CESAR N. SARINO, PROF. H. HARRY L. ROQUE, JR. OSCAR EVANGELISTA, CAESAR VENTURA, GERARDO ORTEGA, RENATO TENORIO, JR., COSICO, AND MICAHEL B. DALABAJAN, SUNDIAM, PETITIONERS-APPE…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Sarino versus Ermita
The Case
This is an appeal brought by Cesar Sarino, Professor H. Harry Roque, Junior, and several other citizens, taxpayers, and residents of the Province of Palawan against Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita, the Secretaries of Energy, Finance, and Budget, and the provincial and local officials of Palawan. The petitioners had gone to the Regional Trial Court of Puerto Princesa City seeking the extraordinary writs of certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus, with a prayer for a preliminary injunction, to stop the national government from treating the Camago-Malampaya natural gas fields as outside Palawan and to compel the release of what the province claims as its forty percent share of the proceeds. The case matters because it fixes the territorial reach of a Regional Trial Court's power to issue extraordinary writs — a jurisdictional rule every practitioner must know before choosing a forum.
Procedural History
The petitioners filed their petition for certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus, with a prayer for a writ of preliminary injunction, before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 51, of Puerto Princesa City, Palawan. The trial court, in an Order dated December 21, 2005, dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction, reasoning that the writs prayed for were directed against national officials outside its territorial jurisdiction, and relying on Section 21 of Batas Pambansa Bilang 129 and on the rulings in Tan versus Sarmiento and Embassy Farms versus Court of Appeals. The petitioners then appealed to the Supreme Court under Rule 41 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure. The appeal was dismissed and the trial court's Order was affirmed.
Facts
On December 11, 1990, the National Government, through the Department of Energy, entered into a multi-billion dollar service contract with Shell Philippines Exploration and Occidental Philippines for petroleum operations in the Camago-Malampaya area, located some eighty kilometers from the coast of Palawan in the South China Sea. A dispute later arose over the proportionate share in the proceeds of the project. The provincial government of Palawan claimed a forty percent share under the Local Government Code of 1991, asserting that the area lies within its territorial jurisdiction, while the National Government, through the Departments of Finance and Budget, disputed the claim and insisted the area is outside Palawan.
Negotiations between the national agencies and the provincial government proved unsuccessful. On March 14, 2003, Governor Joel Reyes wrote the national secretaries reiterating the demand for Palawan's equitable share and calling off further negotiations. On May 7, 2003, the provincial government formally filed a petition for declaratory relief to resolve the territorial controversy.
The petitioners then instituted their petition for certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus, arguing that the pronouncements of the Chief Executive and the acts of her cabinet secretaries reflected a policy of treating the Camago-Malampaya fields as outside Palawan. They pointed to Executive Orders Numbered 254 and 254-A, which granted Six Hundred Million Pesos in financial assistance to the provincial government as a contribution to the project rather than as recognition of a territorial right, to an earmark of Seven Hundred Seventy-Four Million, Seven Hundred Fifty Thousand Pesos in the 2003 budget of the Department of Energy, and to an Interim Agreement on proceeds-sharing which they alleged was contrary to the Constitution and existing statutes. The trial court dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction, and the petitioners appealed.
Issues
- Whether or not the Regional Trial Court of Palawan has jurisdiction to entertain a petition for certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus under Rule 65 against national and local officials, where the acts sought to be restrained or compelled are not shown to be performed or about to be performed within its territorial jurisdiction.
Applicable Provisions
Paragraph 1 of Section 21 of Batas Pambansa Bilang 129 provides:
Regional Trial Courts shall exercise original jurisdiction in the issuance of writs of certiorari, prohibition, mandamus, quo warranto, habeas corpus and injunction which may be enforced in any part of their respective regions.
This is the provision the Court construes, and its phrase "which may be enforced in any part of their respective regions" confines the writs to the court's own region.
Ruling
The Court held that the appeal is without merit and that the Regional Trial Court correctly dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction. The Court stressed that paragraph 1 of Section 21 of Batas Pambansa Bilang 129 is explicit in confining the jurisdiction of Regional Trial Courts to issue extraordinary writs to those which may be enforced in any part of their respective regions. It then examined what the petition actually sought: to prohibit the enforcement and implementation of Executive Orders Numbered 254 and 254-A and the execution of the Interim Agreement on proceeds-sharing; to prohibit the disbursement of funds under those orders and the special use provision of the 2003 budget of the Department of Energy; to direct the National Government, through the Departments of Energy, Finance, and Budget, to release the forty percent share of Palawan; and to enjoin the disbursement of the allocated funds.
The Court noted that although the funds under the executive orders had already been disbursed, the acts sought to be restrained also included the implementation of the Interim Agreement and the release of the alleged share, which the petitioners directed to be performed by national agencies all situated and holding office in the National Capital Region. The determinative test, drawn from Decano versus Edu, is whether the acts subject of the extraordinary writs are being performed or about to be performed within the court's territorial jurisdiction. Since they were not shown to be so performed, the writs would be futile. The Court added that the ruling in Tan versus Sarmiento remains good law and has been followed after Batas Pambansa Bilang 129 took effect, in Embassy Farms, Martin versus Guerrero, and Gomos versus Adiong.
On the point of hierarchy of courts, the Court found the petitioners' observance laudable, but held that direct resort to the higher courts is allowable where exceptional and compelling circumstances justify it, as where complete relief cannot otherwise be afforded. Because the respondents included national agencies holding office in the National Capital Region, and the writs would direct acts by those agencies outside the trial court's territory, direct resort to the higher courts was permissible. The Court closed by noting that certiorari, prohibition, and mandamus are appropriate remedies to raise constitutional issues and to review and nullify, when proper, acts of legislative and executive officials.
Doctrine
The jurisdiction of a Regional Trial Court to issue the extraordinary writs of certiorari, prohibition, mandamus, and injunction is confined to writs that may be enforced within its own region, as paragraph 1 of Section 21 of Batas Pambansa Bilang 129 commands. The determinative test is whether the acts subject of the writs are being performed or about to be performed within the court's territorial jurisdiction; if they are to be performed elsewhere, the court has no jurisdiction and any writ would be futile. Where the relief sought requires acts by national agencies holding office outside the trial court's region, direct resort to the Court of Appeals or the Supreme Court is allowed, since those courts may issue writs enforceable nationwide.
Disposition
The appeal was dismissed and the trial court's Order of December 21, 2005, dismissing the petition for lack of jurisdiction, was affirmed; the respondents prevailed.
Remember This
Memorize the line: a Regional Trial Court's extraordinary writs reach only as far as its region, and the test is where the acts are performed or about to be performed. Examiners use this case to test jurisdiction over Rule 65 petitions against national officials and the proper application of the hierarchy of courts.