, supported by photographs, prevails over the employee's bare denials and a time card that proves presence at the office only at the exact times stated. These rules flow from the ethical standard quoted above and from the Civil Service provisions on misconduct and dishonesty.
Disposition
The Court dismissed the respondent from the service for dishonesty and grave misconduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service, with forfeiture of all retirement benefits and with prejudice to reemployment in any national or local office of the government, including government-owned or controlled corporations.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that the conduct of everyone connected with the dispensation of justice, from the presiding judge to the lowliest clerk, must always be beyond reproach. Examiners like to use this case on the ethical standards of court personnel, on dishonesty through false sick leave, and on the grave misconduct of a judiciary employee who usurps the functions of a sheriff.