🎧 Case Brief Lecture

BENILDA M. MADDELA, COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. ROSALIE DALLONG-GALICINAO, RESPONDENT.

A.C. No. 6491 (CBD No. 03-1060). January 31, 2005 January 31, 2005

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Maddela versus Dallong-Galicinao

The Case

This is an administrative case for disbarment and disciplinary action. Benilda Madella, a court clerk, filed a complaint against Atty. Rosalie Dallong-Galicinao, who was then the Clerk of Court and Ex-Officio Provincial Sheriff of the Regional Trial Court of Bambang, Nueva Vizcaya. The complainant alleged acts unbecoming a public servant and a lawyer, grave misconduct, and slander, arising from a money-lending arrangement, a confrontation over a cash gift check, and the respondent's act of notarizing documents outside the area of her notarial commission. The case matters because it clarifies the Court's disciplinary authority over a court official who is also a lawyer, and because it treats notarization as a function invested with public interest, the abuse of which may be sanctioned even when the wrong was committed before the respondent became a member of the Bar.

Procedural History

The complainant filed an affidavit-complaint with the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, docketed as CBD No. 03-1060, praying for the respondent's disbarment. On the same affidavit, she filed an administrative complaint with the Office of the Court Administrator, docketed as OCA IPI No. 03-1554-P, which was referred to Executive Judge Jose Godofredo M. Naui of the Regional Trial Court of Bambang, Nueva Vizcaya, for investigation, report, and recommendation. The respondent moved to suspend the proceedings in the disbarment case in view of the pendency of the administrative complaint, but the motion was denied.

Commissioner Rebecca Villanueva-Maala submitted her report and recommendation, finding that the respondent had disproved the charges of being the complainant's creditor and of unlawfully claiming her deceased husband's salary and higher tax deductions, but recommending suspension from the practice of law for six months for notarizing outside her commission and for obtaining the complainant's judicial development fund checks. The Board of Governors of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines issued a resolution annulling that recommendation, dismissing the complaint as to the charge of collecting a loan for which she acted as guarantor, and imposing only the penalty of reprimand for notarizing outside her commission. The matter reached the Supreme Court, which affirmed the dismissal of the administrative complaint to the extent covered by the parallel administrative case, in which the respondent had already been severely reprimanded for simple misconduct, warned, and ordered to replace the broken glass top. The only remaining issue before the Court was the respondent's liability for notarizing outside the area of her commission.

Facts

The complainant alleged that in July 1999 she received forty thousand pesos from the respondent as a loan at five percent interest per month. In November 2001, with part of the loan unpaid, the respondent went to the complainant's office, took her cash gift check worth five thousand pesos in her absence and without her knowledge, uttered unsavory and humiliating words, encashed the check without the complainant's endorsement, and applied the proceeds to the interest. From January to November 2002, the respondent collected from the complainant one-half of the face value of the checks the complainant received from the Judiciary Development Fund. On 10 December 2002, the respondent demanded one-half of the value of a five thousand peso cash gift check; the complainant refused, and the respondent raised her voice, uttered unsavory remarks, and banged her fist on the table, breaking its glass top, in the presence of several witnesses.

To support the complaint, the complainant attached a confidential letter-complaint of Benjamin Rilloraza opposing the respondent's admission to the Bar, alleging that the respondent had notarized documents in Bayombong, Nueva Vizcaya, outside the area of her commission, and that she continued to receive and encash her deceased husband's salary checks and to claim the higher deductions of a married individual. The complainant also presented a certification of Executive Judge Jose B. Rosales stating that the respondent was never appointed as a notary public for Bayombong during the period from 1 January 1997 to December 2003.

The respondent denied lending money, claiming she merely brokered a loan from Josue B. Liclican and acted as guarantor out of pity. She claimed a verbal agreement authorized her to obtain the cash gift check, and presented an authorization signed by the complainant on 8 January 2002 allowing her to receive the fund checks and apply half as installment payment. She showed that she had promptly informed the Office of the Court Administrator of her husband's death and had declared herself head of the family in her income tax return. As to the notarizations, she explained that she did them to accommodate relatives and without profit.

Issues

  • Whether or not the respondent may be disciplined for notarizing documents outside the area of her notarial commission, although that act was not among the grounds relied upon in the complainant's affidavit-complaint.
  • Whether or not the respondent's explanation that she notarized as a favor to relatives and without profit excuses the act.
  • Whether or not the respondent may be disciplined as a lawyer for a misconduct committed while she was not yet a member of the Bar, and what penalty is proper.

Applicable Provisions

The Court applied its Resolution in A.M. No. 02-9-02-SC, which took effect on 1 October 2002, providing:

An administrative case against a court official who is a lawyer, based on grounds which are likewise grounds for the disciplinary action of members of the Bar, shall be considered as disciplinary proceedings against such official both as a court official and as a member of the Bar.

This provision authorized the Court to treat the administrative complaint against the respondent, a court official and a lawyer, as a disciplinary proceeding against her in both capacities.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that although the act of notarizing outside the area of her commission was not one of the grounds relied upon in the affidavit-complaint, the Court could not turn a blind eye to it, considering the respondent's admission that she did the act. For that, as correctly held by the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, the respondent must be disciplined. The Court stressed that notarization is not an empty, meaningless, routinary act; it is invested with substantive public interest, such that only those who are qualified or authorized may act as notaries public, and those not qualified must be prevented from imposing upon the public, the courts, and the administrative offices. Notarization by a notary public converts a private document into a public document, making it admissible in evidence without further proof of authenticity.

On the second issue, the Court was not satisfied with the explanation that the respondent notarized outside her area as a favor to relatives and for free. Whether she derived profit from the act is of no moment; the fact remains that she notarized outside the area of her commission.

On the third issue, the Court noted that the respondent's misconduct as a notary public was committed while she was not yet a lawyer, so she could not be disciplinarily dealt with as a lawyer. The penalty should therefore be meted to her as a notary public before her admission to the Bar, and a fine would be a sufficient sanction. The reprimand recommended by the Integrated Bar of the Philippines was too light.

Doctrine

Notarization is not an empty, meaningless, routinary act; it is invested with substantive public interest, and only those qualified or authorized may act as notaries public. Notarizing outside the area of one's commission is misconduct, and the absence of profit or the fact that the act was a favor to relatives is no defense. A court official who is also a lawyer may be disciplined both as a court official and as a member of the Bar under the Court's resolution in A.M. No. 02-9-02-SC. Where the misconduct as a notary public was committed before admission to the Bar, the penalty is imposed on the respondent as a notary public, not as a lawyer, and a fine may suffice.

Disposition

The Court modified the resolution of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines and imposed on Atty. Rosalie Dallong-Galicinao a fine of ten thousand pesos for misconduct as a notary public.

Remember This

Memorize the line that notarization is not an empty, meaningless, routinary act but is invested with substantive public interest. Examiners use this case to test the scope of the Court's disciplinary authority over lawyer court officials and the sanction for notarizing outside one's commission, especially when the act predates admission to the Bar.