BENEDICT L. ORIBE, PETITIONER, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, FIRSAT DIVISION, HON. LABOR ARBITER JOSELITO CRUZ VILLAROZA, AND HIMEX CORPORATION AND/OR TERUHIRO OHNO (…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Oribe versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by Benedict Oribe against the National Labor Relations Commission, the Labor Arbiter, and Himex Corporation together with Teruhiro Ohno. Oribe asks the Supreme Court to reverse the Commission's affirmance of the Labor Arbiter's dismissal of his complaint for illegal dismissal. The case matters because it is a clean teaching vehicle on two points every labor reviewee must command: the just cause of loss of trust and confidence under Article 282 of the Labor Code as it applies to a managerial employee holding a position of responsibility, and the two notice rule under Article 277 of the same Code, including what substantial compliance means.
Procedural History
Oribe filed a complaint for illegal dismissal before the Labor Arbiter the day after he was terminated. The Labor Arbiter evaluated the evidence and, on 20 August 2001, dismissed the complaint, finding that the company's loss of confidence rested on Oribe's failure and refusal to perform his duties as chief accountant. Oribe appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which commissioned Labor Arbiter Fatima Jumbaro-Franco to review the case; on her report and recommendation, the Commission dismissed the appeal. The Commission affirmed the Labor Arbiter in its Decision of 7 May 2003 and denied Oribe's motion for reconsideration in its Resolution of 16 November 2004. Oribe then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari under Rule 65, alleging grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction.
Facts
Himex hired Oribe on 11 September 1995, and by 1998 he was its chief accountant. He was in charge of all accounting work, the books of accounts and other accounting records, and compliance with the company's tax obligations under the National Internal Revenue Code. He was relied upon to compute, withhold and remit correct taxes, file returns, deduct and remit Social Security System and Philhealth premiums, apply established accounting principles for sales under the installment method, submit the required merchandise inventory to the Bureau of Internal Revenue, implement internal accounting controls, issue official receipts, prepare checks and vouchers, and keep records of the same.
On 11 September 2000, the Bureau of Internal Revenue sent Himex a Letter of Authority informing it that a revenue officer would examine its books and records for 1999. Himex instructed Oribe to submit all requirements and to help expedite the examination, but Oribe was caught unprepared, prompting Himex to hire an external auditor, R.P. Calma and Company. The external auditor's letters of 4 January, 22 January, and 24 January 2001 catalogued Oribe's failures: failure to withhold and remit correct taxes on salaries and wages, failure to file returns and remit tax on fringe benefits, incorrect withholding and remittance of Social Security System and Philhealth contributions, failure to apply the correct accounting principle for installment sales, failure to submit the required merchandise inventory list, weak internal controls such as official receipts issued for post-dated checks, checks payable to cash, multi-payee disbursement vouchers, and vouchers not stamped paid, and failure to furnish his 1999 worksheets or trial balance. The auditor opined that the existing accountant was no longer effective and that his inability to produce the 1999 trial balance was an indication of inadequate competence.
On 12 January 2001, Oribe wrote the Ohnos offering to resign effective 15 January 2001 and asking, as part of his separation pay and benefits, for transfer of his service car and release of 150,000 pesos. On 7 February 2001, Himex sent him a notice requiring him to explain within seventy-two hours why no disciplinary action should be taken for gross incompetence and gross negligence, and placed him on preventive suspension. Oribe answered on 10 February 2001. On 7 March 2001, Himex sent a memorandum terminating his employment for loss of confidence and breach of trust. Oribe claimed that the company was guilty of tax fraud and evasion and turned its ire on him when the Bureau investigated, but the Labor Arbiter, the Commission, and ultimately the Supreme Court found the dismissal justified.
Issues
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction in affirming the Labor Arbiter's decision dismissing Oribe's complaint for illegal dismissal.
- Whether or not Oribe's dismissal on the ground of loss of trust and confidence was valid and substantiated under Article 282 of the Labor Code.
- Whether or not Himex complied with the two notice rule under Article 277 of the Labor Code.
