IN RE: SOCIAL MEDIA POSTS OF EDGAR S. DIZON,
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
In re: Social Media Posts of Edgar S. Dizon
The Case
This is an administrative matter in which the Supreme Court of the Philippines, acting through its Office of the 2023 Bar Chair and the Office of the Bar Confidant, proceeded against Edgar S. Dizon, a bar passer who administered the Facebook accounts Bar Law for Dummies Training Program and Tsidkenu Dizon. The Court initiated the action on its own initiative, requiring Dizon to show cause why he should not be cited for indirect contempt for his social media posts claiming that the 2023 Bar Examinations would be sorted, checked, and corrected by artificial intelligence. The case matters because it is the Court's own pronouncement on the reach of its contempt power over speech that disrupts bar operations, and because it joins that contempt finding to a second and equally serious charge: the unauthorized practice of law by a bar passer who never took his oath.
Procedural History
This case did not travel through the trial courts or the Court of Appeals. It began and ended in the Supreme Court as an administrative matter arising from the Court's supervision of the bar examinations. After the posts went viral in September 2023, the Office of the 2023 Bar Chair issued an Advisory condemning them and commenced a probe, engaging the National Bureau of Investigation. The administrator of both accounts was identified as Dizon. In a Resolution dated October 24, 2023, upon the recommendation and endorsement of the Office of the Bar Confidant, the Court required Dizon to show cause within five working days why he should not be cited for indirect contempt under Sections 3(c), (d), and (e) of Rule 71 of the Rules of Court. Dizon filed his Explanation dated March 14, 2024. The Court then resolved the matter en banc, through a per curiam decision, with a separate concurring opinion from Senior Associate Justice Leonen.
Facts
In September 2023 the Court conducted the bar examinations, released the results, and held the oath-taking ceremonies all within the same year. The preparations were frenzied, technical, precise, and measured, and the bar operations went smoothly as planned. Towards the tail end, however, a post originating from the Facebook accounts Bar Law for Dummies and Tsidkenu Dizon surfaced on September 21, 2023, claiming among others that the 2023 Bar Examinations would be sorted, checked, and corrected by means of artificial intelligence. The posts went viral and caused further panic and anxiety to the examinees, who were then in the middle of their final preparations.
The Office of the 2023 Bar Chair scrambled to track down the origin and authorship of the post, assess its impact, and plug in measures to avoid misconception. It issued an Advisory condemning the publications as false, baseless, irresponsible, defamatory, contumacious, detestable, and formulated with apparent intent to erode the integrity of the digitalized Bar Examinations, and reiterating that all stakeholders should rely exclusively on the Court's official communication channels. The Advisory stated that the examinations would be checked by four examiners per subject, all established experts, by no means created or powered by artificial intelligence. The administrator of both accounts was eventually unveiled as Edgar S. Dizon.
Contrary to Dizon's later claim that the Advisory had a chilling effect on him, he did not take down the posts. Instead he sought media attention for an interview, threatened the Court with a suit, and demanded a public apology within twenty-four hours from the airing of the interview. He also sent several e-mails to the Judiciary Public Assistance Section, claiming he was devastated, denying he spread misinformation, insisting he never said the artificial intelligence would do the correcting, and praying that the Court issue a statement rectifying the Advisory and have a picture taken with him and the 2023 Bar Chair. In his Explanation, Dizon admitted he was the account holder, that he graduated from Arellano School of Law in 2016 and passed the Bar Examinations the same year, but failed to take the oath because of pending murder cases. He insisted he used the word "to help" and denied saying the artificial intelligence would do the sorting, checking, or correction. He disclaimed practicing law, saying he tells his mentees to call him Teacher Edgar and never Attorney, and that as a master's degree holder in Education he merely applies the art of teaching.
Issues
- Whether or not Edgar S. Dizon should be held liable for indirect contempt under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court for his social media posts on the 2023 Bar Examinations.
- Whether or not Dizon, a bar passer who never took his oath, engaged in the unauthorized practice of law, and whether that likewise constitutes indirect contempt.
- Whether or not the penalty of a fine and delisting from the list of bar passers is warranted under the circumstances.
Applicable Provisions
Section 3 of Rule 71 of the Rules of Court provides:
Section 3. Indirect contempt to be punished after charge and hearing. After a charge in writing has been filed, and opportunity given to the respondent to comment thereon within such period as may be fixed by the court and to be heard by himself or counsel, a person guilty of any of the following acts may be punished for indirect contempt: (c) Any abuse of or any unlawful interference with the processes or proceedings of a court not constituting direct contempt under section 1 of this Rule; (d) Any improper conduct tending, directly or indirectly, to impede, obstruct, or degrade the administration of justice; (e) Assuming to be an attorney or an officer of a court, and acting as such without authority.
These are the very grounds on which the Court required Dizon to show cause, and under which it ultimately held him liable.
