EDGAR S. SAN LUIS, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. EDWIN L. FARGAS, DEFENDANT-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
San Luis versus Fargas
The Case
This is an action for damages for malicious prosecution, brought by Edgar San Luis against Edwin Fargas. San Luis, the former President and General Manager of Radio Philippines Network, was charged by Fargas with violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act before the Ombudsman, and that complaint was dismissed for insufficiency of evidence. San Luis then sued Fargas for damages, claiming that the charge was false and malicious. The case matters because it gathers into one decision the whole law of malicious prosecution as a ground for moral damages, and because it shows how the Supreme Court calibrates moral, exemplary, and attorney's fees when no actual damages have been proven.
Procedural History
San Luis filed his complaint for damages before the Regional Trial Court of Sta. Cruz, Laguna. Fargas, instead of filing an answer, moved to dismiss on the ground that the complaint stated no cause of action; the motion was denied for lack of merit. After trial, the court rendered judgment in favor of San Luis, ordering Fargas to pay two million pesos in moral damages, one million pesos in exemplary damages, five hundred thousand pesos in attorney's fees, and the costs of suit. Fargas moved for reconsideration, and the motion was denied, with the trial court declaring its decision final. Fargas then brought an ordinary appeal to the Supreme Court.
Facts
In 1999, President Joseph Estrada directed the streamlining of Radio Philippines Network, then known as RPN-9, and by a letter dated May 13, 1999 expressed his desire that Edgar San Luis be elected President and General Manager. A new Table of Organization was drawn up, and the News and Current Affairs Department headed by Edwin Fargas was merged with the Operations Division. Fargas's office was abolished. On July 12, 1999, San Luis notified Fargas that, pursuant to the audit findings and a Board Resolution, he was to be considered retired effective July 13, 1999, after thirty-one years of continuous service, with retirement pay computed at eighty days' pay for every year of service. Fargas received five million two hundred twenty-three thousand eight hundred ninety-nine pesos and thirteen centavos, and he signed a waiver, release, and quitclaim against the network and its directors and officers.
San Luis also issued a memorandum requiring the return of cars previously provided to executives, and the Board later resolved that San Luis had authority to sign and deliver the contract of sale of a car to the employee who would buy it. In January 2001, San Luis resigned. On March 20, 2001, Fargas filed an affidavit-complaint with the Ombudsman charging San Luis, the Board of Directors, and the Finance and Administration Manager, Vivencio Reyes, with violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act. The complaint was resolved in favor of San Luis for insufficiency of evidence.
As a consequence, San Luis underwent medical treatment for hypertension and depression and incurred hospital expenses. He testified that it was the first time he had ever been charged with an offense, that the stress took him to a cardiologist, and that he hired a law office to defend himself before the Ombudsman. The trial court ruled in his favor, and Fargas appealed, assigning as errors that the evidence was insufficient, that the decision was contrary to law, and that the damages awarded were excessive.
Issues
- Whether or not the elements of malicious prosecution are present so as to make Fargas liable for damages.
- Whether or not San Luis is entitled to moral damages arising from the malicious prosecution.
- Whether or not San Luis is entitled to exemplary damages and attorney's fees.
- Whether or not the amounts awarded as moral damages, exemplary damages, and attorney's fees are excessive and should be reduced.
Applicable Provisions
Article 2217 of the Civil Code defines moral damages and provides:
Moral damages include physical suffering, mental anguish, fright, serious anxiety, besmirched reputation, wounded feelings, moral shock, social humiliation, and similar injury. Though incapable of pecuniary computation, moral damages may be recovered if they are the proximate result of the defendant's wrongful act or omission.
This is the measure of the injury San Luis suffered from the false charge, and it anchors the award of moral damages.
Article 2229 of the Civil Code governs exemplary damages and provides:
Exemplary or corrective damages are imposed, by way of example or correction for the public good, in addition, to the moral, temperate, liquidated or compensatory damages.
Because San Luis was awarded moral damages, exemplary damages may be imposed in addition, by way of example for the public good.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the appeal is devoid of merit. Malicious prosecution is an action for damages brought by one against whom a criminal prosecution, civil suit, or other legal proceeding has been instituted maliciously and without probable cause, after the termination of such proceeding in favor of the defendant therein. To constitute it, there must be proof that the prosecution was prompted by a sinister design to vex or humiliate a person, and that it was initiated deliberately by the defendant knowing that his charges were false and groundless. The elements of malice and absence of probable cause must both be present. The Court found ample basis for the trial court's finding that Fargas's false accusations were prompted only by malice and deliberate intent to harass San Luis. Fargas knew very well that his complaint lacked probable cause, since he had voluntarily signed a quitclaim absolving the network and its officers from liability after receiving his retirement pay. The filing was intended to vex and humiliate San Luis and to blacken his reputation as a businessman and as a politician.
On the second issue, the Court held that malicious prosecution is among the instances in Article 2219 of the Civil Code where moral damages may be recovered. To merit such an award, claimants must prove that they had been denounced or charged falsely, that the complainant knew the charge was false, that the latter acted with malice, and of course, the damages they suffered. All were proven. The Court gave due consideration to San Luis's social and financial status as a businessman and as an elected congressman, and to the mental anguish he suffered from the false imputation.
On the third issue, the Court held that to claim exemplary damages a complainant must show that he is entitled to moral, temperate, or compensatory damages. Since San Luis proved his entitlement to moral damages, the award of exemplary damages was in order. Attorney's fees were justified under paragraphs 1 and 3 of Article 2208 of the Civil Code, which allow attorney's fees when exemplary damages are awarded and in criminal cases of malicious prosecution against the plaintiff.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that moral and exemplary damages are designed to compensate claimants for actual injury and are not meant to enrich the complainant at the expense of the defendant. In instances where no actual damages are adjudicated, the court may reduce moral and exemplary damages. Because the trial court had awarded no actual damages owing to the paucity of evidence, the Court found the sums excessive and unconscionable, and reduced them.
Doctrine
Malicious prosecution as a ground for damages requires two elements: malice, meaning a sinister design to vex or humiliate, and absence of probable cause, meaning the charge was initiated deliberately with knowledge that it was false and groundless. Favorable termination of the prosecution in favor of the defendant is the setting in which the action arises. Moral damages may be recovered for malicious prosecution under Article 2219 of the Civil Code, upon proof that the claimant was falsely charged, that the complainant knew the charge was false, that he acted with malice, and that damages were suffered. Exemplary damages may be added only when the claimant is first entitled to moral, temperate, or compensatory damages. Where no actual damages are adjudicated, moral and exemplary damages, as well as attorney's fees, may be reduced by the court, since these awards compensate for actual injury and are not meant to enrich the complainant.
Disposition
The appeal was denied, and the decision and order of the trial court were affirmed with modification, reducing the moral damages to one hundred thousand pesos, the exemplary damages to twenty-five thousand pesos, and the attorney's fees to fifty thousand pesos. San Luis won.
Remember This
Memorize the twin elements of malicious prosecution, malice and absence of probable cause, and the rule that moral and exemplary damages may be reduced when no actual damages are proven. Examiners use this case to test malicious prosecution as a ground for moral damages and the calibration of excessive awards.