THE HEIRS OF THE LATE JOSE DELOS REYES, DULY REPRESENTED BY JOSELITO A. DELOS REYES, PETITIONERS, VS. HON. RODOLFO R. BONIFACIO, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE, RTC BRANCH 1…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Heirs of the Late Jose delos Reyes versus Bonifacio
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by the heirs of the late Jose delos Reyes against Judge Rodolfo Bonifacio, in his capacity as presiding judge of a branch of the Regional Trial Court, and against Bhagwan Ramnani as private respondent. The heirs ask the Supreme Court to annul the trial court's orders allowing Bhagwan to substitute his deceased wife Josephine as the party in the execution of a long-final judgment. The case matters because it fixes two rules every reviewee must carry: substitution of a deceased party is a requirement of due process, and the supervening death of a party does not divest a court that has already acquired jurisdiction. It also teaches who is a person aggrieved for purposes of certiorari.
Procedural History
The case is an offshoot of an earlier decision of the Supreme Court in the civil case between Josephine Ramnani and Jose delos Reyes. In that case, the trial court rendered judgment in Josephine's favor, an execution sale followed, Josephine was the highest bidder, the redemption period lapsed without redemption by Jose, and the ruling was affirmed all the way to the Supreme Court. Josephine later died. Her husband Bhagwan filed a Manifestation and Substitution of Parties with the Regional Trial Court to replace her in the execution of the judgment. The heirs of Jose opposed, but the trial court granted the substitution. The heirs moved for reconsideration, and the trial court denied it. The heirs then filed this petition for certiorari under Rule 65 assailing the trial court's twin orders. In the interim, Bhagwan obtained an alias writ of possession and a notice to vacate was issued against the heirs; their motion to quash was denied, prompting them to seek a temporary restraining order and writ of preliminary injunction from the Supreme Court, which they reiterated later.
Facts
On October 11, 1977, the trial court rendered a decision in the civil case in favor of Josephine Anne Ramnani. A writ of execution issued, an execution sale was conducted over the property covered by the transfer certificate of title, and Josephine emerged as the highest bidder. A certificate of sale was issued. The redemption period lapsed, and Jose delos Reyes, the defeated party, never redeemed the property. Josephine therefore moved for the issuance of the final certificate of sale, and the trial court granted it. Jose appealed, and both the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court affirmed, holding that Josephine was entitled to the final certificate of sale as a matter of right, the issuance being a mere formality confirming a title already vested in her.
Josephine then died. On March 15, 2012, her husband Bhagwan filed a Manifestation and Substitution of Parties with the Regional Trial Court to replace Josephine as party in the execution of the judgment. The trial court granted the substitution, holding that Bhagwan is entitled to substitute Josephine since he is the owner of the property involved. The heirs moved for reconsideration, but the trial court denied it.
In the interim, Bhagwan filed a Motion for Alias Writ of Possession, which was granted, and on the same date a Notice to Vacate was issued against the petitioners. Their motion to quash the alias writ was denied. The heirs then came to the Supreme Court, contending that Bhagwan cannot substitute Josephine because he never participated in any of the proceedings before the trial court, the Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court, appearing only at the execution stage, so that the court never acquired jurisdiction over his person.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in ordering the substitution of Bhagwan Ramnani in place of the deceased Josephine Ramnani.
- Whether or not jurisdiction over the person of Bhagwan had to be acquired by the trial court before he could be substituted.
- Whether or not the heirs of the late Jose delos Reyes are persons aggrieved who may avail themselves of the remedy of certiorari.
Applicable Provisions
Section 16, Rule 3 of the Rules of Court provides:
Death of party; duty of counsel. — Whenever a party to a pending action dies, and the claim is not thereby extinguished, it shall be the duty of his counsel to inform the court within thirty (30) days after such death of the fact thereof, and to give the name and address of his legal representative or representatives. Failure of counsel to comply with his duty shall be a ground for disciplinary action. The heirs of the deceased may be allowed to be substituted for the deceased, without requiring the appointment of an executor or administrator and the court may appoint a guardian ad litem for the minor heirs. The court shall forthwith order said legal representative or representatives to appear and be substituted within a period of thirty (30) days from notice. If no legal representative is named by the counsel for the deceased party, or if the one so named shall fail to appear within the specified period, the court may order the opposing party, within a specified time to procure the appointment of an executor or administrator for the estate of the deceased and the latter shall immediately appear for and on behalf of the deceased. The court charges in procuring such appointment, if defrayed by the opposing party, may be recovered as costs.