Section 2, third paragraph of the 2025 Proposed Amendments to Rule 138 of the Rules of Court provides:
In the Supreme Court's assessment and sole discretion, considering the gravity of the claim or offense charged, any prior cases filed against the applicant, and similar reasons, the Supreme Court may defer the oath-taking of the concerned applicant, or impose any other preventive measures, as warranted.
This provision supplies the Court's authority to impose preventive measures on an applicant, which the Court applied to delist Dizon.
Section 17, fourth paragraph of the same Proposed Amendments provides:
In any case, any false or inaccurate information, concealment or failure to disclose, or misrepresentation on the part of an applicant shall be a ground for either the denial of the application, disqualification from taking the examinations, or delisting from the list of passers, depending on the stage of discovery, and without prejudice to other disciplinary sanctions that the Supreme Court may impose.
This is the specific ground the Court invoked in ordering Dizon's delisting from the list of bar passers.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled in the affirmative. The conduct of the bar examinations is crucial to the legal profession, and any charge or insinuation of anomaly in it is imbued with wide and general interest and national importance. Dizon unlawfully interfered in a court-sanctioned activity by peddling false information and causing alarm and panic among the examinees, and his post undermined the integrity not only of the examinations but of the Supreme Court itself, which has overall supervision and control over them. The Court rejected his claim that he used the word "to help" and never said the artificial intelligence would do the sorting, checking, or correction. Reproducing his post, which read "Always start with yes or no. Yan ang unang hahanapin ng AI Checking to sort out the correct answers," the Court held this to be res ipsa loquitur, a thing speaking for itself: Dizon clearly and categorically mentioned that the artificial intelligence would do the checking and sorting. The Court stressed that the viral posts disrupted bar operations, forcing the Office of the 2023 Bar Chair to expend limited time and lean staff tracing the post, coordinating with the National Bureau of Investigation, issuing an Advisory, and answering queries, while examinees spent time awaiting news instead of reviewing. Plainly, Dizon impeded and degraded the administration of justice.
On the second issue, the Court likewise ruled in the affirmative. Quoting Cayetano versus Monsod, it defined the practice of law as any activity, in or out of court, which requires the application of law, legal procedure, knowledge, training and experience. Dizon's disclaimer that his coaching centered only on style and process was untenable: his mentees enrolled precisely because they wanted to pass the bar, and discussing past bar examination answers definitely requires an application of legal knowledge. Dizon himself admitted he did not waste his knowledge of law and skills in coaching and teaching, and he admitted preparing numerous bar materials and reviewers. Preparing all these required the application of legal knowledge. Thus, for engaging in the unauthorized practice of law, Dizon was similarly guilty of indirect contempt.
On the third issue, the Court noted that Dizon expressed no remorse, showed excessive audacity in demanding an apology within twenty-four hours and threatening a suit, did not take down his posts, and even demanded a rectifying statement and a picture with the Bar Chair. Rule 71, Section 7 allows indirect contempt to be punished by a fine not exceeding 30,000 pesos or imprisonment not exceeding six months, or both, if committed against a Regional Trial Court or a court of equivalent or higher rank. The Court found a 30,000 peso fine appropriate. It further held that the practice of law is a privilege and not a vested right, and that the Court is the gatekeeper to the bar. Recalling that Dizon passed the 2016 Bar Examinations but could not take the oath because of pending murder cases, the Court held that his irresponsible spreading of false information which directly compromised the integrity of the 2023 Bar Examinations warranted his delisting from the list of bar passers.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate must retain these rules. First, the Supreme Court has overall supervision and control over the bar examinations, and any unlawful interference with that court-sanctioned process, or any improper conduct tending to impede, obstruct, or degrade the administration of justice, is indirect contempt under Section 3(c) and (d) of Rule 71. Second, false and irresponsible posts that cause alarm among examinees and erode the integrity of the examinations are contemptuous, and the Court will not be shielded from criticism, but fair criticism confined to facts and based on decisions is not contempt, while charges of improper or corrupt motives tend to create distrust and destroy confidence in the courts. Third, the practice of law means any activity, in or out of court, which requires the application of law, legal procedure, knowledge, training and experience, and a non-lawyer who coaches bar reviewees and prepares bar materials engages in its unauthorized practice, which is itself indirect contempt under Section 3(e). Fourth, the practice of law is a privilege and not a vested right, and under the 2025 Proposed Amendments to Rule 138 the Court may defer oath-taking, impose preventive measures, and delist from the list of passers one who spreads false information compromising the integrity of the examinations.
Disposition
The Court found Edgar S. Dizon guilty of indirect contempt, ordered him to pay a fine of 30,000 pesos, directed the Office of the Bar Confidant to delist him from the list of bar passers and report within five days, and warned him against further engaging in the unauthorized practice of law.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that the practice of law is a privilege and not a vested right, and the Court, as gatekeeper to the bar, may delist a bar passer whose false posts compromise the integrity of the examinations while citing him for indirect contempt. Examiners like to use this case on the scope of indirect contempt under Rule 71, on the definition of the practice of law, and on the Court's power to impose preventive measures and delisting under the amendments to Rule 138.