ELISA MIGUEL RAMOS, FLORENCIA MIGUEL CAPALAD, MAXIMA MIGUEL SABARIAGA, WILFREDO MIGUEL, AND MAURA MIGUEL TIONGSON, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS, VS. SPOUSES AGUSTINA M. VALERIO AND ARM…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Ramos versus Valerio
The Case
This is a civil action for the nullification of deeds, brought by the surviving heirs of the Miguel family — Elisa Miguel Ramos, Florencia Miguel Capalad, Maxima Miguel Sabariaga, Wilfredo Miguel, and Maura Miguel Tiongson — against the spouses Agustina and Armando Valerio, together with Emmanuel Valerio and Miguelito Valerio. The plaintiffs asked the courts to annul a long series of deeds covering registered land in Bulacan: deeds of encumbrances, assignments and transfer of real estate in payment of debt, known as dacion en pago, executed by Ruperto Miguel; deeds of sale of registered land; deeds of sale of co-owner's undivided shares; and extrajudicial settlements adjudicating the estates of the deceased Maria Miguel, Feliciana Miguel, and Ruperto Miguel to a surviving sole heir. The case matters because it shows how strictly a special power of attorney is read: an agent who is given authority to mortgage does not thereby receive authority to sell, and every deed built on that excess of authority falls with it.
Procedural History
The plaintiffs filed their complaint, later amended, in the Regional Trial Court, and the case was decided in their favor. The defendants appealed to the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals rendered a Decision on 22 April 2014, nullifying the deeds in question. The defendants then returned to the same court by filing a Motion for Reconsideration, and the plaintiffs filed their Comment in opposition. The Court of Appeals denied the motion, and that denial is the ruling now before us.
Facts
Ruperto Miguel, together with Maria Miguel and Feliciana Miguel, stood at the center of the controversy. Registered lands in Bulacan, covered by several transfer certificates of title, were the subject of a series of transactions. Ruperto Miguel executed deeds of encumbrances, assignments and transfer of real estate in payment of debt, the dacion en pago deeds, conveying the properties to the Valerios. Deeds of sale of registered land, and deeds of sale of co-owner's undivided shares, were likewise executed. Extrajudicial settlements were also made, adjudicating the estates of the deceased Maria Miguel, Feliciana Miguel, and Ruperto Miguel to a surviving sole heir.
The plaintiffs, who are the surviving heirs of the Miguel family, challenged all of these deeds. They alleged that the dispositions made by Miguelito and Emmanuel Valerio in the deeds of sale were not authorized under the special powers of attorney on which the Valerios relied. The special powers of attorney, the plaintiffs pointed out, did not include the power to dispose of or to sell the properties.
The Valerios defended the deeds. They insisted that the plaintiffs had presented no evidence warranting nullification, and that Emmanuel and Miguelito Valerio were in fact empowered under the special powers of attorney to dispose of the properties as payment for the obligation of Ruperto Miguel. They also raised a procedural objection: the ground on which the deeds were struck down, the absence of a power to dispose or sell in the special powers of attorney, had supposedly never been pleaded by the plaintiffs.
Issues
- Whether or not the plaintiffs raised, as a ground for nullity of the subject deeds, the absence of authority to dispose of or sell in the special powers of attorney.
- Whether or not the special powers of attorney empowered Emmanuel and Miguelito Valerio to dispose of the subject properties in payment of the obligation of Ruperto Miguel.
- Whether or not the deeds should be nullified for having been executed beyond the authority granted in the special powers of attorney.
Applicable Provisions
The decision turns on the principle that an agent acts only within the limits of the authority granted to him. The Court enforced the terms of the special powers of attorney themselves, which did not include the power to dispose of or to sell, and it treated that absence of authority as the measure of the agents' acts. The deeds of sale and the dacion en pago deeds, executed without that power, could not stand.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the contention that the plaintiffs never raised the absence of authority to dispose or sell was without merit. The Court found that the plaintiffs, as early as in their amended complaint, had already pointed out that the dispositions made by Miguelito and Emmanuel Valerio in the deeds of sale were not authorized under the special powers of attorney. The ground was therefore squarely in the pleadings from the beginning.
On the second and third issues, the Court stood by its earlier ruling. The special powers of attorney did not include the power to dispose of or to sell the properties, and the dispositions made under them were unauthorized. The deeds of encumbrances, assignments and transfer of real estate in payment of debt, the deeds of sale of registered land, the deeds of sale of co-owner's undivided shares, and the extrajudicial settlements were all nullified. The Court found the remaining arguments of the Valerios to be a mere rehash of the issues already passed upon in its Decision, and it found no cogent reason to reverse or even to modify that Decision.
Doctrine
An agent's authority is measured strictly by the four corners of the special power of attorney. Where the instrument grants no power to dispose of or to sell, any deed of sale or deed of dacion en pago executed by the agent in excess of that authority is void and produces no effect. A party who would uphold such a deed must point to an express grant of the power exercised, because the power to encumber is not the power to sell. And a ground for nullity pleaded in the amended complaint is timely raised; the opposing party cannot defeat it by claiming it was never presented.
Disposition
The motion for reconsideration was denied, and the Decision of 22 April 2014 nullifying the deeds was affirmed in full.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a special power of attorney that does not include the power to dispose of or to sell cannot support a deed of sale or a dacion en pago. Examiners use this case to test the strict construction of agency authority and the rule that a ground alleged in the amended complaint is a ground properly raised.