🎧 Case Brief Lecture

BUENAVISTA PROPERTIES, INC., PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. LA SAVOIE DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, DEFENDANT-APPELLANT.

May 7, 1992

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Buenavista Properties versus La Savoie Development

The Case

This is an ordinary appeal brought by La Savoie Development Corporation against Buenavista Properties, Incorporated. Buenavista sued La Savoie for termination of contract, recovery of property, and damages, after La Savoie failed to complete a subdivision project that it had undertaken to develop under a joint venture agreement. The case matters to a reviewee for two reasons. First, it is a clean illustration of the rule that a party who invokes a court's jurisdiction and actively participates in the proceedings cannot later turn around and question that same jurisdiction. Second, it is a firm restatement of the mandatory character of the rules on motions and on pre-trial, and of the principle that procedural rules cannot be brushed aside simply because their non-observance may prejudice a party's substantive rights.

Procedural History

Buenavista filed its complaint before the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 217. After several incidents and postponements, pre-trial was repeatedly reset. La Savoie and its counsel failed to appear at the scheduled pre-trial conferences, and the trial court allowed Buenavista to present its evidence ex parte. La Savoie filed motions for reconsideration, and the trial court at one point set aside its orders and reset the hearings. Ultimately, the trial court issued an order reinstating the ex parte presentation of evidence, and on the scheduled hearing Buenavista's lone witness, Mr. Delfin Cruz, testified. On 12 June 2003, the trial court rendered judgment in favor of Buenavista, terminating the joint venture agreement and its addendum, ordering La Savoie to deliver possession of the Buenavista Park Subdivision with all improvements, ordering payment of a penalty of Ten Thousand Pesos a day from the filing of the case until paid, and awarding One Hundred Thousand Pesos in attorney's fees, with costs against La Savoie.

La Savoie filed a Notice of Appeal elevating the case to the Supreme Court. In its appellant's brief it assigned several errors, all of which pertained to the trial court's order of 19 December 2002. In a supplemental brief, La Savoie belatedly questioned the jurisdiction of the trial court, praying that the complaint be dismissed on the ground that the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board has the sole power and authority to hear the case.

Facts

On 7 May 1992, Buenavista and La Savoie voluntarily entered into a Joint Venture Agreement. Under that agreement, La Savoie was tasked to develop into a subdivision certain real properties owned by Buenavista, located in San Rafael, Bulacan and covered by three transfer certificates of title. The agreement obliged La Savoie to build a commercial arcade and other amenities, including a shopping arcade, clubhouse, swimming pool, basketball court, children's playground, church, and a landscaped main entrance with guard house. La Savoie was also to handle the advertisement, promotion, and sale of the subdivision lots, with pricing to be determined jointly by both parties, and to secure the permit for development from the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board.

La Savoie failed to complete the project by 5 May 1995. The parties agreed to extend the period until 5 May 1997, but despite the extension La Savoie still failed to comply with its contractual obligations. Buenavista demanded that La Savoie stop selling subdivision lots at prices it had unilaterally fixed, but La Savoie proceeded with the sales. A certification from the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board showed that the development had not been fully completed as of March 1998, and a later certification showed that it remained incomplete.

On 2 March 1998, Buenavista filed its complaint. Pre-trial was set almost four years later, on 22 November 2001, but La Savoie and its counsel failed to appear despite due notice, so the trial court allowed Buenavista to present evidence ex parte. The trial court later set aside that order and reset the hearings, but La Savoie's counsel again failed to appear, and the trial court again allowed ex parte presentation of evidence. After further motions and orders, Buenavista's witness testified, and the trial court rendered the judgment now on appeal.

Issues

  • Whether or not La Savoie is estopped from challenging the jurisdiction of the trial court after it had voluntarily submitted its cause and actively participated in the proceedings below.
  • Whether or not the motion for reconsideration filed by La Savoie was procedurally infirm for failure to comply with the mandatory requirements on notices of hearing.
  • Whether or not the failure of La Savoie and its counsel to appear at pre-trial justified the allowance of ex parte presentation of evidence and judgment on the basis thereof.
  • Whether or not La Savoie has a substantive right that would warrant setting aside the judgment of the trial court.

Applicable Provisions

Section 4 of Rule 15 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure provides:

Section 4. Proof of service. Proof of service of the notice of hearing shall be filed with the motion, and shall consist of a written admission of the party served, or the registry receipt, or the affidavit of the person serving the motion, with the affidavit of the person mailing the same if service is by mail.

