🎧 Case Brief Lecture

RE: ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS OCA IPI NO. 97-228-P (JUDGE RAFAEL P. SANTELICES VS. LOIDA B. SAMAR, UTILITY AIDE, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT-LIBRARY, LEGAZPI CITY); AND OCA IPI NO. 97-383…

A.M. No. 00-1394. January 15, 2002 January 15, 2002

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Santelices versus Samar

The Case

This is an administrative matter in which Judge Rafael P. Santelices of the Regional Trial Court of Legazpi City, Branch 2, filed a series of complaints against Loida B. Samar, a Utility Aide assigned to the Regional Trial Court Library Unit of the same city. The complaints charge her with misconduct, dishonesty, insubordination, conduct unbecoming a public officer, and deceit, arising from her refusal to sign an office logbook, her unexplained absences and the erasures she made on her bundy card, her loitering during office hours, and an incident in which she was seen slapping and dragging her own mother within the premises of the Hall of Justice. The case matters because it states, in the clearest terms, the standard of conduct demanded of every employee of the judiciary, from the judge down to the lowest personnel, and because it shows how the Supreme Court calibrates the penalty to the circumstances rather than accepting the recommendation below without question.

Procedural History

The complaints were filed directly with the Supreme Court, which on 19 July 1999 referred them to Executive Judge Vladimir B. Brusola of the Regional Trial Court of Legazpi City for investigation, report, and recommendation. Judge Brusola found the charges founded and recommended a fine of 10,000 pesos in each of the two consolidated complaint groups. The Court then referred the matter to the Office of the Court Administrator for further evaluation, report, and recommendation. The Office of the Court Administrator, in its memorandum of 25 April 2000, agreed that the charges were substantially established but recommended suspension for six months without pay, with a stern warning. The case thus reached the Supreme Court as an original administrative matter, resolved on the basis of the investigating judge's report and the evaluation of the Office of the Court Administrator.

Facts

Judge Santelices charged that Samar, who had been detailed to his office, refused to comply with the office policy requiring personnel to sign a logbook in addition to using the bundy clock. He alleged that she was often seen loitering in downtown Legazpi City during office hours with a lady companion with whom she was supposedly living under scandalous and immoral circumstances, and that she had slept for two nights in the court library with that companion. He further alleged that she did not report for work from 24 March to 01 April 1997 without filing any application for leave, yet her bundy card showed her as having reported for work on those dates; when she returned on 02 April 1997, she filed a leave application and erased the time in and out entries on her bundy card, indicating instead that she was on leave.

A second complaint concerned an incident on 18 November 1997, between 1:30 and 2:00 in the afternoon, when Samar's mother, Aurelia B. Samar, was on her way to the chambers of Judge Santelices. Samar was seen slapping and dragging her mother toward the door on the east side of the building. Two court personnel, Germelina Jadie and Rey Fernandez, witnessed the commotion and tried to pacify her, and both executed affidavits. Judge Santelices, informed by Jadie, went to the scene and saw Samar still yelling at her mother.

A third complaint, consolidated with the second, charged Samar with acts unbecoming a public officer as well as falsification, forgery, and dishonesty. A few days after the November incident, her mother went to the judge's office to inquire about a letter sent to her by Samar, to which was attached an affidavit supposedly executed by Geminiano Aringo, Jr., the process server in the judge's sala, stating that Samar had shown him a list of the money she regularly sent her mother. When summoned, Aringo denied having executed the affidavit. In her answer, Samar denied knowledge of the logbook policy, claimed she left the Hall of Justice only on the judge's own errands, explained that she shared a boarding room with another woman only because she could not afford the rent alone, and said she had gone to Catanduanes to visit her sick father, admitting the erasures on her bundy card but only to reflect her absences. She claimed the affidavits against her were fabricated, and her mother executed an affidavit denying that any untoward incident occurred.

Issues

  • Whether or not Samar is guilty of misconduct, dishonesty, insubordination, and conduct unbecoming a public officer on the basis of the charges against her.
  • Whether or not the erasures she made on her bundy card constitute dishonesty.
  • Whether or not the affidavit of her mother, recanting or denying the charges, should be given weight.
  • Whether or not the penalty recommended by the Office of the Court Administrator is appropriate.

Applicable Provisions

Section 4, paragraph b, of Republic Act Number 6713, the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees, provides:

Public officials and employees shall perform and discharge their duties with the highest degree of excellence, professionalism, intelligence and skill.

This is the standard the Court invokes in holding that Samar fell short of the degree of professionalism expected of a public official.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court agreed with the evaluation of the Office of the Court Administrator that the conduct exhibited by Samar showed she had fallen short of the degree of professionalism expected of a public official. It held that employees of the judiciary particularly should be living examples of uprightness not only in the performance of official duties but also in their personal and private dealings with other people, so as to preserve at all times the good name and standing of the courts in the community. The image of a court as a true temple of justice, the Court said, is aptly mirrored in the conduct, official or otherwise, of the men and women who work there, from the judge to the least and lowest of its personnel.

On the second issue, the Court adopted the finding of the Office of the Court Administrator that there was no substantial evidence that Samar had caused somebody to punch her attendance card while she was absent, and that the erasures she later made were in fact done to reflect her absence during the period. On the charge of falsification and forgery, however, both the investigating judge and the Office of the Court Administrator concluded that the unsigned draft affidavit of Aringo, drafted without his knowledge and consent, nevertheless indicated that Samar had less than an honest motive in using it.

On the third issue, the Court gave weight to the declarations of the witnesses to the November incident and saw nothing to indicate that they would have testified falsely against Samar. It downgraded the affidavit of her mother, explaining that the outcome of the case could not be made dependent on the subsequent recantation of charges and on the whims and caprices of the personalities involved, especially where the integrity and credibility of the judiciary and the people comprising it were at stake.

On the fourth issue, the Court held that the recommended penalty of six months suspension without pay appeared a bit harsh, and that a three-month suspension without pay would be more reasonable given the circumstances.

Doctrine

Every employee of the judiciary, from the judge to the least and lowest of its personnel, must be a living example of uprightness, not only in the performance of official duties but also in personal and private dealings with others, so that the good name and standing of the courts are preserved at all times. This is the demand of Section 4, paragraph b, of Republic Act Number 6713, which requires public officials and employees to perform and discharge their duties with the highest degree of excellence, professionalism, intelligence, and skill. A public officer's misconduct need not be committed in the discharge of official functions to be administratively punishable, because the image of the court as a temple of justice is mirrored in the conduct, official or otherwise, of all who work there. Finally, a recantation or affidavit of desistance executed by a complainant or a witness does not bind the Court in administrative disciplinary cases, since the integrity of the judiciary cannot be made to depend on the whims and caprices of the personalities involved.

Disposition

The Court found Loida B. Samar guilty of misconduct and suspended her for three months without pay, with a stern warning that a repetition of similar infractions would be dealt with most severely.

Remember This

Memorize the line that the image of a court as a true temple of justice is mirrored in the conduct, official or otherwise, of its personnel from the judge to the least and lowest of them. Examiners use this case to test the standard of conduct of judiciary employees under Republic Act Number 6713 and the rule that recantations do not defeat administrative liability.