ULYSSES NALLOS AND ELISA NALLOS-PENA, REP. BY ATTY. RUBEN N. VILLALUZ, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS, VS. DELFIN SUMPAY, LOURDES SUMPAY AND LYDIO NUEVA, DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Nallos versus Sumpay
The Case
This is a lecture on Nallos versus Sumpay, a decision of the Supreme Court on an appeal in a case for recovery of ownership and possession with damages. The plaintiffs, Ulysses Nallos and Elisa Nallos-Pena, sued Delfin Sumpay, Lourdes Sumpay, and Lydio Nueva over a ten thousand square meter parcel of land in Pawili, Pili, Camarines Sur. The Nallos claimed that the land had been sold to them by Isabel Beriña in a deed of absolute sale, and that the later sale of the same land to the Sumpay spouses was void and done in bad faith. The case matters because it is a clean teaching vehicle on two things every examinee must master: the proof required before a private document may be admitted as authentic, and the second concept of res judicata, the conclusiveness of judgment.
Procedural History
The case began in the Regional Trial Court, Branch 31, Pili, Camarines Sur, where the Nallos filed their complaint for ownership, possession, and damages. In its decision of February 15, 2012, that court dismissed the complaint for lack of merit and ordered the Nallos to pay the Sumpay spouses twenty five thousand pesos as exemplary damages and twenty thousand pesos as attorney's fees. The Nallos moved for reconsideration, which was denied. They then appealed to the Supreme Court. The appellees failed to file their appellees' brief despite due notice, and the Court resolved the appeal on the record.
Facts
The controversy involves a ten thousand square meter land in Pawili, Pili, Camarines Sur, originally registered in the name of Isabel Beriña under an original certificate of title. In March 1982, Isabel and her son Lydio executed a deed of sale with right to repurchase over the property in favor of the Sumpay spouses, who took physical possession of the premises.
On February 2, 1987, Isabel also executed a deed of absolute sale over the same property in favor of the Nallos. Lydio was a witness to that deed. The Nallos claimed that Lydio assured them the property would be redeemed from the Sumpay spouses. After Isabel died, her heirs, including Lydio, offered to redeem the land, but the Sumpay spouses insisted they were already the owners. The heirs then filed a complaint for consignation, and in its decision of January 30, 1992, the trial court held that the consignation of seven thousand pesos released the heirs from their obligation under the sale with right to repurchase and ordered the Sumpay spouses to deliver possession to the heirs.
Despite that final decision, Lydio and Delfin filed a joint motion manifesting an amicable settlement, and the court allowed Lydio to withdraw the consigned amount as partial payment for a consideration of one hundred twenty thousand pesos. The heirs of Isabel then executed, on February 14, 1997, an extrajudicial settlement of estate with absolute sale, adjudicating the estate to themselves and selling the land to Delfin. The Nallos demanded that the Sumpay spouses vacate, and when the demand was ignored, they sued Lydio for specific performance. That case was dismissed in an order dated November 12, 2004, which became final and executory on October 23, 2008. The Nallos then filed the present case for recovery of ownership and possession.
Issues
- Whether or not the 1987 deed of sale in favor of the Nallos may be admitted in evidence and given probative value despite the failure to prove its due execution and authenticity.
- Whether or not the dismissal of the earlier specific performance case bars the later action for recovery of ownership and possession under the principle of res judicata.
Applicable Provisions
Section 20, Rule 132 of the Rules of Court provides:
Proof of private document. Before any private document offered as authentic is received in evidence, its due execution and authenticity must be proved either: (a) By anyone who saw the document executed or written; or (b) By evidence of the genuineness of the signature or handwriting of the maker. Any other private document need only be identified as that which it is claimed to be.
This provision governs the 1987 deed of sale, which the Court treated as a private document whose execution and authenticity the Nallos never proved.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the November 12, 2004 order in the specific performance case did not declare the 1987 deed of sale a forgery. It merely pronounced the instrument a private document because the notary was not commissioned for the place of notarization and the witness did not appear before any notary public. The Nallos themselves conceded that the deed is only a private document. As such, it could be admitted only if its due execution and authenticity were proved, either by anyone who saw it executed or written, or by evidence of the genuineness of the signature or handwriting of the maker. The Nallos presented no such supporting evidence. Consequently, the instrument could not be admitted and could not prove the supposed sale. The affidavit of seller or transferor executed by Lydio was likewise given no probative value, because his lack of authority to sell had been settled with finality in the specific performance case.
On the second issue, the Court held that the dismissal of the specific performance case barred the later action under res judicata, specifically the second concept, the conclusiveness of judgment. The Court defined res judicata as a matter adjudged, a thing or matter acted upon or decided or settled by judgment. It arises where the judgment sought to bar the new action is final, the decision was rendered by a court having jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties, the disposition was a judgment on the merits, and there is between the actions identity of parties, subject matter, and causes of action. The Court distinguished the two concepts. Bar by prior judgment requires identity of parties, subject matter, and causes of action, and absolutely bars the second action. Conclusiveness of judgment requires only identity of parties, and the first judgment is conclusive only as to those matters actually and directly controverted and determined. The Court found all the elements of conclusiveness of judgment present. The order had become final, jurisdiction was never disputed, and both cases involved the Nallos and Lydio. The inclusion of the Sumpay spouses did not remove the case from identity of parties, because they are Lydio's successors in interest, having bought the land from him and the other heirs. Identity of parties exists not only when the parties are the same but also between those in privity with them, and absolute identity is not required, since a shared identity of interest suffices. There was also identity of subject matter, as both actions involved the Nallos' rights over the same land.
The Court further held that the November 12, 2004 order was an adjudication on the merits even though it resolved only the special and affirmative defenses in the answer. A judgment is upon the merits when it amounts to a declaration of the law as to the respective rights and duties of the parties, based upon the ultimate facts disclosed by the pleadings and evidence, irrespective of formal, technical, or dilatory objections. The Court noted that although the reliefs prayed for in the two actions were ostensibly different, the ultimate objective of the Nallos was the same: to obtain ownership and possession of the property by virtue of the 1987 deed of sale. To allow the second case would be to re-litigate matters already adjudged. The difference in form and nature of the two cases is immaterial and does not exempt the Nallos from the effects of res judicata.
Doctrine
First, a private document offered as authentic is not admissible unless its due execution and authenticity are proved by anyone who saw it executed or written, or by evidence of the genuineness of the signature or handwriting of the maker. A defective notarization strips a deed of its public character, and the instrument must then be proved as a private document.
Second, res judicata has two concepts. Bar by prior judgment requires identity of parties, subject matter, and causes of action, and absolutely bars the second action. Conclusiveness of judgment requires only identity of parties, and the first judgment is conclusive as to every matter actually and directly controverted and determined. Identity of parties includes their successors in interest and those sharing a community of interests, and absolute identity is not required.
Third, a judgment is upon the merits even if rendered on the special and affirmative defenses in the answer, without a full trial, so long as it declares the rights and duties of the parties based on the ultimate facts.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the appeal and affirmed the February 15, 2012 decision of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 31, Pili, Camarines Sur, dismissing the complaint and awarding exemplary damages and attorney's fees to the Sumpay spouses.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a final judgment on the merits is conclusive between the parties and their successors in interest on every point actually adjudicated, and that is the conclusiveness of judgment. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between the two concepts of res judicata and the proof required for a private document under Section 20, Rule 132.