SPOUSES WILFREDO BOYBOY AND LYDIA BOYBOY, PETITIONERS, VS. ATTY. VICTORIANO R. YABUT, JR., RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Boyboy versus Yabut
The Case
This is an administrative case for disbarment. Spouses Wilfredo Boyboy and Lydia Boyboy accused Atty. Victoriano Yabut, Jr. of blackmail and extortion, and asked that he be disbarred from the practice of law. The case matters because the Supreme Court refused to adopt the recommendation of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines and instead dismissed the complaint, teaching a lesson every Bar candidate must carry: an accusation is not proof, and in administrative proceedings the complainant bears the burden of establishing the charge by substantial evidence, which means more than a mere scintilla of evidence.
Procedural History
The complainants first filed a criminal complaint for grave threats under Article 282 of the Revised Penal Code in connection with the same alleged blackmail and extortion. The Assistant City Prosecutor of Angeles City dismissed that criminal case for lack of probable cause. The complainants then filed this administrative complaint for disbarment before the Supreme Court. The Court referred the matter to the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, and its Committee on Bar Discipline investigated. The Committee dispensed with a full-dress hearing and required the parties to file memoranda, deciding the case on the pleadings. It submitted a Report and Recommendation, adopted by the Integrated Bar, that the respondent be suspended from the practice of law for three months. The case then came before the Supreme Court, which reviewed the recommendation and rendered its own decision.
Facts
Sometime in November 1999, the respondent allegedly called Dr. Lydia Boyboy at her clinic in Angeles City. He supposedly threatened to charge her with estafa before the National Bureau of Investigation and to cause the revocation of her physician's license unless she paid him 300,000 pesos, saying he held incriminatory evidence against her. On the seventh of December 1999, the respondent went to her clinic and personally served on her a subpoena from the National Bureau of Investigation in a case for estafa through falsification of public documents that he had filed against the spouses. The next day, Wilfredo Boyboy visited the respondent at his law office, and the respondent allegedly intimidated him by saying he had already persuaded the Director for Region III of the National Bureau of Investigation to dismiss the case for a consideration of 400,000 pesos.
Appalled by the increased demand, the spouses met with the Director, who denied making any such demand and reacted adversely to the name-dropping. He recommended an entrapment operation, but it did not push through supposedly for lack of funds. The spouses instead filed the criminal complaint and this disbarment case.
The respondent denied the charge and said the complaint was retaliatory. He narrated that he came to know the complainants only when a certain Ms. Arlene Sto. Tomas sought his professional services. She was a member of the entity handling the Medicare benefits of United States veterans and their families, and she discovered that the complainants, among others, received 90,000 dollars from that entity after filing fictitious medical claims in her name and her family's name. The respondent filed criminal cases for estafa through falsification of public documents and for perjury, and an administrative case for the revocation of Dr. Boyboy's license. He claimed the complainants filed cases against Ms. Sto. Tomas and against him to force the withdrawal of those cases.
Issues
- Whether or not the complainants established by substantial evidence their charge of blackmail and extortion against the respondent.
- Whether or not the Committee on Bar Discipline of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines erred in deciding the case on the basis of affidavits and pleadings alone, without receiving testimonial evidence.
- Whether or not the respondent may be held administratively liable on the strength of the complainants' accusations and the weakness of his defense of denial.
Applicable Provisions
The decision invokes the ancient rule on the burden of proof, stated in Latin as ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat, meaning he who asserts, not he who denies, must prove:
Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat.
This rule places the burden on the complainants, who assert the wrongdoing, and frees the respondent from any duty to prove his denial.
The decision also states the standard of substantial evidence required in administrative proceedings:
The standard of substantial evidence required in administrative proceedings is more than a mere scintilla. It means such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion.
This standard governs whether the charge of blackmail and extortion was sufficiently proved.
Finally, the decision states the hornbook doctrine on affidavits whose affiants never take the witness stand:
The hornbook doctrine is that unless the affiants themselves take the witness stand to affirm the averments in their affidavits, those affidavits must be excluded from the proceedings for being inadmissible and hearsay.
This doctrine disposes of the affidavits on which the Committee relied.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the charge was not proved. The records were barren of any evidence of the respondent's culpability. Apart from the complainants' naked assertion that he demanded 300,000 pesos, later raised to 400,000 pesos, no other proof was presented. The Court stressed that a mere charge or allegation of wrongdoing does not suffice, and that accusation is not synonymous with guilt. It noted that the criminal case for grave threats had been dismissed for lack of probable cause, and asked how the Committee could conclude that the evidence crossed the more rigid threshold of substantial evidence when it could not even hurdle the low quantum needed for probable cause.
On the second issue, the Court held that the Committee erred in dispensing with a full-dress hearing. The Committee anchored its recommendation on the credibility of the complainants, yet it never heard the witnesses or observed their deportment. The Court held that since the Committee inexorably anchored its report on credibility, a trial-type hearing became an indispensable requirement in this case. The affidavits, never affirmed on the witness stand, were inadmissible hearsay. The failure of the respondent to appear did not relieve the Committee of its duty to inquire diligently; it should have received the complainants' testimonial evidence ex parte after proper warning.
On the third issue, the Court held that the respondent's denial, though inherently weak, sufficed, for he was not obliged to prove his negative averment. A finding of guilt should come from the strength of the complainants' evidence, not from the weakness of the respondent's defense. The Court also observed that the planned entrapment, a tried and tested method of trapping felons in clandestine crimes such as blackmail and extortion, was not pursued, and that the excuse of lack of funds was lame and flimsy, since a few genuine bills stuffed with blank paper would have sufficed.
Doctrine
He who asserts, not he who denies, must prove. In disbarment and other administrative proceedings, the complainant bears the burden of establishing the charge by substantial evidence, which means such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion, more than a mere scintilla. A mere charge or allegation of wrongdoing does not suffice, for accusation is not synonymous with guilt. The respondent who denies is under no obligation to prove his negative averment, and a finding of guilt should come only from the strength of the complainant's evidence, not from the weakness of the respondent's defense. Affidavits whose affiants never take the witness stand are inadmissible hearsay. While a trial-type hearing is not always required in administrative proceedings, it becomes indispensable when the deciding body anchors its ruling on the credibility of witnesses.
Disposition
The administrative complaint for disbarment against Atty. Victoriano Yabut, Jr. was dismissed, and the respondent won.
Remember This
Memorize the line that accusation is not synonymous with guilt, and that he who asserts, not he who denies, must prove. Examiners use this case in disbarment and administrative discipline questions on the burden of proof, the substantial evidence standard, and the hearsay character of unaffirmed affidavits.