This is the very rule the trial court applied when it allowed Bhagwan to substitute Josephine, and it anchors the due process rationale of the decision.
Section 7, Rule 39 of the Rules of Court provides that in case of the death of the judgment obligee, execution may issue or be enforced upon the application of his executor or administrator or successor in interest. This provision supplies the authority for Bhagwan, as Josephine's successor in interest, to move for execution in her place.
Section 1, Rule 65 of the Rules of Court provides:
When any tribunal, board or officer exercising judicial or quasi-judicial functions has acted without or in excess its or his jurisdiction, or with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction, and there is no appeal, or any plain, speedy, and adequate remedy in the ordinary course of law, a person aggrieved thereby may file a verified petition in the proper court, alleging the facts with certainty and praying that judgment be rendered annulling or modifying the proceedings of such tribunal, board or officer, and granting such incidental reliefs as law and justice may require. The petition shall be accompanied by a certified true copy of the judgment, order or resolution subject thereof, copies of all pleadings and documents relevant and pertinent thereto, and a sworn certification of non-forum shopping as provided in the third paragraph of section 3, Rule 46.
The phrase person aggrieved in this provision is the gate the heirs failed to pass, because the Court held they stand to be neither benefited nor injured by the judgment.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the trial court committed no error in ordering the substitution. The rule on substitution by heirs is a requirement of due process designed to ensure that the deceased party continues to be properly represented through his heirs or the duly appointed legal representative of his estate. When there is denial of due process, as when the deceased is not represented by any legal representative or heir, the court may nullify the trial proceedings and the resulting judgment. Here, the trial court ordered the substitution in accordance with the rules.
On the second issue, the Court held that it was not necessary for the trial court to acquire jurisdiction over the person of Bhagwan, who merely substituted the deceased party. As this proceeding is a continuation of the case in which the Court had previously acquired jurisdiction, the supervening event of death of the parties will not divest the Court of its authority. The Court also stressed that under Section 7, Rule 39, execution may be enforced upon the application of the judgment obligee's successor in interest, and Bhagwan is Josephine's successor in interest who can validly substitute her. His Manifestation and Substitution of Parties was sufficient to complete the execution of the judgment.
On the third issue, the Court held that the case had long been final and executory, and that the petitioners no longer have a real and substantial interest in the property, being the heirs of the defeated party. Since Jose failed to redeem the property within the prescribed period, Josephine's ownership became absolute, and the issuance of the certificate of sale is a ministerial function of the court. The Court explained that the term person aggrieved is not construed to mean that any person who feels injured by the lower court's order may question it via certiorari. A person aggrieved is one who stands to be benefited or injured by the judgment in the suit, or the party entitled to the avails of the suit. Since the resolution of the petition will not affect the petitioners nor their rights, they do not stand to be aggrieved.
Doctrine
Substitution of a deceased party by his heirs or legal representative is a requirement of due process, and its denial may nullify the trial proceedings and the resulting judgment. The supervening death of a party does not divest a court that has already acquired jurisdiction; hence, jurisdiction over the person of the substituting party need not be separately acquired, because the substitution is a continuation of the same case. Upon the death of the judgment obligee, execution may issue or be enforced upon the application of his executor, administrator, or successor in interest. Finally, the remedy of certiorari under Section 1, Rule 65 belongs only to a person aggrieved, meaning one who stands to be benefited or injured by the judgment in the suit, or the party entitled to the avails of the suit, not one who merely feels injured by the order.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed and the application for injunctive relief was denied, so Bhagwan Ramnani prevailed and the substitution and execution in his favor stood.
Remember This
Memorize this line: the death of a party does not divest a court of jurisdiction already acquired, and substitution by heirs is a requirement of due process. Examiners use this case to test the rule on substitution of parties during execution and the meaning of person aggrieved in a petition for certiorari.