🎧 Case Brief Lecture

BSM CREW SERVICE CENTRE PHILIPPINES, INC., AND/OR BERNHARD SCHULTE SHIPMGT (CYPRUS) LIMITED, PETITIONERS, VS. PANEL OF VOLUNTARY ARBITRATORS COMPOSED OF FROILAN A. BAGABALDO (CH…

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Corales versus BSM Crew Service Centre Philippines

The Case

This is BSM Crew Service Centre Philippines versus the Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators, a special civil action for certiorari brought by the manning agency and the foreign shipowner against the Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators and the seafarer Garry Guevarra. The petitioners asked the Supreme Court to annul the arbitral award, but before the Court could rule on the merits, the parties settled amicably before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board. The case matters because it shows how a compromise settlement, embodied in a release and quitclaim and a joint motion to dismiss, ends a labor dispute and withdraws a pending petition, leaving no ruling on the merits for a reviewee to rely on.

Procedural History

The dispute began as a claim by the seafarer Garry Guevarra against the manning agency and the foreign principal, and it was submitted to voluntary arbitration. The Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators, composed of Froilan Bagabaldo as chairman and other members, issued an award in the seafarer's favor. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court by a petition for certiorari, seeking to set aside that award. While the petition was pending, the parties reached an amicable settlement before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board. The petitioners filed a Manifestation with Motion informing the Court of the settlement and praying for the withdrawal of the petition. They attached the Joint Motion to Dismiss filed before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, the Release of All Rights, the Pagpapaubaya ng Lahat ng Karapatan, the Affidavit of Claimant, and the Receipt of Payment, all executed by the seafarer. The Court then resolved the motion.

Facts

Garry Guevarra, a seafarer, suffered an injury or illness on board the vessel Cosco Long Beach. The injury is described in the release as a surgery, open reduction and internal fixation with K-wire fixation, of the right big toe. He filed a claim against BSM Crew Service Centre Philippines and Bernhard Schulte Shipmgt Cyprus Limited, and the claim went to voluntary arbitration.

The Panel of Voluntary Arbitrators ruled in his favor. The employers then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari.

On February 26, 2015, the petitioners filed a Manifestation with Motion alleging that the parties had agreed to an amicable settlement before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, and they prayed for the withdrawal of the petition. In support, they submitted the Joint Motion to Dismiss filed before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, the Release of All Rights, the Pagpapaubaya ng Lahat ng Karapatan, the Affidavit of Claimant, and the Receipt of Payment, all executed by the seafarer. In the Release of All Rights, the seafarer acknowledged receiving one hundred twenty thousand dollars, or its peso equivalent of five million one hundred ninety one thousand four hundred forty pesos, and discharged the employers and the vessel from every claim arising from the injury on board the Cosco Long Beach, wiping the slate clean as between the parties.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Manifestation with Motion for the withdrawal of the petition should be granted in view of the amicable settlement between the parties.
  • Whether or not the petition for certiorari should be withdrawn and the case closed and terminated.

Applicable Provisions

The decision does not quote any statute, rule, or constitutional provision. Its operative text is the Release of All Rights executed by the seafarer, which defines the scope of the settlement and bears on the withdrawal of the petition. It reads:

I, GARRY G. GUEVARRA, of legal age, married, with residence at 293-D Sta. Teresita Street, Sampaloc Manila, Philippines, in exchange for ONE HUNDRED TWENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS (US$120,000.00) or its peso equivalent of FIVE MILLION ONE HUNDRED NINETY ONE THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED FORTY PESOS, (Php5,191,440.00) which I have received, do hereby Release (Please write the word RELEASE to show that you know what you are doing) and forever discharge: BSM CREW SERVICE CENTRE PHILIPPINES INC., and/or BERNHARD SCHULTE SHIPMGT (CYPRUS) LIMITED, and their heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, and their several vessels and in particular the COSCO LONG BEACH and the owners, agents, operators, charterers, master, officers and crews, the underwriters and P & I Club of said vessels from each and every right and claim which I now have, or may hereafter have, whether arising in tort, contract, statutory law, or any other basis of recovery, on account of injury/illness/death suffered by GARRY G. GUEVARRA on board the vessel COSCO LONG BEACH as follows: S/P Open Reduction and Internal Fixation with K-wire Fixation, Right Big Toe, and, in addition to that, I Release (Please white the word RELEASE to show that you know what you are doing) them from each and every right and claim which I now have or may hereafter have because of any matter or thing which happened before the signing of this paper, it being my intention by the signing of this paper to wipe the slate clean as between myself, my successors-in-interest and the parties released, even with respect to injuries, illnesses, rights and claims not mentioned herein and which are not known to me. I agree not to file any claims against the Owners and its successors-in-interest based on torn or on any other ground, but also not to arrest the subject vessel or any other vessel of said Owners, operators or charterers.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court found the Manifestation with Motion well taken and granted it. The parties had amicably settled before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, and the seafarer had executed a Release of All Rights, a Pagpapaubaya ng Lahat ng Karapatan, an Affidavit of Claimant, and a Receipt of Payment. In the release, he acknowledged receiving one hundred twenty thousand dollars, or its peso equivalent of five million one hundred ninety one thousand four hundred forty pesos, and discharged the employers and the vessel from every claim arising from the injury on board the Cosco Long Beach, wiping the slate clean as between the parties. Because the settlement had extinguished the claim, there was nothing left for the Court to resolve on the merits.

On the second issue, the Court accordingly allowed the withdrawal of the petition for certiorari and deemed the case closed and terminated, ordering that an Entry of Judgment be issued. The Court did not pass upon the correctness of the arbitral award, because the settlement had rendered the petition moot.

Doctrine

A compromise settlement freely entered into before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, embodied in a release and quitclaim and a joint motion to dismiss, extinguishes the seafarer's claim and renders a pending petition for certiorari moot. When the parties inform the Court of such a settlement and pray for the withdrawal of the petition, the Court grants the motion, withdraws the petition, and closes and terminates the case. The release operates to discharge the employers and the vessel from every right and claim, whether arising in tort, contract, statutory law, or any other basis of recovery, and the seafarer binds himself not to file further claims or to arrest the vessel. The Court will not rule on the merits of an award that the parties have already settled.

Disposition

The Court granted the Manifestation with Motion, withdrew the petition for certiorari, deemed the case closed and terminated, and ordered the issuance of an Entry of Judgment.

Remember This

The one line to memorize is that a compromise settlement before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, followed by a motion to withdraw, closes and terminates the case and leaves no ruling on the merits. Examiners use this case to test whether a reviewee recognizes that a valid release and quitclaim, coupled with a joint motion to dismiss, renders a pending petition moot and forecloses any further claim by the seafarer.