🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CORBAN COMMUNITY FARMS, INCORPORATED, PETITIONER, VS. HON. INOCENCIO M. JAURIQUE, PRESIDING JUDGE, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT BRANCH 44, MAMBURAO, OCCIDENTAL MINDORO, EFREN AVILA, ENR…

May 20, 2002

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Corban Community Farms versus Jaurique

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari, prohibition and mandamus brought by Corban Community Farms, Incorporated against the presiding judge of a branch of the Regional Trial Court of Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro, and against a group of private oppositors who claim to have long occupied and cultivated the land the corporation seeks to register. The corporation asks the Supreme Court to annul two orders by which the trial court set aside its earlier ruling that the oppositors had no legal standing, and reinstated them as parties entitled to oppose the application. The case matters because it fixes the character of an interlocutory order in a land registration proceeding and measures how far a trial court may correct its own mistake before judgment without committing grave abuse of discretion.

Procedural History

Corban Farms filed an application for registration of title before the Regional Trial Court of Mindoro, docketed as a land registration case. The private respondents, together with the Republic of the Philippines, opposed the application. The oppositors moved to dismiss on the ground that the application lacked a certification and verification of non-forum shopping, and the trial court granted the motion in an order dated December 17, 1999, dismissing the application.

Corban Farms sought reconsideration and also challenged the personality of the oppositors to oppose, since they were not claiming or occupying any specific portion of the property. In an order dated April 4, 2000, the trial court ruled that the oppositors had no legal standing, reconsidered and set aside the December 17, 1999 dismissal, and instead merely required the applicant to attach the certificate of non-forum shopping, resetting the case for the presentation of the applicant's evidence.

Later, finding that it had committed an error that needed correction, the trial court issued the order of May 20, 2002, setting aside the April 4, 2000 order and reiterating its oral order of February 12, 2002 allowing the oppositors, through counsel, to participate in all proceedings. Corban Farms moved for reconsideration, which was denied for lack of merit in the order of July 25, 2002. Corban Farms then came to the Supreme Court by this petition for certiorari, prohibition and mandamus.

Facts

Corban Farms applied to register title over twenty three parcels of land with a combined area of 187,685 square meters. The private respondents opposed the application, and the Republic joined them. The oppositors first succeeded in having the application dismissed for want of a certificate of non-forum shopping.

On reconsideration, the trial court reversed itself. It held that the certificate of non-forum shopping is mandatory but not jurisdictional, allowed the applicant to attach the certificate, and in the same April 4, 2000 order declared that the oppositors had no legal standing because they were not claiming or occupying the land subject of the case.

Upon a careful reexamination of the records, however, the trial court found that the oppositors had alleged in their opposition filed on May 24, 1996 that for several years they had been occupants of the land applied for, cultivating it and devoting it to the production of palay and other vegetable crops. Concluding that its earlier ruling on standing was a palpable mistake, the trial court set that ruling aside and restored the oppositors' right to participate and be heard.

Issues

  • Whether or not the presiding judge committed grave abuse of discretion in setting aside the order of April 4, 2000, which had removed the oppositors' right to oppose and participate in the proceedings.
  • Whether or not the order of April 4, 2000 had become final and unchangeable, so that the trial court could no longer disturb it.
  • Whether or not the petitioner was denied due process when the trial court reinstated the oppositors.

Applicable Provisions

The decision does not quote a specific statutory text; it rests on the settled rule governing interlocutory orders and on the court's inherent power to control its own processes. The principle it applies may be stated thus:

An interlocutory order does not finally dispose of the case and may be modified or rescinded upon sufficient grounds shown at any time before judgment.

This rule bears directly on the case because it answers whether the April 4, 2000 order could still be reconsidered by the trial court.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court ruled in the negative and against Corban Farms. The order of April 4, 2000 was not a final but an interlocutory order, one that did not finally dispose of the case. As such, it could never become final in the sense of becoming unchangeable and impervious to impugnation after the period for appeal from a final judgment had expired. It is always under the control of the court and may be modified or rescinded upon sufficient grounds shown at any time before judgment.

On the second issue, the Court explained that this power flows from a court's inherent power to amend and control its processes and orders so as to make them conformable to law and justice. That power includes the right to reverse itself, especially when in its honest opinion it has committed an error or mistake in judgment, and when adhering to its decision would cause injustice to a party litigant. The trial court had found a palpable mistake, and correcting it could by no stretch be deemed grave abuse of discretion. This was especially so because the application covered twenty three parcels of land with a combined area of 187,685 square meters which the respondents allegedly had previously cultivated; it was but just and proper to afford them their right to be heard.

On the third issue, the Court rejected the plea of denial of due process. A plea of denial of procedural due process does not lie where the alleged aggrieved party had the opportunity to be heard on a motion for reconsideration, giving sufficient opportunity to inform the tribunal of his side of the controversy. Since Corban Farms had that opportunity, no grave abuse of discretion could be imputed to the assailed orders. The Court also noted that the arguments of the Office of the Solicitor General on the lifting of the order of general default were irrelevant, because the petitioner was not assailing that lifting.

Doctrine

An interlocutory order is one that does not finally dispose of the case. It never becomes final and unchangeable, and it remains under the control of the court, which may modify or rescind it upon sufficient grounds at any time before judgment. This is an incident of the court's inherent power to amend and control its processes and orders so as to make them conformable to law and justice, and it includes the right to reverse itself when it honestly believes it has committed an error whose adherence would cause injustice to a party litigant. Correcting such a palpable mistake is not grave abuse of discretion. Finally, a plea of denial of procedural due process does not lie where the aggrieved party had the opportunity to be heard on a motion for reconsideration.

Disposition

The petition was denied due course and dismissed, so the trial court's orders of May 20, 2002 and July 25, 2002 stand and the oppositors remain entitled to participate and be heard.

Remember This

Memorize the line that an interlocutory order is always under the control of the court and may be modified or rescinded upon sufficient grounds at any time before judgment. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between final and interlocutory orders, the court's power to correct its own error, and the rule that due process is satisfied where a motion for reconsideration was available.