JONAS MARCOS BRIONES, JR., PETITIONER, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, TIGERLAND SECURITY AND INVESTIGATION AGENCY, INC., DAVID P. ZAPANTA AND CECILIA L. ZAPANTA, RESPO…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Briones versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a labor case about a security guard who claimed he was illegally dismissed, but who, the Court found, had never actually been dismissed at all. Jonas Marcos Briones, Jr. filed a complaint against his employer, Tigerland Security and Investigation Agency, Inc., and its officers David P. Zapanta and Cecilia L. Zapanta, alleging illegal dismissal and a long list of money claims. The case matters because it fixes the order of battle in every illegal dismissal suit: before the employer must prove that a dismissal was lawful, the employee must first prove by substantial evidence that a dismissal ever happened. It also gives the Bar candidate a clean statement of the doctrine of floating status for security guards, and of how the burden of proof shifts on money claims.
Procedural History
Briones filed his complaint with the Labor Arbiter for illegal dismissal and various money claims. The Labor Arbiter dismissed the complaint for illegal dismissal but ordered Tigerland to pay service incentive leave pay, and denied the other claims. Briones appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which dismissed the appeal and affirmed the Labor Arbiter, holding that Briones had abandoned his job. Briones moved for reconsideration, which the Commission denied. He then came to the Supreme Court by a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court, alleging grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction.
Facts
In September 2011, Tigerland hired Briones as a security guard and assigned him to various clients, the last of which was Salve Regina Hospital. Since April 2012, however, he was assigned as a reliever or extra guard because there was no available regular post for duty detail. On January 3, 2013, Briones did not report for duty.
On January 29, 2013, Briones filed a complaint for illegal dismissal, underpayment of wages and thirteenth month pay, non-payment of overtime pay, holiday pay, holiday premium, rest day premium, service incentive leave pay and night shift differential, separation pay, and refund of an illegal deduction called abuloy sa patay, as well as of deducted but unremitted SSS, Philhealth and Pag-ibig contributions. Meanwhile, his wife Cynthia went to the Tigerland office to secure the release of his cash bond and unclaimed salary for the period December 16, 2012 to January 2, 2013, and to request a certificate of employment. Tigerland told her, for Briones, that his post was still open and required him to report for work, but he did not comply.
Tigerland denied dismissing Briones and said he could only be placed on floating status, so that the complaint filed on January 29, 2013 was premature, since he had been on floating status for less than six months.
Issues
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion in ruling that Briones was not illegally dismissed.
- Whether or not Briones was entitled to his monetary claims.
Applicable Provisions
Article 286 of the Labor Code of the Philippines, applied by analogy to security guards, provides:
When employment not deemed terminated. — The bona fide suspension of the operation of a business or undertaking for a period not exceeding six (6) months, or the fulfillment by the employee of a military or civic duty shall not terminate employment. In all such cases, the employer shall reinstate the employee to his former position without loss of seniority rights if he indicates his desire to resume his work not later than one (1) month from the resumption of operations of his employer or from his relief from the military or civic duty.
This six-month measure is the yardstick the Court uses to test when a floating status stops being lawful and ripens into constructive dismissal.
Article 13, Section 3, second paragraph of the Constitution provides:
They shall be entitled to security of tenure, humane conditions of work, and a living wage.
This is the constitutional guarantee that underlies the rule that an employee may be dismissed only for just or authorized causes and after due process.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that there was no dismissal, actual or constructive, to speak of. Placing a security guard on floating status does not automatically result in constructive dismissal; it is lawful and not unusual, because assignments depend on the contracts the agency enters into with third parties. The temporary inactivity should continue only for six months, and a floating status ripens into constructive dismissal only when it goes beyond that maximum period. Here, Briones filed his complaint before the six months had lapsed, so his claim lacked basis. It was in fact he who intended to end the relationship, as shown by his prayer for separation pay rather than reinstatement.
The Court acknowledged the rule that the employer bears the burden of proving a valid termination, but stressed that the employee must first establish by competent evidence the fact of dismissal. The Court quoted its own ruling in Machica versus Roosevelt Services Center, Incorporated:
The rule is that one who alleges a fact has the burden of proving it; thus, petitioners were burdened to prove their allegation that respondents dismissed them from their employment. It must be stressed that the evidence to prove this fact must be clear, positive and convincing. The rule that the employer bears the burden of proof in illegal dismissal cases finds no application here because the respondents deny having dismissed the petitioners.
Briones offered only an unsubstantiated conclusion that he was dismissed, with no overt or positive act shown, so his claim was self-serving and conjectural. Given that there was no dismissal, there could be no question as to its legality or illegality.
On the second issue, the Court held that the factual findings of the Labor Arbiter and the Commission, affirmed and supported by substantial evidence, deserve great respect and even finality. The money claims, except service incentive leave pay, had already been paid. On payment, the burden rests on the employer, because the payrolls and records are in its custody; since Tigerland failed to adduce evidence of actual payment, it must pay the service incentive leave pay. But the burden of proving entitlement to overtime pay and premium pay for holidays and rest days rests on the employee, because these are not incurred in the normal course of business, and Briones adduced no such evidence.
Doctrine
- Before the employer must prove that a dismissal was lawful, the employee must first establish by substantial evidence the fact of dismissal; if there is no dismissal, there can be no question as to its legality or illegality.
- Placing a security guard on floating status is lawful and is not equivalent to dismissal, for as long as the temporary inactivity does not exceed six months, by analogy to Article 286 of the Labor Code.
- Floating status ripens into constructive dismissal only when it goes beyond the six-month maximum period.
- The employer bears the burden of proving payment of money claims, since the records are in its custody; but the employee bears the burden of proving entitlement to overtime pay and premium pay for holidays and rest days.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed and the Commission's resolutions were affirmed; Briones lost his illegal dismissal claim, and Tigerland was ordered to pay him service incentive leave pay of 2,280 pesos.
Remember This
Memorize the line: if there is no dismissal, there can be no question as to the legality or illegality thereof. Examiners use this case to test floating status of security guards and the six-month rule, and to test who carries the burden of proof on the fact of dismissal as against the burden of proving payment of money claims.