INVESTMENT AND MANAGEMENT SERVICES CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. LEODEGARIO V. ROXAS, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Investment and Management Services Corporation versus Roxas
The Case
This is an administrative case for disbarment or suspension brought by the Investment and Management Services Corporation against Attorney Leodegario Roxas, a lawyer who had served as the corporation's administrative and legal officer. The corporation accused him of misappropriating funds and checks entrusted to him and of issuing bouncing checks for personal obligations. The case matters far beyond the money involved, which was modest. It is a leading reminder that a lawyer's duty of candor and respect runs not only to clients but to the court, the Integrated Bar, and the investigating officers, and that evading an administrative investigation is itself a serious disciplinary offense.
Procedural History
The corporation filed its petition for disbarment or suspension in January 1975. The Supreme Court required the respondent to answer within ten days, but no answer came. After more than two and a half years, he asked that the ten-day period be counted anew from his receipt of a legible copy of the petition, claiming the copy sent to him was partly illegible. Copies sent to his Malate address were returned unclaimed. The Court then directed that the petition be mailed to his permanent address in Lemery, Batangas, as shown in his Bar Examinations petition, and referred the matter to the Office of the Solicitor General for investigation, report, and recommendation.
The Office of the Solicitor General transmitted its report in April 1990, recommending a five-year suspension, and filed a separate complaint. The Court required an answer, which the respondent filed in July 1990, denying the charges as harassment and giving a Sampaloc, Manila address. The matter was then referred to the Integrated Bar of the Philippines. The Investigating Commissioner, noting that both parties failed to appear at several hearings and that notices to the respondent later went unclaimed, recommended dismissal for lack of evidence but observed that the respondent's conduct during the proceedings deserved disciplinary sanction. The Board of Governors adopted that report and suspended him for one month. The records and decision were transmitted to the Supreme Court for final action, and the Court reviewed the recommendation and imposed a heavier penalty.
Facts
The corporation managed three companies: Worldwide Paper Mills, Prime Trading Corporation, and Luzon Leather Industries. While serving as its administrative and legal officer, the respondent allegedly misappropriated or converted to his own use and benefit sums and checks he had received in trust, totaling seven thousand eight hundred seventeen pesos and thirty centavos, drawn from the debtors and employees of those companies. He also allegedly issued bouncing checks to pay personal obligations.
When ordered to answer, he did not respond at the address on record. Years later he moved for substitution of a legible copy of the petition and asked that his answer period run anew, giving a Malate address. The legible copy sent there was returned unclaimed. The Court then sent the petition to his permanent address in Lemery, Batangas, and referred the matter to the Solicitor General.
Throughout the investigation, the respondent repeatedly changed his address without informing the investigating officials or the Court. Notices sent to his Sampaloc address were at first received, but later communications went unclaimed. After years of delay, the complainant corporation could no longer be reached to substantiate its charges, and the Commissioner recommended dismissal for lack of evidence while flagging the respondent's conduct.
Issues
- Whether or not the respondent lawyer may be held administratively liable for misappropriating funds and checks entrusted to him and for issuing bouncing checks.
- Whether or not the respondent's repeated changes of address and evasion of the administrative investigation constitute a ground for disciplinary sanction.
- Whether or not the penalty recommended by the Integrated Bar of the Philippines should be adopted, or a more severe penalty imposed.
Applicable Provisions
The Court applied Rule 139-B of the Rules of Court on the transmission of the Integrated Bar's resolution to the Supreme Court for final action, which provides:
If the IBP Board of Governors, by a majority vote of its total membership, determines that a lawyer should be suspended from the practice of law or disbarred, it shall issue a resolution setting forth its findings and recommendations. The resolution, together with the whole record of the case, shall then be transmitted to the Supreme Court for final action.
This confirms that the Integrated Bar's resolution is merely recommendatory and that the final power to discipline belongs to the Supreme Court.
The Court also invoked Canon 10 of the Code of Professional Responsibility, which provides:
A lawyer shall observe candor, fairness and loyalty in all his dealings and transactions with his clients.
This anchors the standard of good faith, fairness, and candor that the respondent failed to meet.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court did not sustain the misappropriation charge on the evidence, since the complainant could no longer be reached to substantiate it and the Commissioner had recommended dismissal for lack of evidence. The Court nonetheless found that the respondent clearly had no intention to squarely face the charges against him.
On the second issue, the Court held that by repeatedly changing his address without informing the investigating officials or the Court, the respondent managed to evade the administrative investigation for years, until the complainant could no longer be reached. The Court stressed that a lawyer must constantly conduct himself with great propriety, that he is an officer of the court owing it and his peers utmost respect and fidelity, and that his relationship with others should be characterized by the highest degree of good faith, fairness, and candor. Having taken the lawyer's oath, he made a solemn promise to stand by those pledges, and in that covenant he miserably failed.
On the third issue, the Court treated the Integrated Bar's one-month suspension as merely recommendatory and, finding nothing to warrant reversal of its findings, imposed a more severe penalty of six months.
Doctrine
A lawyer is an officer of the court and owes it, as well as his peers, utmost respect and fidelity; his dealings with others must be marked by the highest degree of good faith, fairness, and candor under Canon 10 of the Code of Professional Responsibility. Evading an administrative investigation, such as by repeatedly changing address without notice to the Court or investigating officials, is itself a serious disciplinary offense, even where the underlying charge is dismissed for lack of evidence. The resolution of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines is merely recommendatory; the Supreme Court may adopt, reduce, or increase the recommended penalty in the exercise of its final disciplinary authority.
Disposition
The Court suspended Attorney Leodegario Roxas from the practice of law for six months effective upon his receipt of the decision, ordered the suspension entered in his personal record and furnished to the Bar Confidant and the Integrated Bar, and directed the Court Administrator to circulate the order to all courts.
Remember This
Memorize the line that a lawyer's relationship with others must be characterized by the highest degree of good faith, fairness, and candor, and that evading investigation is itself punishable. Examiners use this case on a lawyer's duty to the court and on the recommendatory nature of Integrated Bar resolutions, where the Supreme Court may impose a heavier penalty than that recommended.