ABBOTT LABORATORIES, PETITIONER, VS. VINCENT S. CHAN, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Abbott Laboratories versus Chan
The Case
This is a petition for review under Rule 43 of the Rules of Court, filed by Abbott Laboratories against Vincent S. Chan. Abbott asks the Supreme Court to set aside the decision of the Director General of the Intellectual Property Office, which sustained the earlier ruling of the Director of the Bureau of Legal Affairs dismissing Abbott's opposition to Chan's trademark application. Abbott is the prior registrant of the mark "EYE-Q" for infant formula and its ingredients; Chan seeks to register the nearly identical mark "Eye Q" for pencils, crayons, pens, and other school and office supplies. The case matters because it is the Court's cleanest statement that an identical mark, by itself, does not bar registration where the goods of the two parties are unrelated — and it draws the line sharply against the confusion-of-business doctrine in Dermaline.
Procedural History
Abbott filed a verified Notice of Opposition before the Bureau of Legal Affairs of the Intellectual Property Office, invoking paragraphs (d), (e), (f) and (g) of Section 123.1 of the Intellectual Property Code. Chan did not file an Answer, and the case was submitted for decision. The Director of the Bureau of Legal Affairs dismissed the opposition, holding that while the marks were identical, the goods covered were neither the same nor closely related, so there could be no confusing similarity. Abbott appealed to the Director General of the Intellectual Property Office, which likewise dismissed the appeal, agreeing that the goods were unrelated and rejecting the argument on normal expansion of business. Abbott then filed the present petition for review with the Supreme Court, raising for the first time the argument that its mark is a fanciful mark entitled to protection even as against unrelated goods.
Facts
Abbott had registered in the Philippines the mark "EYE-Q" and its variations, for goods under Class 5 of the Nice International Classification — infant formula and ingredients for infant formula. Its mark is written in Times New Roman, size 18, in black and white, all letters in uppercase, with a dash between "EYE" and "Q."
On 21 December 2010, Chan filed an application to register the mark "Eye Q" for goods under Class 16 — pencils, crayons, water and poster color, rulers, scissors, punchers, staplers, templates, artist brushes, chalk, coloring paint, sharpeners, pens, adhesive, fasteners, expanding files, paper clips, stamp pads, plastic material for packaging, blades, staple wire, daters, and numbering machines. Chan's mark is in Rockwell Extra Bold, sizes 18 and 24, in red, with only the letters "E" and "Q" in uppercase and no dash between them.
Upon publication of Chan's application, Abbott filed its Notice of Opposition, claiming prior use and first registration of the "EYE-Q" marks and alleging that Chan's mark was confusingly similar, if not identical, and would cause confusion, mistake, and deception to the purchasing public. Both the Bureau of Legal Affairs and the Director General found the marks identical but the goods unrelated, and dismissed the opposition. Abbott elevated the matter to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not Chan's mark "Eye Q" is barred from registration under paragraph (e) of Section 123.1 of the Intellectual Property Code, given that the competing marks are used on goods that are not identical or similar.
- Whether or not the registration of Chan's mark is proscribed under paragraphs (d), (f) and (g) of Section 123.1 because the similarity of the marks is likely to deceive, cause confusion, or mislead the public.
- Whether or not the doctrine of confusion of business, as applied in Dermaline, extends to this case so as to bar Chan's registration.
- Whether or not Abbott's argument that "EYE-Q" is a fanciful mark may be considered when raised for the first time on petition for review.
Applicable Provisions
Paragraphs (d), (e), (f) and (g) of Section 123.1 of the Intellectual Property Code provide:
"(d) Is identical with a registered mark belonging to a different proprietor or a mark with an earlier filing or priority date, in respect of: (i) The same goods or services, or (ii) Closely related goods or services, or (iii) If it nearly resembles such a mark as to be likely to deceive or cause confusion; (e) Is identical with, or confusingly similar to, or constitutes a translation of a mark which is considered by the competent authority of the Philippines to be well-known internationally and in the Philippines, whether or not it is registered here, as being already the mark of a person other than the applicant for registration, and used for identical or similar goods or services: Provided, That in determining whether a mark is well-known, account shall be taken of the knowledge of the relevant sector of the public, rather than of the public at large, including knowledge in the Philippines which has been obtained as a result of the promotion of the mark; (f) Is identical with, or confusingly similar to, or constitutes a translation of a mark considered well-known in accordance with the preceding paragraph, which is registered in the Philippines with respect to goods or services which are not similar to those with respect to which registration is applied for: Provided, That use of the mark in relation to those goods or services would indicate a connection between those goods or services, and the owner of the registered mark: Provided further, That the interests of the owner of the registered mark are likely to be damaged by such use; (g) Is likely to mislead the public, particularly as to the nature, quality, characteristics or geographical origin of the goods or services;"
These are the very grounds Abbott invoked, and the Court measures each one against the relationship of the goods and the likelihood of confusion.
