🎧 Case Brief Lecture

REPORT ON THE ON-THE-SPOT JUDICIAL AUDIT CONDUCTED IN THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, BRANCHES 45 AND 53, BACOLOD CITY.

A.M. NO. 00-2-65-RTC. February 15, 2005 February 15, 2005

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Report on the Judicial Audit in the Regional Trial Court, Branches 45 and 53, Bacolod City

The Case

This is an administrative matter arising from the on-the-spot judicial audit conducted by the Judicial Audit Team of the Office of the Court Administrator in the Regional Trial Court of Bacolod City, Branches 45 and 53, presided over by Judge Edgardo L. De Los Santos and Judge Pepito B. Gellada. It is not a suit between private parties but a disciplinary proceeding initiated by the Supreme Court itself against judges and branch clerks of court for failure to decide cases and resolve pending incidents within the reglementary period. It matters to every reviewee because it fixes the rule that inability to decide within the required period is not excusable and constitutes gross inefficiency, and it clarifies when a judgment of an appellate court need not be promulgated.

Procedural History

The audit was conducted on September 8 and 9, 1999. Acting on the audit report, the Supreme Court issued a Resolution dated February 23, 2000, directing Judge De Los Santos and Judge Gellada to explain their failure to decide and resolve cases within the ninety-day reglementary period, to render the missing decisions, to take appropriate action on dormant cases, and to submit reports of compliance. The branch clerks of court, Connie F. Tan for Branch 45 and Victor B. Tañoso for Branch 53, were likewise directed to report on promulgations and to cause the completion of transcripts of stenographic notes. The judges and clerks submitted their respective letters of explanation and compliance. In a Resolution dated April 1, 2002, the Court referred the matter to the Office of the Court Administrator for evaluation, report and recommendation, and the Office submitted its Memorandum dated May 29, 2002. The case was resolved by the Supreme Court as an administrative matter in its own original jurisdiction.

Facts

The audit found that Judge De Los Santos had failed to decide or resolve within the ninety-day period a large number of cases, both those he tried in full and those appealed from the inferior courts, as well as pending incidents in many others. When directed to explain, he asked for repeated extensions, and in his letter dated August 15, 2000 he reported that all the enumerated cases had been decided or resolved except the inherited Civil Case No. 261, which he promised to decide by August 31, 2000. In truth, many decisions came months and even years after the due dates, and Civil Case No. 7556 remained undecided. He attributed the delays to his designation as acting presiding judge in other branches, his sessions in Kabankalan City, his weekly five-hour travel to his hometown, his poor health, and the death of his mother. He never requested an extension of time to decide the cases, except once, on May 4, 2000, for Civil Case No. 261, long after the period had lapsed.

Judge Gellada, for his part, decided Civil Case No. 96-9412 on March 15, 2000 when it was due on July 11, 1999, and resolved the incidents in Criminal Case No. 13339 and decided that case on April 5, 2000 when the incidents were due on May 25, 1998. He blamed the delay on the late transcription of stenographic notes. He also failed to report whether he had decided Criminal Cases Nos. 170 and 1128 and Civil Cases Nos. 4498 and 4628, and whether he had acted on several dormant criminal cases.

As to the clerks, Clerk of Court Tan substantially complied, causing the completion of transcripts and reporting the promulgations. Clerk of Court Tañoso reported that Criminal Case No. 98-19422, an appealed case, was decided on September 30, 1999 but was not promulgated because their practice was to dispense with promulgation in appealed cases and simply serve copies of the decision. He could not produce the transcripts in Criminal Case No. 1128 because the stenographers could no longer be located.

Issues

  • Whether or not Judge De Los Santos is administratively liable for gross inefficiency for failing to decide and resolve cases within the reglementary period.
  • Whether or not Judge Gellada is administratively liable for gross inefficiency for deciding cases beyond the reglementary period, and whether the late transcription of stenographic notes excuses the delay.
  • Whether or not the failure to promulgate the decision in an appealed case, Criminal Case No. 98-19422, is a violation of the rules on promulgation.
  • Whether or not the branch clerks of court complied with the directives of the Court.

Applicable Provisions

Section 15, paragraph 1, Article VIII of the Constitution provides:

Section 15. (1) All cases or matters filed after the effectivity of this Constitution must be decided or resolved within twenty-four months from date of submission for the Supreme Court, and, unless reduced by the Supreme Court, twelve months for all lower collegiate courts, and three months for all other lower courts.

This fixes the three-month period for the regional trial courts that both judges violated.

Section 9 of Rule 140 of the Revised Rules of Court provides:

Section 9. Less Serious Charges. — Less serious charges include: . . . (2) Undue delay in rendering a decision or order, or in transmitting the records of a case.

This classifies the offense with which the judges were charged.

Section 11 of the same Rule provides:

Section 11. Sanctions. — . . . B. If the respondent is guilty of a less serious charge, any of the following sanctions shall be imposed: (1) Suspension from office without salary and other benefits for not less than one (1) nor more than three (3) months; or (2) A fine of more than 10,000 pesos but not exceeding 20,000 pesos.

This supplies the range of penalties actually imposed on the two judges.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held Judge De Los Santos guilty of gross inefficiency. His heavy caseload and deteriorating health mitigate but do not exonerate him. The Court ruled that inability to decide a case within the required period is not excusable and constitutes gross inefficiency, and reminded judges that whenever they cannot decide on time, all they have to do is inform the Court and request an extension. He never did so in a timely manner.

On the second issue, the Court held Judge Gellada equally liable. It ruled that judges are not required to await the transcription of stenographic notes before rendering a decision, since otherwise they could easily find justification for failing to comply with the mandatory period. Proper and efficient court management is the responsibility of the judge. Having totally heard the two cases, he was not justified in deciding them late on the ground of delayed transcripts.

On the third issue, the Court held that no promulgation was needed in Criminal Case No. 98-19422. The judgment which the rule requires to be promulgated is the sentence rendered by the trial court, not the judgment of the appellate court sent to the trial court, for it is presumed that the accused or his attorney had already been notified by the appellate court. The copy is sent to the trial court not for promulgation but for execution.

On the fourth issue, the Court accepted the compliance of Clerk of Court Tan as satisfactory, noted that of Clerk of Court Tañoso, and directed him to submit copies of two decisions.

Doctrine

A judge's failure to decide a case or resolve a pending incident within the three-month period fixed by Section 15, paragraph 1, Article VIII of the Constitution constitutes gross inefficiency and warrants administrative sanction under Rule 140. Heavy caseload and poor health mitigate liability but do not exonerate. The remedy for an overburdened judge is to request an extension of time from the Court, not to let the period lapse in silence. A judge may not await the transcription of stenographic notes before deciding, because court management is the judge's own responsibility. Finally, the judgment of an appellate court sent to the trial court for execution need not be promulgated, since promulgation concerns the sentence rendered by the trial court.

Disposition

Judge De Los Santos was found guilty of gross inefficiency and fined 20,000 pesos, and was directed to decide Civil Case No. 7556; Judge Gellada was found guilty of gross inefficiency and fined 11,000 pesos, and was directed to decide the pending cases, act on the dormant ones, and cause the completion of the missing transcripts; the explanation of Clerk of Court Tan was accepted, and Clerk of Court Tañoso was directed to submit copies of two decisions.

Remember This

Memorize the line that inability to decide a case within the required period is not excusable and constitutes gross inefficiency. Examiners use this case to test the constitutional three-month period for lower courts, the mitigating effect of caseload and health, and the rule that an appellate judgment sent to the trial court for execution need not be promulgated.