CESAR L. LANTORIA, COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. IRINEO L. BUNYI, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Lantoria versus Bunyi
The Case
This is an administrative complaint for disbarment or disciplinary action filed by Cesar L. Lantoria against Attorney Irineo L. Bunyi, a member of the Philippine Bar. The complainant charged the respondent with graft and corruption, dishonesty, conduct unbecoming a member of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, and corruption of the judge and bribery, all arising from the respondent's handling of three civil cases for ejectment pending before the Municipal Court of Esperanza, Agusan del Sur, where the respondent was counsel for one of the parties. The case matters because it fixes the ethical boundary between a lawyer's assistance to a court and an improper attempt to influence it, and because it shows that a complainant's withdrawal of his charges does not defeat the Court's own disciplinary jurisdiction once the lawyer himself admits the acts complained of.
Procedural History
The complainant filed the administrative case directly with the Supreme Court on 11 April 1977, predicated mainly on three letters written by the respondent in 1974. The Court, by resolution dated 28 November 1977, referred the case to the Solicitor General for investigation, report, and recommendation. After several settings, the Solicitor General submitted his report on 21 July 1980, finding the respondent guilty of highly unethical and unprofessional conduct and recommending suspension from the practice of law for one year, and he filed the corresponding complaint with the Court. The respondent answered, manifesting that in the future he would be more careful in observing his duties as a lawyer and in upholding the canons of professional ethics. Hearings were reset, the respondent filed a manifestation and later a memorandum, and the case was resolved by the Court en banc.
Facts
Mrs. Constancia M. Mascarinas owned a farm in Esperanza, Agusan del Sur, and the complainant Lantoria was its manager and supervisor. The respondent Bunyi was counsel for Mrs. Mascarinas in three civil cases, docketed as Civil Case Numbers 81, 83, and 88, which sought to eject squatters from the farm. These cases were assigned to the Municipal Court of Esperanza, presided over by Municipal Judge Vicente Galicia, who was at the same time the regular judge of the municipal court of Bayugan, Agusan del Sur. The defendants in the three cases were declared in default.
By letter dated 04 March 1974, the respondent asked the complainant to deliver to Judge Galicia an envelope containing decisions and orders which, according to the respondent, the judge had told him to prepare and was going to sign. The respondent asked that the envelope be delivered as if the complainant had no knowledge of it and had not opened it, and suggested delivery at the judge's residence in Butuan City during the weekend, or at Bayugan. By letter dated 23 April 1974, the complainant informed the respondent that upon being told of the respondent's willingness to prepare the corresponding judgments in the three defaulted cases, the judge said he had no objection and was in fact happy, and recommended that the decisions be mailed in due time through the complainant for delivery to him. By letter dated 01 June 1974, the respondent enclosed the three decisions against the defaulted defendants and requested, through the complainant's kind mediation, that if the preparation did not suit the judge's consideration, he was ready and willing to accept the judge's suggestions or corrections to change or modify them for the better.
Three years later, on 11 April 1977, the complainant filed this administrative case, contending that the respondent won the three cases because he himself unethically prepared the decisions rendered therein. At a hearing on 16 January 1979, the complainant submitted a letter praying that the complaint be withdrawn, dropped, or dismissed on the ground that he could hardly substantiate his charges and was no longer interested in prosecuting them, and he testified that he no longer had the originals of the letters. The respondent did not object to the withdrawal. The Solicitor General nonetheless found that the respondent had prepared the draft decisions and had previous communications with the judge about them, and that the withdrawal and the loss of the originals were of no moment because the respondent had admitted preparing the drafts and affirmed the existence of the letters.
Issues
- Whether or not the withdrawal of the complaint by the complainant bars the continuation of the administrative proceedings against the respondent.
- Whether or not the respondent's preparation of the draft decisions for the judge, and his communications with the judge regarding them, constitute unethical practice and conduct unbecoming of a lawyer and an officer of the Court warranting disciplinary action.
