NICANOR B. GATMAYTAN, JR., COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. ISIDRO C. ILAO, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Gatmaytan versus Ilao
The Case
This is a disbarment case that became a lesson in procedure. Atty. Nicanor Gatmaytan, Jr., a practicing lawyer, filed a complaint for disbarment before the Commission on Bar Discipline of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines against Atty. Isidro Ilao, his opposing counsel in a civil case, accusing him of violating Canons 8, 10, and 15 of the Code of Professional Responsibility. The complaint was dismissed without any formal investigation, and Gatmaytan appealed to the Supreme Court, insisting that an investigation was mandatory. The case matters because the Supreme Court uses it to draw the line between the two modes open to an Investigator under Rule 139-B of the Rules of Court: to dismiss a complaint outright when it lacks merit, or to proceed with a formal investigation when it does not.
Procedural History
Gatmaytan filed his complaint for disbarment before the Commission on Bar Discipline of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines on 05 August 2002. After the parties exchanged pleadings, Investigating Commissioner Milagros V. San Juan issued her Report and Recommendation on 04 April 2003, recommending dismissal of the complaint for lack of merit. On 26 April 2003, the Board of Governors of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines passed a Resolution adopting and approving that recommendation, and the disbarment case was dismissed. Gatmaytan moved for reconsideration on 10 July 2003, but the Board denied it on 30 August 2003, having already endorsed the matter to the Supreme Court and thus no longer exercising jurisdiction over it. The Supreme Court, in a resolution dated 12 January 2004, treated Gatmaytan's Motion for Reconsideration as an appeal to the Supreme Court of the earlier IBP resolution. Hence, the appeal.
Facts
Atty. Gatmaytan represented Teofista Payuran in a civil case for cancellation of title before the Regional Trial Court of Pasay City, Branch 109. Atty. Ilao was counsel for the respondents in that case. On 17 August 1995, Gatmaytan received the Decision rendered by Judge Lilia C. Lopez, which ordered Payuran to pay substantial amounts in rentals, interest, and attorney's fees, and ordered Payuran, Atty. Augusto Gatmaytan, and others to pay moral and exemplary damages.
Gatmaytan filed a Motion for Reconsideration, which was denied, and then filed a second Motion for Reconsideration, which was likewise denied, with notice received on 26 December 1995. On 08 January 1996, he filed a notice of appeal, but the trial court denied it due course on the ground that the appeal was already time-barred. Gatmaytan then filed a Petition for Certiorari and Mandamus before the Court of Appeals on behalf of Payuran.
On 14 February 2002, while that petition was pending, Atty. Ilao filed a complaint for disbarment against Gatmaytan before the Supreme Court. On 07 March 2002, Ilao, in his personal capacity and as attorney-in-fact of his co-plaintiffs, filed a complaint for damages before the Regional Trial Court of Nasugbu, Batangas, Branch 14, against Gatmaytan, Payuran, and Atty. Augusto Gatmaytan. On 05 August 2002, Gatmaytan filed his own complaint for disbarment against Ilao, claiming that by filing the damages case in Batangas, Ilao made false representations and advice to his clients, committed falsehood, misled the court, and misused the Rules of Procedure.
Issues
- Whether or not the Investigating Commissioner was required to conduct a formal investigation of the complaint for disbarment before dismissing it for lack of merit.
- Whether or not the dismissal of the complaint by the Board of Governors of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, upon the recommendation of the Investigating Commissioner, was proper.
Applicable Provisions
Section 5 of Rule 139-B of the Rules of Court provides:
Section 5. Service or dismissal. If the complaint appears to be meritorious, the Investigator shall direct that a copy thereof be served upon the respondent, requiring him to answer the same within fifteen (15) days from the date of service. If the complaint does not merit action, or if the answer shows to the satisfaction of the Investigator that the complaint is not meritorious, the same may be dismissed by the Board of Governors upon his recommendation.
This provision is the source of the Investigator's power to recommend outright dismissal when the complaint lacks merit, which is exactly what happened here.
