PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. SPO2 EDUARDO O. UNTALAN, ACCUSED-APPELLANT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Untalan
The Case
This is the People of the Philippines against SPO2 Eduardo Untalan, a police officer charged with shooting a civilian after a night of drinking. The action began as a criminal prosecution for frustrated homicide in the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, and it reaches the Supreme Court on appeal from a judgment of conviction. The case matters for two reasons a reviewee should hold onto: it is a clean teaching vehicle for the line between the attempted and the frustrated stages of a crime against persons, and it restates the settled rule that a bare denial cannot overcome positive identification by credible witnesses.
Procedural History
The City Prosecutor filed an Information for frustrated homicide against SPO2 Untalan. On arraignment he pleaded not guilty, and trial on the merits followed. The Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 216, rendered its Decision on March 25, 2003, finding him guilty beyond reasonable doubt of frustrated homicide under Article 249 in relation to Article 50 of the Revised Penal Code, and sentencing him to an indeterminate prison term of two years four months and one day of prision correccional as minimum, to six years four months and ten days of prision mayor as maximum. He filed his Notice of Appeal on March 31, 2003. The appeal went directly to the Supreme Court under Rule 122 of the Revised Rules of Court.
Facts
On the evening of October 4, 1998, Teodoro Amor Jr. was at a gathering at his sister's house in Fairview, Quezon City. Around ten o'clock he walked two guests out. On the way he stopped to urinate, and when he resumed walking he saw his friend Royales talking with a tricycle driver whose passengers were SPO2 Untalan and SPO3 De Los Reyes. Amor, who appeared drunk, shouted at a man on the sidewalk. Untalan told him to go home or he might get hurt. Amor ignored him and kept walking.
Untalan and Royales then moved toward Amor, and De Los Reyes alighted from the tricycle. Untalan tapped Amor's shoulder and asked, do you not know me? He drew his gun and poked it alternately at Amor and Royales, while De Los Reyes also drew his gun and pointed it at Amor. Untalan pulled the trigger but the gun did not fire. Amor bluffed that he too was a policeman. Untalan pulled the trigger again and hit Amor on the upper left thigh. Royales pressed a lead pipe against Untalan's chest to restrain him, and Amor ran. Untalan freed himself, fired again, and hit Amor on the right arm.
A police patrol car brought Amor to hospital, where a doctor closed the two gunshot wounds and gave medicine to prevent infection. Amor was confined for five days. The medico-legal certificate described a gunshot wound on the left thigh and a grazed wound on the right upper arm, and stated that the injuries required at least twenty-five days of medical attention. Untalan denied shooting Amor and pointed to De Los Reyes as the gunman.
Issues
- Whether or not the crime proved is frustrated homicide, as the trial court held, or only attempted homicide.
- Whether or not the accused's defense of denial can prevail over the positive identification and categorical testimony of the prosecution witnesses.
Applicable Provisions
Article 249 of the Revised Penal Code, which the trial court applied, defines and penalizes homicide:
Article 249. Death caused in a quarrel. — Any person who, without intending to kill, shall inflict upon another any serious physical injury, which, by reason of the injury inflicted, shall cause the death of the latter, shall be punished by prision mayor in its medium and maximum periods.
The provision fixes the penalty for the consummated felony, and the Court uses it as the reference point for the penalty of the frustrated and attempted stages.
Article 50 of the Revised Penal Code, also applied by the trial court, governs the penalty for the frustrated stage:
Article 50. Penalty to be imposed upon principals of a frustrated crime. — The penalty next lower in degree than that prescribed by law for the consummated felony shall be imposed upon the principal in a frustrated felony.
Because the Court reclassifies the crime as attempted, the penalty next lower in degree is taken from this graduated scheme.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court modified the conviction. The crime committed is only attempted homicide, not frustrated homicide. The prosecution proved that what Untalan inflicted were wounds on the left thigh and the upper right arm, which an ordinary man, not even schooled in medicine, can discern to be wounds on non-vital parts of the body. The wounds were not mortal. The doctor's testimony that the victim could have bled to death if left unattended does not change the criminal law concept of a mortal wound, because loss of blood is merely an after-effect or consequence of the wound. What is crucial is whether the blow intended was delivered on a mortal part of the body in order to cause death. Where the wound is not so severe as to cause death, the offender has not performed all the acts of execution, and the crime is only attempted. The assumption that infection could have caused death is too speculative and remote, and if tetanus had set in it would be an efficient intervening cause, distinct and foreign to the crime. For the frustrated stage, the probable death of the victim must be the direct, natural, and logical consequence of the wounds inflicted, and proof must be beyond reasonable doubt.
On the second issue, the Court rejected the denial. Denial is intrinsically a weak defense. To merit credibility it must be supported by strong evidence of non-culpability, and as negative, self-serving evidence it cannot be given evidentiary weight greater than that of credible witnesses who testify on affirmative matters. The trial court's evaluation of the eyewitnesses deserved the highest respect, and the accused's own statements before the Prosecutor's Office contained no allegation about De Los Reyes' culpability. The Court restated the governing rule:
Time-tested is the rule that between the positive assertions of prosecution witnesses and the negative averments of the accused, the former indisputably deserve more credence and evidentiary weight.
Where there is positive identification of the accused as the perpetrator, his denial cannot be sustained.
Doctrine
- Attempted versus frustrated homicide. The dividing line is whether the blow was delivered on a mortal part of the body in order to cause death. If the wound is not severe enough to cause death, not all acts of execution have been performed, and the crime is attempted only.
- Mortal wound. The probable death of the victim must be the direct, natural, and logical consequence of the wounds inflicted. Bleeding is an after-effect, and infection such as tetanus, if it occurs, is an efficient intervening cause foreign to the crime.
- Denial. Denial is intrinsically weak, negative, and self-serving. It cannot outweigh the positive assertions and positive identification of credible prosecution witnesses.
- Credibility on appeal. The trial court's assessment of witness credibility is given great weight and even finality, absent a showing that it failed to appreciate facts that would materially affect the result.
Disposition
The Court modified the trial court's decision, finding SPO2 Eduardo Untalan guilty of attempted homicide instead of frustrated homicide and sentencing him to an indeterminate penalty of four months of arresto mayor in its medium period as minimum, to three years of prision correccional in its medium period as maximum.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that the stage of the crime turns on whether the blow was aimed at a mortal part to cause death, not on what complications might later have arisen. Examiners use this case to test the attempted and frustrated distinction and the weight of denial against positive identification.