🎧 Case Brief Lecture

BANK OF COMMERCE, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. FELTMAN BROS., CORP., AND ACE APPAREL ASSOCIATES, INC., DEFENDANT-APPELLANT.

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Bank of Commerce versus Feltman Bros., Corp. and Ace Apparel Associates, Inc

The Case

This is a case in which the Bank of Commerce, as plaintiff and appellee, sought to collect a monetary obligation from Feltman Bros., Corp. and Ace Apparel Associates, Inc., as defendants and appellant. Rather than resolving the dispute through a full adversarial judgment, the parties chose the path of amicable settlement, and the decision before us is the Court's approval of the Compromise Agreement they reached through mediation. The case matters to a Bar candidate because it illustrates the force and effect of a judicially approved compromise: once the Court finds the terms not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy, it renders judgment adopting those terms and enjoins the parties to comply in good faith, closing and terminating the case.

Procedural History

The action originated in the Regional Trial Court, Branch 139, Makati City, where the Bank of Commerce sued the defendants for the enforcement of a monetary obligation. While the case was pending, the parties were referred to mediation, and through their authorized representatives and assisted by their respective counsel, they arrived at a Compromise Agreement. The parties then filed this Compromise Agreement with the Court, praying that it be approved as not contrary to law, morals, good customs and public policy, and that judgment be rendered in accordance therewith. The Court, finding the terms mutually agreed upon to be consistent with law and public policy, approved the agreement and rendered judgment adopting its terms. The case thus reached the Supreme Court on the parties' joint submission of the Compromise Agreement for approval, and the Court resolved it in the decision now before us.

Facts

The Bank of Commerce held a monetary claim against Feltman Bros., Corp. and Ace Apparel Associates, Inc. To amicably settle the case for their mutual satisfaction, the parties, assisted by their respective counsel, executed a Compromise Agreement fixing the obligation of the defendant-appellant to the plaintiff-appellee in the total amount of 3,400,000 pesos.

Under the agreement, this obligation was to be paid in twenty-two equal monthly installments of 150,000 pesos, beginning on the fifteenth of June 2007 and every fifteenth day of each month thereafter until the fifteenth of March 2009. The remaining balance of 100,000 pesos was made due on the fifteenth of April 2009.

The agreement further provided that in the event the defendant-appellant failed to pay at least three consecutive monthly installments when due, the entire remaining balance would then become immediately due and demandable, and the plaintiff-appellee would then be entitled to the issuance of a Writ of Execution upon motion before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 139, Makati City. The parties prayed that the Compromise Agreement be approved and that judgment be rendered in accordance therewith.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Compromise Agreement entered into by the parties through mediation may be approved by the Court.
  • Whether or not the terms of the Compromise Agreement are contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy.
  • Whether or not judgment may be rendered adopting the terms of the Compromise Agreement and enjoining the parties to comply therewith in good faith.

Applicable Provisions

The Compromise Agreement itself, as quoted in the decision, provides the terms the Court was asked to approve:

The parties hereby fix the obligation of Defendant-Appellant to Plaintiff-Appellee in the total amount of P3,400,000.00. The aforesaid obligation shall be paid by the Defendant-Appellant in Twenty-Two (22) equal monthly installments of P150,000.00 beginning June 15, 2007 and every 15th day of each month thereafter until March 15, 2009. The remaining balance of P100,000.00 shall be due on April 15, 2009. In the event the Defendant-Appellant failed to pay at least thee (3) (sic) consecutive monthly installments when due, the entire remaining balance shall then become immediately due and demandable and the Plaintiff-Appellee shall then be entitles (sic) to the issuance of a Writ of Execution upon motion before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 139, Makati City.

These terms fix the amount, the schedule of installments, the acceleration clause, and the remedy of execution, and they are the very terms the Court adopted in its judgment.

The prayer of the parties, also quoted in the decision, states the relief sought:

WHEREFORE, it is most respectfully prayed of the Honorable Court that the foregoing Compromise Agreement, not be (sic) contrary to law, morals, good customs and public policy, be approved and that judgement (sic) be rendered in accordance therewith.

This prayer frames the standard the Court applied in deciding whether to approve the agreement.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court approved the Compromise Agreement. It found that the terms mutually agreed upon by the parties are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy. The Court stated:

The Court finds that the foregoing terms of the Compromise Agreement mutually agreed upon by the parties are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy.

On the second issue, the Court held that the terms of the Compromise Agreement pass the test of validity, being consistent with law, morals, good customs, public order and public policy. Having so found, the Court gave the agreement the force of a judgment.

On the third issue, the Court rendered judgment adopting the terms of the Compromise Agreement and enjoined the parties to comply therewith in good faith. It declared the case closed and terminated. The Court stated:

WHEREFORE, the subject Compromise Agreement between the herein parties is approved. Judgment is hereby rendered adopting the terms thereof and enjoining the parties to comply therewith in good faith. This case is now deemed CLOSED and TERMINATED.

Doctrine

A compromise agreement entered into by the parties through mediation, assisted by their respective counsel, may be approved by the Court where its terms are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy. Once approved, the Court renders judgment adopting the terms of the compromise and enjoins the parties to comply therewith in good faith, and the case is deemed closed and terminated. The agreement's terms, including the fixed obligation, the schedule of installments, the acceleration clause upon failure to pay at least three consecutive monthly installments, and the remedy of execution upon motion, become the law between the parties and the basis of the judgment. The standard for approval is that the terms must not be contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy, as the Court expressly found in this case.

Disposition

The Court approved the Compromise Agreement, rendered judgment adopting its terms, enjoined the parties to comply therewith in good faith, and declared the case closed and terminated.

Remember This

The single line worth memorizing is that a compromise agreement whose terms are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy is approved and becomes the judgment of the Court, which enjoins the parties to comply in good faith and closes and terminates the case. Examiners like to use this case on the approval of compromise agreements through mediation, the effect of a judicially approved compromise as the law between the parties, and the acceleration and execution clauses that such agreements may contain.