Section 138 of the Intellectual Property Code provides:
"A certificate of registration of a mark shall be prima facie evidence of the validity of the registration, the registrant's ownership of the mark, and of the registrant's exclusive right to use the same in connection with the goods or services and those that are related thereto specified in the certificate."
This limits the protection of Abbott's registered mark to infant formula and related goods, and cannot be stretched to cover Chan's school and office supplies.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that Chan's application cannot be denied under paragraph (e) of Section 123.1. That provision requires that the competing marks be used for identical or similar goods or services, and Abbott's registrations are for Class 5 goods while Chan's application covers Class 16 goods. The goods are not identical or similar.
On the second issue, the Court held that the application is not proscribed under paragraphs (d), (f) and (g), because the similarity between the marks is not likely to deceive, cause confusion, or mislead the public. Likelihood of confusion is a relative term, to be determined according to the peculiar circumstances of each case. The Court distinguished the two types of confusion:
"The first is the confusion of goods 'in which event the ordinarily prudent purchaser would be induced to purchase one product in the belief that he was purchasing the other.' In which case, 'defendant's goods are then bought as the plaintiff's, and the poorer quality of the former reflects adversely on the plaintiff's reputation.' The other is the confusion of business: 'Here though the goods of the parties are different, the defendant's product is such as might reasonably be assumed to originate with the plaintiff, and the public would then be deceived either into that belief or into the belief that there is some connection between the plaintiff and defendant which, in fact, does not exist.'"
There can be no confusion of goods because the goods are not identical, similar, or related, and the businesses are not in competition. Nor is there confusion of business: goods are related when they belong to the same class or have the same descriptive properties, possess the same physical attributes or essential characteristics as to form, composition, texture or quality, or serve the same purpose or are sold in the same stores. The Court found "a whale of a difference" between infant formula and school supplies, which are sold in different and separate outlets. Since Abbott's marks are used on infant formula, the protection of Section 138 is limited to such goods and those related thereto, and cannot be used against Chan's application.
On the third issue, the Court held that Dermaline does not apply, because there the products, though in different classifications, both pertained to treatments for the skin and were very closely related. Here, there is no such relation, and it was not shown that Abbott had ventured or intended to venture into producing Class 16 goods, so the possibility of damage is very remote.
On the fourth issue, the Court refused to consider the fanciful-mark argument because it was raised for the first time on petition for review, and an issue raised for the first time on appeal is barred by estoppel.
Doctrine
An identical or confusingly similar mark does not, by itself, bar registration. Under paragraph (e) of Section 123.1, the competing marks must be used on identical or similar goods or services; under paragraphs (d), (f) and (g), there must be a likelihood of confusion, deception, or misleading of the public. The protection of a registered mark under Section 138 extends only to the goods specified in the certificate and those related thereto. Goods are related when they belong to the same class or have the same descriptive properties, possess the same physical attributes or essential characteristics as to form, composition, texture or quality, or serve the same purpose or are sold in the same stores. Confusion of business requires that the goods be so related that the public would reasonably assume they originate from the same source. An issue not raised before the Bureau of Legal Affairs or the Director General cannot be raised for the first time on petition for review.
Disposition
The petition for review was denied due course and dismissed; Chan prevailed, and the dismissal of Abbott's opposition to the registration of "Eye Q" stands.
Remember This
Memorize the line: an identical trademark may be used by different manufacturers for non-competing and unrelated goods. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between confusion of goods and confusion of business, and to test whether a candidate knows that the relatedness of goods, not the identity of the marks alone, decides a trademark opposition.