SPS. EBON LATAGAN AND MARIA JERERA LATAGAN, PETITIONERS, V. HON. JUDGE MAMERTO BUBAN OF RTC-BRANCH 18 – TABACO CITY, HON. JUDGE ALBEN RABE OF RTC-BRANCH 15- TABACO CITY, AND SPS…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Latagan versus Buban
The Case
This is the case of Latagan versus Buban. Spouses Ebon Latagan and Maria Jerera Latagan, the petitioners, brought a special civil action before the Supreme Court against two judges of the Regional Trial Court of Tabaco City and against private respondents Spouses Cesar Bulawan and Salome Bulawan. The petition arose from a related civil case pending before the trial courts. What matters most for the Bar candidate is not the merits of the underlying dispute, but what the Court did when the parties told it, in the middle of the proceedings, that they had already settled their differences amicably. The case therefore teaches the procedural rule on withdrawal of a petition and the effect of a compromise settlement on a pending case.
Procedural History
The petitioners filed a petition before the Supreme Court, impleading the presiding judges of two branches of the Regional Trial Court of Tabaco City and the private respondents. While the petition was pending, the petitioners filed a Motion to Withdraw Petition. In that motion, they alleged that in the related civil case, the parties had already amicably settled their claims and differences by way of a Judgment Based on Compromise Agreement issued by another branch of the Regional Trial Court of Tabaco City. On that ground, they asked that the petition be withdrawn and dismissed as moot and academic. The Supreme Court issued a resolution requiring the private respondents to confirm or comment on the motion within ten days from notice, warning that failure to respond would be treated as tacit assent to the allegation of amicable settlement. The private respondents then filed a Manifestation confirming that an amicable settlement had indeed been agreed upon by the parties with the intention to end the litigation. With the withdrawal unopposed, the Court resolved the motion.
Facts
The petitioners, Spouses Latagan, were litigants in a civil case before the Regional Trial Court of Tabaco City. That civil case was intimately related to the petition they later filed with the Supreme Court against the respondent judges and the private respondents, Spouses Bulawan.
While the petition was pending, the parties in the related civil case reached an amicable settlement. The settlement was embodied in a Judgment Based on Compromise Agreement issued by the Regional Trial Court of Tabaco City. Because the settlement resolved the very controversy that had driven the petition, the petitioners moved to withdraw their petition, asking that it be dismissed as moot and academic.
The Court did not act on the motion at once. It required the private respondents to confirm or comment on the motion, warning that silence would be taken as assent. The private respondents responded by Manifestation, expressly confirming that an amicable settlement had been agreed upon by the parties with the intention to end the instant litigation. With both sides in agreement, the Court granted the withdrawal and dismissed the petition.
Issues
- Whether or not the petition should be dismissed upon the petitioners' motion to withdraw it on the ground that the parties had amicably settled the related civil case, rendering the petition moot and academic.
- Whether or not the private respondents' confirmation of the amicable settlement, in response to the Court's resolution, justified the grant of the motion to withdraw.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote any statutory provision. It rests on the procedural rule that a petition may be withdrawn and dismissed where the withdrawal is justified and is not objected to by the adverse party, and on the principle that a case rendered moot and academic by a compromise settlement need not be resolved on the merits. The Court's resolution warned the private respondents that failure to respond would be treated as tacit assent to the petitioners' allegation of amicable settlement, and that this situation would justify granting the motion. No verbatim provision is reproduced in the decision text, so none is quoted here.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court granted the motion to withdraw. The petitioners alleged that the related civil case had been amicably settled by a Judgment Based on Compromise Agreement, and that the petition had therefore been rendered moot and academic. The Court accepted this ground as a justification for withdrawal.
On the second issue, the Court relied on the private respondents' confirmation. It had required them to confirm or comment on the motion, warning that failure to respond would be treated as tacit assent to the allegation of amicable settlement, and that this would justify granting the motion. The private respondents filed their Manifestation expressly confirming that an amicable settlement had been agreed upon by the parties with the intention to end the instant litigation. Since the withdrawal was not objected to by the private respondents, the Court held that the motion was justified. It granted the Motion to Withdraw Petition and dismissed the petition.
Doctrine
A petition pending before the Supreme Court may be withdrawn and dismissed where the parties have amicably settled the related controversy, rendering the petition moot and academic. The withdrawal must be justified, and it must not be objected to by the adverse party. Where the Court requires the adverse party to confirm or comment on the motion and warns that silence will be treated as tacit assent, the adverse party's express confirmation of the amicable settlement supplies the basis for granting the motion. A compromise settlement that ends the litigation between the parties removes the live controversy that a petition seeks to resolve, and the Court will not proceed to decide a case that no longer presents a justiciable issue.
Disposition
The Court granted the petitioners' Motion to Withdraw Petition and dismissed the petition, with the private respondents confirming the amicable settlement and interposing no objection.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a petition rendered moot and academic by an amicable settlement may be withdrawn and dismissed, especially where the adverse party confirms the settlement and does not object. Examiners like to use this case on the procedural effect of compromise settlements and withdrawal of petitions, and on the doctrine of moot and academic.