🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CORAZON PURISIMA, LEELIN PURISIMA, AND BERNARDITA PURISIMA, PETITIONERS-APPELLANTS, V. ROSALIO PURISIMA SUBSTITUTED BY HIS CHILDREN, FEDERICO G. PURISIMA, VIRGINIA P. DELA CRUZ,…

April 29, 2003

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Purisima versus Purisima

The Case

This is a petition for review brought by Corazon Purisima, Leelin Purisima, and Bernardita Purisima against Rosalio Purisima, later substituted by his children, in an action for recovery of ownership, which the complaint itself calls reivindicacion. Rosalio sued to recover a small parcel of land in Paoay, Ilocos Norte, that the petitioners were occupying. The petitioners defended on the strength of a supposed dowry given to Corazon and on long possession. The case matters because it gathers in one place two rules a reviewee must never confuse: possession by mere tolerance never ripens into ownership by prescription, and the factual findings of the trial court, affirmed by the Regional Trial Court, are accorded finality when supported by the evidence.

Procedural History

Rosalio Purisima filed a verified complaint for recovery of ownership before the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Paoay and Currimao, Ilocos Norte. During the pendency of the proceedings Rosalio died and was substituted by his heirs. The Municipal Circuit Trial Court rendered judgment in favor of Rosalio, declaring the plaintiffs the owners of the 124 square meters, directing Leelin Purisima to reconvey the land covered by her tax declaration, and ordering Bernardita Purisima and Corazon Purisima to vacate and deliver possession, with Corazon also directed to reconvey the 44 square meters she claimed to have acquired from Felipe Purisima.

The petitioners appealed to the Regional Trial Court of Batac, Ilocos Norte, which dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Municipal Circuit Trial Court in its decision of April 29, 2003. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review under Rule 42 of the Rules of Court, assigning errors on prescription and laches, on the identity of the land covered by the two deeds of sale, on facts allegedly drawn from surmises, and on the application of the law on succession.

Facts

Cirilo Purisima married Pastora Pulido Pasol, who was already the mother of a love child named Ursula Pasol. Cirilo and Pastora had four legitimate children: Gualberto, Felipe, Alejandra, and Rosalio, all surnamed Purisima. During the marriage, Cirilo begot six children with his stepdaughter Ursula, among them Salustiano, who became the husband of Corazon Purisima and the father of Leelin and Bernardita.

Pastora and Cirilo owned a parcel of land of 326 square meters, which they had bought from Mamerto Pobre. The northern portion of 202 square meters was sold to Elias Corpuz in two transactions, the proceeds going to pay a loan incurred for the burial of Ursula. What remained was 124 square meters, and this is the land in dispute, occupied by the petitioners.

Corazon claimed that Pastora gave her a parcel of 306 square meters on July 20, 1953 as a dowry in consideration of her marriage to Salustiano in November 1951, and that she had paid taxes on it. She also claimed that the 104 square meters she possessed had been mortgaged to her in 1976 by Felipe Purisima. The courts below found otherwise: that Corazon had stayed in the house of the childless Felipe as a transient, by his tolerance and liberality, and that the land she occupied belonged to the legitimate children of Pastora, to the total exclusion of the heirs of Ursula.

Issues

  • Whether or not prescription or laches had set in in favor of the petitioners.
  • Whether or not the property covered by the deed of absolute sale of October 17, 1951 was erroneously considered as part of the property covered by the deed of absolute sale of October 8, 1957.
  • Whether or not the trial courts imputed facts based on surmises not proven during the trial.
  • Whether or not the trial courts erred in applying the law on succession.

Applicable Provisions

Article 1119 of the Civil Code provides:

Acts of possessory character executed in virtue of license or by mere tolerance of the owner shall not be available for the purposes of possession.

This is the provision on which the Court rests its ruling that the petitioners' long occupation, being by tolerance, never started the running of the period of prescription.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the petitioners could not have acquired the land by prescription. Their possession was by mere tolerance of Rosalio's brother Felipe, who was then occupying the property, and possession by tolerance, no matter how long continued, does not start the running of any period of prescription. The Court quoted its earlier ruling in Pabalan versus the Heirs of Maamo, which applied Article 1119 and held that possession must be in the concept of an owner, or adverse, to constitute the foundation of a prescriptive right; if it is not, such possessory acts, no matter how long, do not start the running of the period of prescription.

On the second, third, and fourth issues, the Court held that the records showed the remaining 124 square meters still belonged to Pastora, because Pastora and her children had sold only 202 square meters to Elias Corpuz under the deed of October 8, 1957. Rosalio, as Pastora's son, had a right to inherit that remaining land, subject to the rights of the heirs of his siblings, to the total exclusion of the heirs of Ursula, from whom Salustiano descended. The Court added that the factual findings of the Municipal Circuit Trial Court, especially when affirmed by the Regional Trial Court, are entitled to great weight and respect on appeal, and are accorded finality when supported by sufficient evidence on the record.

Doctrine

Possession by mere tolerance or license of the owner is not adverse possession. Under Article 1119 of the Civil Code, acts of possessory character executed in virtue of license or by mere tolerance of the owner shall not be available for the purposes of possession, so such possession, however long, never ripens into ownership by acquisitive prescription. Possession must be in the concept of an owner, or adverse, to serve as the foundation of a prescriptive right. And the factual findings of the trial court, when affirmed by the Regional Trial Court and supported by sufficient evidence, are entitled to great weight and respect and are accorded finality on appeal.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the decision of the Regional Trial Court, which had affirmed the Municipal Circuit Trial Court, so the heirs of Rosalio Purisima won.

Remember This

Memorize the line: possession by mere tolerance, no matter how long, does not start the running of prescription, because Article 1119 excludes acts done by license or tolerance from the purposes of possession. Examiners use this case to test the requisites of acquisitive prescription and the finality given to factual findings affirmed by the Regional Trial Court.