Section 8 of Rule 139-B of the Rules of Court provides:
Section 8. Investigation. Upon joinder of issues or upon failure of the respondent to answer, the Investigator shall, with deliberate speed, proceed with the investigation of the case. He shall have the power to issue subpoenas and administer oaths. The respondent shall be given full opportunity to defend himself, to present witnesses on behalf, and be heard by himself and counsel. However, if upon reasonable notice, the respondent fails to appear, the investigation shall proceed ex parte.
This provision defines when a formal investigation must proceed, and the Court reads it together with Section 5 to show that investigation is not always mandatory.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the Investigator has two modes of initiatory action upon a complaint: either to dismiss it without delay or to proceed with the investigation. The Court laid out the instances with precision. The Investigator shall proceed with the investigation if the complaint appears to be meritorious; or upon joinder of the issues, when the answer shows that the complaint is indeed meritorious; or if the respondent fails to answer. On the other hand, the Investigator may recommend dismissal if the complaint lacks merit, or if the answer shows, to the satisfaction of the Investigator, that the complaint is not meritorious. It is therefore within the sound discretion of the Investigator to determine whether the complaint is meritorious and whether an investigation must ensue.
Here, Commissioner San Juan did not see the need to conduct an investigation because the instances when an investigation shall push through did not arise. Atty. Ilao submitted his answer, the parties exchanged pleadings, and the Commissioner determined that the complaint did not merit action and must be dismissed. The Court quoted with approval her reasoning: the complaint for damages was filed precisely because of the petition for certiorari and mandamus filed by Payuran with Gatmaytan's assistance; whether the claim for damages had merit was not relevant; and the right to litigate is guaranteed by the Constitution, so that the adverse result of an action does not per se make the action wrongful. On the claim of improper venue, the Commissioner noted that one of the plaintiffs, Ilao himself, was a resident of Nasugbu, Batangas, and since venue may be the residence of the defendants or of the plaintiffs at the option of the plaintiffs, the case was properly filed in Batangas.
On the second issue, the Court held that absent a showing that the findings complained of are totally devoid of support in the record or are so glaringly erroneous as to constitute serious abuse of discretion, such findings must stand. Absent a showing of grave abuse of discretion in dismissing the complaint, the Court gave credence to the findings and recommendation of the Investigating Commissioner and the Board of Governors. The Court stressed that Gatmaytan was laboring under a misapprehension of Rule 139-B: it is only when the complaint bears merit, or when the answer fails to show that the complaint indeed lacks merit, or when the respondent fails to file an answer, that an investigation shall proceed. Otherwise, if the complaint is bereft of merit, either on its face or as proven by the respondent's answer, it would be unjust to mandate the Investigator to conduct an investigation.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, under Rule 139-B of the Rules of Court, the Investigator has discretion either to dismiss a disbarment complaint outright or to proceed with a formal investigation. Second, a formal investigation is required only in three situations: when the complaint appears meritorious; upon joinder of issues, when the answer shows the complaint is meritorious; or when the respondent fails to answer. Third, dismissal is proper when the complaint lacks merit on its face or as shown by the respondent's answer, and such dismissal may be made by the Board of Governors upon the Investigator's recommendation. Fourth, the findings and recommendation of the Investigating Commissioner and the Board of Governors will be upheld absent a showing that they are totally devoid of support in the record or so glaringly erroneous as to constitute serious abuse of discretion. Finally, the power to disbar or suspend ought always to be exercised on the preservative and not on the vindictive principle, with great caution and only for the most weighty reasons.
Disposition
The appeal was denied and the Resolution of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines dated 26 April 2003, dismissing the complaint for disbarment against Atty. Ilao, was affirmed. Atty. Ilao prevailed.
Remember This
Memorize this line: the Investigator may dismiss a disbarment complaint outright when it lacks merit, and a formal investigation is required only when the complaint is meritorious, when the answer shows it is meritorious, or when the respondent fails to answer. Examiners use this case to test the procedure under Rule 139-B of the Rules of Court, particularly the interplay between Section 5 and Section 8, and the discretion of the Investigator to dismiss without investigation.