🎧 Case Brief Lecture

FE NOBLEZA, CELEDONIO ACLAN, EDELIZA UNIDA AND MELCHOR OBERO, PETITIONERS, VS. AMELITA TAN, RESPONDENT.

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Nobleza versus Tan

The Case

This is the story of Fe Nobleza, Celedonio Aclan, Edeliza Unida, and Melchor Obero, the petitioners, against Amelita Tan, the respondent. Amelita Tan sued the petitioners for ejectment, claiming that she was the lawful possessor of a house in Pateros, Metro Manila, and that she had merely installed Fe Nobleza as caretaker, who in turn leased out portions of the house to the other petitioners. The petitioners refused to vacate and insisted on their own right of possession. The case matters because the Supreme Court draws a bright line between the two species of ejectment, forcible entry and unlawful detainer, and reminds every practitioner that jurisdiction over an ejectment suit depends on the allegations of the complaint, while the judgment itself depends on proof of the plaintiff's cause of action. It is a compact lesson on pleading, jurisdiction, and the burden of proof in summary ejectment.

Procedural History

Amelita Tan filed an amended complaint for ejectment with a prayer for moral damages before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Pateros, Metro Manila, Branch 73. After the parties submitted their position papers, the Metropolitan Trial Court rendered judgment in favor of Amelita Tan, ordering the petitioners and all persons claiming rights under them to vacate the premises and to pay 500 pesos a month per defendant as reasonable compensation for the use of the property from January 2010 until final vacation, with costs against the defendants.

Dissatisfied, the petitioners appealed to the Regional Trial Court of Pateros, Branch 262, which affirmed the findings of the Metropolitan Trial Court. The Regional Trial Court held that the defendants had admitted their status as mere lessees and had recognized the plaintiff's ownership, so that their possession, lawful during the lease, became unlawful only upon termination of the lease and demand to return possession. The petitioners moved for reconsideration, and the motion was denied for lack of merit.

The petitioners then filed a petition for review under Rule 42 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, asking the Supreme Court to set aside the decision of the Regional Trial Court. They argued that the trial court erred in taking cognizance of the complaint, and that the case was really one for recovery of possession, an accion publiciana, which belongs to the Regional Trial Court and not to the Metropolitan Trial Court.

Facts

Amelita Tan claimed that she was the lawful and previous possessor of a house at 1148 Interior P. Rosales, Barangay Santa Ana, Pateros, Metro Manila. The lot on which the house stood was owned by Winnie and Boyet Raon, who allegedly allowed her to build the house and occupy it from 1970 until 1989. In 1989, because of constant flooding in Pateros, she transferred to nearby Pembo, Makati City, but she did not give up the house. She asked Fe Nobleza to act as caretaker, in charge of leasing out portions of the house and of demanding, collecting, and receiving rents in her behalf, with part of the proceeds going to Fe Nobleza as salary.

In June 2008, Amelita Tan, through her son Alfredo Jimenez, informed Fe Nobleza that she needed to repossess the property for her personal use. All occupants were notified and given three months to vacate. The petitioners refused, claiming a right over the premises they occupied. The matter was referred to the barangay for conciliation, but the effort proved futile. Fe Nobleza then denied being a mere caretaker and asserted her own right over the property, and the other petitioners took the same position, refusing to recognize Amelita Tan as owner of the house.

Amelita Tan formally demanded in a letter dated March 22, 2009 that the petitioners vacate, and the demand was sent to them on September 18, 2009. The petitioners refused to heed the demand, and on October 21, 2009, Amelita Tan filed the ejectment suit. In their answer, the petitioners denied the material allegations and claimed open, continuous, and notorious possession adverse to her. They presented a barangay clearance and certificate showing that Unida and Aclan were registered voters and residents of the property from 2000 to 2010, an affidavit of Fe Nobleza that she had lived there since she was thirteen years old, and a joint affidavit of the other petitioners that they had been residents since 2000. They also noted that the Raons' application for registration of title had been dismissed by the Court of Appeals in a decision dated August 20, 2008, which had become final, and that the petitioners had pending applications with the government to award the land to them.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Metropolitan Trial Court correctly took cognizance of the complaint as one for unlawful detainer, rather than an accion publiciana cognizable by the Regional Trial Court.
  • Whether or not Amelita Tan proved by sufficient evidence her cause of action for unlawful detainer against the petitioners.