Applicable Provisions
Canon Number 3 of the Canons of Professional Ethics, which were enforced at the time the respondent committed the acts admitted by him, provides:
3. Attempts to exert personal influence on the court. Marked attention and unusual hospitality on the part of a lawyer to a judge, uncalled for by the personal relations of the parties, subject both the judge and the lawyer to misconstructions of motive and should be avoided. A lawyer should not communicate or argue privately with the judge as to the merits of a pending cause and deserves rebuke and denunciation for any device or attempt to gain from a judge special personal consideration or favor. A self-respecting independence in the discharge of professional duty, without denial or diminution of the courtesy and respect due the judge's station, is the only proper foundation for cordial personal and official relations between bench and bar.
This canon supplies the standard the respondent violated by communicating privately with the judge and preparing the decisions in his own client's pending cases.
Canon Number 13 of the new Code of Professional Responsibility provides:
CANON 13 - A lawyer shall rely upon the merits of his cause and refrain from any impropriety which tends to influence, or gives the appearance of influencing the court.
This canon confirms that the same prohibition continues under the current ethical code.
Rule 13.01 of the same Code provides:
Rule 13.01 - A lawyer shall not extend extraordinary attention or hospitality to, nor seek opportunity for, cultivating familiarity with judges.
This rule reinforces the duty to avoid familiarity with judges that could color judicial action.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the determination of the merits of the case should proceed notwithstanding the complainant's withdrawal of his complaint, because the respondent himself admitted that the letters in question truly exist and even asked for an apology from the Court for whatever effects such letters may have had on his duty as a lawyer. With that admission, the remaining issue was the effect of the acts complained of on the respondent's duty both as a lawyer and as an officer of the Court.
On the second issue, the Court found merit in the Solicitor General's recommendation that the respondent deserves suspension from the practice of law. The letters indicated that the respondent had previous communication with Judge Galicia regarding the preparation of the draft decisions in the three civil cases, and that he in fact prepared them. Although nothing in the records showed that the respondent obtained the judge's consent to the preparation for a favor or consideration, his acts nevertheless amounted to conduct unbecoming of a lawyer and an officer of the Court. The Court held that the respondent clearly violated Canon Number 3 of the Canons of Professional Ethics, which forbids a lawyer from communicating or arguing privately with the judge as to the merits of a pending cause, and that under the new Code of Professional Responsibility the same attempt to influence the court is rebuked by Canon Number 13 and Rule 13.01. The Court therefore found the respondent guilty of unethical practice in attempting to influence the court where he had a pending civil case.
Doctrine
A lawyer may not communicate privately with the judge as to the merits of a pending cause, and may not prepare the decisions in his own client's case for the judge's signature, for such acts amount to an attempt to influence the court and to conduct unbecoming of a lawyer and an officer of the Court, in violation of Canon Number 3 of the Canons of Professional Ethics and Canon Number 13 and Rule 13.01 of the Code of Professional Responsibility. The absence of proof that the lawyer gave the judge a gift or consideration does not save him, because the prohibition strikes at the device or attempt to gain special personal consideration or favor, not merely at a completed bribe. And a complainant's withdrawal of his administrative complaint does not divest the Court of jurisdiction to discipline a lawyer, especially where the lawyer himself admits the existence of the letters and the acts on which the complaint rests.
Disposition
The Court found Attorney Irineo L. Bunyi guilty of unethical practice and suspended him from the practice of law for one year from notice, directing that the decision be entered in his bar records and that the Court Administrator inform the different courts of the suspension.
Remember This
A lawyer who privately communicates with the judge and drafts the decision in his own pending case is guilty of unethical practice even without proof of a bribe, and the complainant's withdrawal does not stop the discipline. Examiners use this case on the independence of the judiciary, on Canon Number 3 and Canon Number 13 with Rule 13.01, and on the rule that disbarment proceedings are matters of public interest that survive the complainant's desistance.