🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. ALBERTO VIADO, JR. Y REYES AND ERNESTO VIADO Y REYES, ACCUSED-APPELLANTS.

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

People versus Viado

The Case

People versus Viado is a criminal case in which the People of the Philippines prosecuted Alberto Viado, Junior and Ernesto Viado, both surnamed Reyes, as accused. The matter reached the Supreme Court on a motion for reconsideration of the Court's own decision, and the Court was asked to reconsider that decision. The case matters to a reviewee less for its facts than for what it teaches about finality and about the narrow room a motion for reconsideration is given: a litigant who simply repeats arguments already passed upon, or who offers new arguments that are not cogent or compelling, will not move the Court to modify, much less reverse, its judgment.

Procedural History

The accused-appellants filed a motion for reconsideration praying that the Court reconsider its decision of March 24, 2014. The decision sought to be reconsidered had already resolved the case against them. The motion for reconsideration was the vehicle by which the matter was again brought before the Supreme Court, and the Court resolved it in the assailed resolution. The text before us records the Court's ruling on that motion and the concurrence of Justices Lopez and Inting.

Facts

The accused-appellants, Alberto Viado, Junior and Ernesto Viado, both surnamed Reyes, were the subject of a decision of the Supreme Court dated March 24, 2014. That decision disposed of the case against them.

Seeking to overturn that result, the accused-appellants filed a motion for reconsideration. In it they raised grounds and arguments in support of their prayer for reconsideration.

The Court examined those grounds and arguments. It found that the reasons and arguments had already been amply treated, discussed, and passed upon in the March 24, 2014 decision, and that the additional arguments offered constituted no cogent or compelling reason to modify, much less reverse, that decision.

Issues

  • Whether or not the grounds and arguments raised in the accused-appellants' motion for reconsideration warrant the reconsideration of the Court's March 24, 2014 decision.
  • Whether or not the additional arguments proffered in the motion constitute a cogent or compelling reason to modify, much less reverse, that decision.

Applicable Provisions

The decision text before us quotes no statutory provision and construes no statute. It rests entirely on the Court's assessment of the motion for reconsideration. Accordingly, no provision is quoted here, because none is quoted or discussed in the decision text.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the motion for reconsideration must fail. It found that the reasons and the arguments in support of the motion had been amply treated, discussed, and passed upon in the March 24, 2014 decision. A motion that merely reprises what the Court has already resolved gives the Court nothing new to decide.

On the second issue, the Court held that the additional arguments proffered in the motion constituted no cogent or compelling reason to modify, much less reverse, its decision. The standard the Court applied is exacting: new matter must be cogent, meaning convincing, and compelling, meaning it moves the Court to act. Absent that, the judgment stands.

The Court's dispositive language states the rule of the case:

Wherefore, the motion for reconsideration is denied for lack of merit.

The concurrence of Justices Lopez and Inting completed the resolution.

Doctrine

A motion for reconsideration is not a second appeal and not a fresh opportunity to reargue the case. The rules a Bar candidate should retain are these. First, a motion for reconsideration is denied for lack of merit where its grounds and arguments have already been amply treated, discussed, and passed upon in the decision sought to be reconsidered. Second, additional arguments offered in a motion for reconsideration must constitute a cogent or compelling reason to modify, much less reverse, the decision; arguments that do not meet that standard leave the judgment undisturbed. Third, the Court will not modify, much less reverse, its decision on the strength of arguments that add nothing to what it has already ruled upon.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied the accused-appellants' motion for reconsideration for lack of merit, leaving its March 24, 2014 decision in force.

Remember This

The line worth memorizing is that a motion for reconsideration is denied for lack of merit where its grounds have already been amply treated, discussed, and passed upon, and its additional arguments are no cogent or compelling reason to modify, much less reverse, the decision. Examiners use this case on the nature and limits of a motion for reconsideration, and on the finality of judgments.