Applicable Provisions

Section 1 of Rule 70 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended, defines who may institute ejectment proceedings and when, and it provides:

SECTION 1. Who may institute proceedings, and when. — Subject to the provisions of the next succeeding section, a person deprived of the possession of any land or building by force, intimidation, threat, strategy, or stealth, or a lessor, vendor, vendee, or other person against whom the possession of any land or building is unlawfully withheld after the expiration or termination of the right to hold possession, by virtue of any contract, express or implied, or the legal representatives or assigns of any such lessor, vendor, vendee, or other person, may, at any time within one (1) year after such unlawful deprivation or withholding of possession, bring an action in the proper Municipal Trial Court against the person or persons unlawfully withholding or depriving of possession, or any person or persons claiming under them, for the restitution of such possession, together with damages and costs.

This provision supplies the two species of ejectment, forcible entry and unlawful detainer, and fixes the one-year period and the Municipal Trial Court as the forum, which is the very jurisdictional question the petitioners raised.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Metropolitan Trial Court correctly took cognizance of the case. What determines the nature of the action and the court that has jurisdiction are the allegations in the complaint. The complaint sufficiently alleged a cause of action for unlawful detainer because it recited that the possession of the defendants was initially by contract with or by tolerance of the plaintiff, that it became illegal upon notice of the termination of the right of possession, that the defendants remained in possession and deprived the plaintiff of the enjoyment of the property, and that the complaint was instituted within one year from the last demand. The Court stressed that the rules do not require the plaintiff to use the exact language of the law, so the absence of the word tolerate did not change the nature of the action. It also held that the one-year period is counted from the last demand, and since the last demand letter dated March 22, 2009 was sent on September 18, 2009 and the complaint was filed on October 21, 2009, the action was well within the period. Demand, the Court reminded, is jurisdictional in nature.

On the second issue, however, the Court ruled for the petitioners. The party who asserts, not the one who denies, must prove, and it was Amelita Tan who bore the burden of proving the agreement that the petitioners occupied the property as caretaker or lessees who would vacate upon demand. The Court found that she failed to substantiate an implied contract with Fe Nobleza, presented no proof that she received rentals, offered no evidence of her claimed prior possession, and produced not a single witness to testify that she occupied the premises during the period she claimed. The minutes of the barangay conciliation, which the Metropolitan Trial Court relied on for an alleged admission of payment of rents, could not be found in the records, and the petitioners vehemently denied making any such admission. Against this, the petitioners proved possession for quite some time through their barangay documents and sworn affidavits, and showed that the Raons' application for registration had been dismissed and that the land was not yet owned by anyone except the State.

The Court added an important qualification. The only issue in an unlawful detainer case is physical or material possession, independent of any claim of ownership, although where ownership is raised the courts may pass upon it to determine who has the right to possess. Such a determination is merely provisional and would not bar or prejudice an action between the same parties involving title to the property.

Doctrine

First, the nature of an ejectment action and the jurisdiction of the court are determined by the allegations of the complaint, not by the evidence later presented. A complaint states a cause of action for unlawful detainer when it alleges possession initially by contract or tolerance, termination of the right of possession by notice, continued possession depriving the plaintiff of enjoyment, and filing within one year from the last demand. The exact statutory words need not be used.

Second, the one-year period under Section 1 of Rule 70 is counted from the last demand to vacate, and a demand is jurisdictional in nature.

Third, the plaintiff in ejectment bears the burden of proving the agreement or tolerance on which the action rests, because the party who asserts, not the one who denies, must prove. Failure to prove the cause of action, even if the court validly acquired jurisdiction, warrants dismissal for insufficiency of evidence.

Fourth, the judgment in ejectment settles only physical or material possession; any pronouncement on ownership is provisional and does not bar a separate action on title.

Disposition

The Supreme Court set aside the decision of the Regional Trial Court and dismissed the complaint for unlawful detainer, so the petitioners won.

Remember This

Memorize this line: the allegations of the complaint determine jurisdiction in ejectment, but the plaintiff must still prove the contract or tolerance that makes the possession unlawful. Examiners like to use this case to test the distinction between forcible entry and unlawful detainer, the counting of the one-year period from the last demand, and the rule that an ejectment judgment settles only physical possession.