Applicable Provisions
Article 282 of the Labor Code, as cited by the Court through its paragraph (c), provides:
An employer may terminate an employment for any of the following causes: Fraud or willful breach by the employee of the trust reposed in him by his employer or duly authorized representative.
This is the just cause the Court applies to Oribe's position as chief accountant, a position reposed with trust and confidence.
Article 277 of the Labor Code, paragraph (b), is the provision on the two notice rule that Oribe invoked, and the Court quoted the explanation of its purpose from Amadeo Fishing Corporation versus Nierra:
The first notice, which may be considered as the proper charge, serves to apprise the employee of the particular acts or omissions for which his dismissal is sought. The second notice on the other hand seeks to inform the employee of the employer's decision to dismiss him. This decision, however, must come only after the employee is given reasonable period from receipt of the first notice within which to answer the charge and ample opportunity to be heard and defend himself with the assistance of a representative if he so desires. This is in consonance with the express provision of the law on the protection to labor and the broader dictates of procedural due process. Non-compliance therewith is fatal because these requirements are conditions sine qua non before dismissal may be validly effected.
This quotation supplies the standard against which the Court measures whether Himex's notices satisfied procedural due process.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found no grave abuse of discretion and declined to reverse the Commission. On the second issue, the Court held that loss of trust and confidence under Article 282 paragraph (c) was properly established. That cause is premised on the employee holding a position of responsibility or trust and confidence, invested with confidence on delicate matters such as the custody, handling, care and protection of the employer's property and assets, and the act complained of must be work related and must show the employee unfit to continue such delicate and sensitive work. Oribe did not deny that his position was managerial and reposed with trust and confidence; as chief accountant he dealt closely with the financial interests of the company. His failure to apply correct accounting principles, to implement internal accounting measures, and to furnish worksheets to the external auditor constituted a breach of that trust. The Court noted that some failings, such as checks payable to cash and unstamped vouchers, were not merely unbeneficial but detrimental to Himex, and that his claim of obeying tax-evasion schemes did not excuse his ineptness and incompetence. It cited Inter-Capitol Marketing Corporation versus National Labor Relations Commission, where a chief accountant's failure to observe normal company procedures regarding funds under her control and custody was likewise a breach of trust and confidence.
On the third issue, the Court held that Himex substantially complied with the two notice rule. The first notice apprised Oribe of the particular acts and omissions charged, and he admitted receiving it and answering the charges on 10 February 2001, which obtained the purpose of the first notice and afforded him due process. After deliberation, the company issued the second notice, the memorandum of 7 March 2001, dismissing him. The Court added that whether Himex is guilty of tax evasion is not relevant to this case, as the Bureau of Internal Revenue will have charge of that; what matters is the sloppiness of Oribe's work as chief accountant, which Himex substantially established.
Doctrine
Loss of trust and confidence as a just cause under Article 282 paragraph (c) of the Labor Code requires that the employee hold a position of responsibility or trust and confidence, that he be invested with confidence on delicate matters such as the custody, handling, care and protection of the employer's property and assets, and that the act complained of be work related and show him unfit to continue such delicate and sensitive work. A chief accountant occupies such a position, and failure to apply correct accounting principles, to implement internal accounting controls, and to furnish worksheets to the external auditor is a breach of that trust. The two notice rule under Article 277 paragraph (b) is satisfied by substantial compliance: a first notice apprising the employee of the particular acts or omissions charged, a reasonable period to answer, and a second notice informing him of the decision to dismiss after deliberation. Non-compliance is fatal because the requirements are conditions sine qua non before dismissal may be validly effected, but where the employee actually receives the charge and answers it, the purpose of the rule is obtained.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed and the Commission's decision affirming the Labor Arbiter's dismissal of Oribe's complaint for illegal dismissal was affirmed; Himex won.
Remember This
The single line to memorize: loss of trust and confidence must rest on a work-related act showing the employee unfit for a position of trust, and the two notice rule is met by substantial compliance where the employee receives the charge and answers it. Examiners use this case to test the managerial employee standard under Article 282 paragraph (c) and the substantial compliance doctrine under Article 277 paragraph (b).