MARIA ALAR, LOLITA ALAR AND SOCRATES ALAR JR., PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS, VS. PETRA ASIS, SPS. PABLITO JR., AND LYNLYN ASIS, SPS. ARMANDO JR., AND GLORIA ASIS-DALA, SPS. SALVADOR AN…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Alar versus Asis
The Case
This is a civil case for recovery of property and, in the alternative, for partition, brought by Maria Alar, Lolita Alar, and Socrates Alar Jr. against Petra Asis and the several Asis spouses before the Regional Trial Court of Borongan, Eastern Samar. The plaintiffs claim ownership and long possession of a residential lot, while the defendants claim to be the true owners who have occupied it since time immemorial. The case matters to a Bar candidate for two reasons: it is a clean illustration of how jurisdiction over the subject matter is fixed by the allegations of the complaint and by the assessed value of the property, and it is a stern reminder that an appeal raising a pure question of law must go to the Supreme Court by petition for review, not to the Court of Appeals by ordinary appeal.
Procedural History
The plaintiffs filed their complaint before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 1, of Borongan, Eastern Samar. The trial court initially ruled that there was a misjoinder of causes of action and directed the plaintiffs to sever them; the plaintiffs filed a notice of severance, maintaining the action for partition. Later, the defendants filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the lone tax declaration attached to the complaint showed an assessed value of only two hundred twenty pesos, well below twenty thousand pesos, so that the Municipal Trial Court, and not the Regional Trial Court, had jurisdiction. The trial court granted the motion and dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter. The plaintiffs moved for reconsideration, which was denied. The plaintiffs then filed a notice of appeal, assailing both orders, and the appeal was taken to the Supreme Court.
Facts
On January 21, 2003, the plaintiffs filed a complaint alleging that they are the absolute owners of a parcel of residential land in Borongan, Eastern Samar, and that they and their predecessors in interest had possessed it publicly, peacefully, continuously, and adversely for decades. They alleged that on March 17, 2001, the defendants, by stealth and strategy, occupied the entire land and built a concrete hollow-block fence along the street, blocking the only ingress and egress to the property. As a result, the store of the lessees was shut off from the street, and the plaintiffs lost rental income. Despite demands, the defendants refused to vacate and even increased the height of the fence. The matter was referred to the barangay authorities, but no settlement was reached.
As an alternative cause of action, the plaintiffs averred that they are co-owners of the property with the defendants in at least four equal parts, being the heirs and successors in interest of Faustino Alar and Clotilde Alar-Asis, respectively, and they asked for partition. The only documentary exhibit attached to the complaint was a 1940 Declaration of Real Property, Tax Declaration Number 47638, showing an assessed value of two hundred twenty pesos.
In their answer, the defendants countered that the plaintiffs had never been in possession; that the defendants and their predecessors had occupied the property since time immemorial and had a residential house there built in the 1960s; that they had every right to build a fence on their own property; and that the plaintiffs were barred by laches, estoppel, and prescription. After pre-trial and several postponements, the defendants filed a motion to dismiss, pointing to the tax declaration as proof that the assessed value did not exceed twenty thousand pesos, so that the Municipal Trial Court had jurisdiction. The trial court granted the motion and dismissed the case. The plaintiffs appealed.
Issues
- Whether or not the Regional Trial Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of the case, given that the assessed value of the property stated in the tax declaration does not exceed twenty thousand pesos.
- Whether or not the appeal, raising a pure question of law from a decision of the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction, was taken by the proper mode.
Applicable Provisions
Section 2 of Rule 50 of the Rules of Court provides:
Section 2. Dismissal of improper appeal to the Court of Appeals. — An appeal under Rule 41 taken from the Regional Trial Court to the Court of Appeals raising only questions of law shall be dismissed, issues purely of law not being reviewable by said court. Similarly, an appeal by notice of appeal instead of by petition for review from the appellate judgment of a Regional Trial Court shall be dismissed.
This provision governs the second issue, because it commands the dismissal of an appeal that raises only questions of law and is erroneously taken to the Court of Appeals.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the appeal is bereft of merit. The settled rule is that jurisdiction over the subject matter is determined by the allegations of the complaint. The Court quoted its earlier ruling that jurisdiction over the nature and subject matter of a petition or complaint is determined by the material allegations therein and the character of the relief prayed for, irrespective of whether the complainant is entitled to any or all such reliefs, and that jurisdiction is conferred by the Constitution and the law, not by the consent or waiver of the parties. The Court also stressed that lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter may be raised at any time, even during appeal or after final judgment, because that kind of jurisdiction is conferred by law and is not for the courts or the parties to set aside.
Applying this, the Court noted that the complaint itself does not mention the assessed value of the property; the assessed value appears only in Tax Declaration Number 47638, the sole documentary exhibit. The trial court had used that tax declaration as the basis for the assessed value because the complaint was silent on the point. The Court held that this was not sanctioned by the Rules, and that what the trial court should have done was to dismiss the case outright.
On the second issue, the Court held that the appeal should likewise be denied. Although not raised as a defense, the Court observed that the appeal involves a pure question of law. The plaintiffs' lone assignment of error was that the trial court erred in ruling that it had no jurisdiction because the assessed value did not exceed twenty thousand pesos. Since the case was decided by the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction, the proper mode of appeal was a petition for review by certiorari with the Supreme Court under Rule 45. The Court cited its ruling that issues dealing with a court's jurisdiction over the subject matter are pure questions of law, and that an appeal solely involving a question of law should have been taken directly to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45, not by ordinary appeal with the Court of Appeals under Rule 41. It then applied Section 2 of Rule 50, which provides that an appeal from the Regional Trial Court to the Court of Appeals raising only questions of law shall be dismissed, and that an appeal erroneously taken to the Court of Appeals shall be dismissed outright.
Doctrine
Jurisdiction over the subject matter is determined by the material allegations of the complaint and the character of the relief prayed for, not by the consent or waiver of the parties, and it is conferred only by the Constitution or by statute. Lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter may be raised at any time, even on appeal or after final judgment. Where the complaint is silent on the assessed value of the property, the trial court may not supply that value from a tax declaration; the case should be dismissed outright. Finally, an appeal from the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction that raises only a pure question of law must be taken to the Supreme Court by petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45; an appeal erroneously taken to the Court of Appeals under Rule 41 shall be dismissed under Section 2 of Rule 50.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the appeal and affirmed the orders of the Regional Trial Court dismissing the case for lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter.
Remember This
The single line to memorize is that jurisdiction over the subject matter is fixed by the allegations of the complaint and by law, never by the consent of the parties, and that a pure question of law from the Regional Trial Court goes to the Supreme Court by petition for review, not to the Court of Appeals by ordinary appeal. Examiners like to use this case to test the proper mode of appeal and the rule that lack of jurisdiction may be raised at any stage.