This provision, together with the rules on notice of hearing, governs the mandatory requirements that La Savoie's motion for reconsideration failed to satisfy.

Section 5 of Rule 15 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure provides:

Section 5. Notice of hearing. The notice of hearing shall be addressed to all parties concerned, and shall specify the time and date of the hearing which must not be later than ten (10) days after the filing of the motion.

This provision fixes the three requirements that La Savoie violated: setting the motion for hearing, serving a copy at least three days before the hearing, and scheduling the hearing not later than ten days after filing.

Section 8 of the Joint Venture Agreement provides:

8.1 In case the developer is unable to complete the development of this project as described in 2.1.1 to 2.1.10 above accordance with the schedule in 6.2 above, the developer shall pay the land owner a penalty of ten thousand pesos (P10,000.00) a day until the development is completed. 8.2 In case the developer violates any provision of this contract or otherwise fails and/or refuses to go through with its commitment herein, the landowner instead of suing for specific performance, my elect to cancel this contract by means of a written communication set to that effect to the developer. In the event of said cancellation the developer shall, in addition to the rights granted the landowner by law, forfeit in favor of said land owner all investments and/or improvements that shall have been introduced.

This penalty clause is the contractual basis for the award of Ten Thousand Pesos a day against La Savoie for its delay in completing the project.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that La Savoie was already estopped to challenge the jurisdiction of the trial court. It had not only sought affirmative relief from that court but had also participated actively in the proceedings below. The Court applied the rule in Tijam versus Sibonghanoy, quoting that after voluntarily submitting a cause and encountering an adverse decision on the merits, it is too late for the loser to question the jurisdiction or power of the court. It is not right for a party who has affirmed and invoked the jurisdiction of a court in a particular matter to secure an affirmative relief, to afterwards deny that same jurisdiction to escape a penalty. The Court found La Savoie guilty of estoppel by laches, so the Tijam ruling controlled.

On the second issue, the Court found that the motion for reconsideration was procedurally infirm. It violated Sections 4 and 5 of Rule 15 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure because La Savoie failed to set the motion for hearing, failed to serve a copy at least three days before the date of hearing, and failed to schedule the hearing not later than ten days after the filing of the motion. Since these requirements are mandatory, the motion was nothing but a scrap of paper.

On the third issue, the Court held that the failure of the defendant and its counsel to appear at pre-trial is a cause to allow the plaintiff to present evidence ex parte and for the court to render judgment on the basis thereof. It rejected the submission that substantive rights should precede procedural infirmities, holding that the Court cannot allow a party to gain advantage from its flagrant disregard of the Rules. The trial court had already extended so much liberality in favor of La Savoie, and yet it still failed to appear, so it was time to impose the full arm of the law. The Court quoted Pedrosa versus Hill:

Procedural rules are not to be belittled or dismissed simply because their non-observance may result in prejudice to a party's substantive rights. Like all rules, they are required to be followed.

On the fourth issue, the Court found that La Savoie had no substantive right that ought to be considered. The records showed that it was indeed in delay and had disposed of the properties not in accord with the terms and conditions of the Joint Venture Agreement. The trial court was therefore correct in applying the penalty clause against La Savoie.

Doctrine

A party who voluntarily submits a cause to a court, seeks affirmative relief from it, and actively participates in the proceedings below is estopped from later challenging that court's jurisdiction after receiving an adverse decision on the merits. This is the rule of estoppel by laches announced in Tijam versus Sibonghanoy.

The requirements for a motion's notice of hearing under Sections 4 and 5 of Rule 15 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure are mandatory. A motion that fails to set the motion for hearing, to serve a copy at least three days before the hearing, and to schedule the hearing not later than ten days after filing is a mere scrap of paper that confers no right on the movant.

The failure of a defendant and its counsel to appear at pre-trial is a cause to allow the plaintiff to present evidence ex parte and for the court to render judgment on the basis thereof. Procedural rules are not to be belittled or dismissed simply because their non-observance may result in prejudice to a party's substantive rights; like all rules, they are required to be followed.

Disposition

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal for lack of merit and affirmed in toto the decision of the trial court dated 12 June 2003, with no costs.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that a party who invokes a court's jurisdiction and actively participates in the proceedings cannot later deny that same jurisdiction to escape an adverse judgment. Examiners like to use this case on the doctrine of estoppel by laches against belated jurisdictional challenges, and on the mandatory character of the rules on notices of hearing and on pre-trial.