ESTELITA P. PACARDO, PETITIONER, VS. COMMISSION ON AUDIT, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Pacardo versus Commission on Audit
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Estelita P. Pacardo against the Commission on Audit, asking the Supreme Court to overturn the administrative finding of the Office of the Ombudsman-Mindanao that she is liable for Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service and to set aside the one-year suspension imposed on her. The case matters because it fixes the standard of substantial evidence needed to hold a member of a Bids and Awards Committee administratively liable for simulated biddings and overpriced purchases, and because it identifies which procurement law governed transactions made in 1998, before the passage of the Government Procurement Reform Act.
Procedural History
Acting on an anonymous letter, the Department of Agriculture asked the Commission on Audit to conduct an audit and fact-finding investigation of its Region IX office in Zamboanga City. State Auditor Bernardo R. Sumicad conducted the investigation and produced a Report on the Audit and Fact-Finding Investigation dated 07 July 1999. Charges were filed before the Office of the Ombudsman-Mindanao, docketed as OMB-MIN-ADM-00-200, and several employees of the Department, including Pacardo and Salvador P. Peñaflor, all members of the Bids and Awards Committee, filed a Joint Counter-Affidavit dated 27 September 2001.
On 11 June 2002, the Office of the Ombudsman-Mindanao rendered a Decision dated 15 April 2002 finding substantial evidence of dishonesty and imposing dismissal from the service on twenty-six respondents, including Pacardo. Pacardo and others moved for reconsideration. In an Order dated 20 January 2005, the Ombudsman partially granted the motion, modifying the Decision: for the first two findings, Pacardo and several others were held liable for the less grave offense of Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service and meted one year of suspension from office.
Pacardo and Peñaflor each filed a Petition for Review under Rule 43 of the Rules of Court. Their petitions, filed on 07 November 2008, were late because the Court had granted only a fifteen-day extension, but the Court admitted them in its Resolution dated 23 January 2009. The Commission on Audit failed to submit its Comment and was deemed to have waived it, but later filed a Memorandum through the Office of the Solicitor General. The Court consolidated the two cases motu proprio in its Resolution dated 18 April 2013, and in its Resolution dated 23 October 2013 declared the petitions submitted for decision.
Facts
In 1998, the Department of Agriculture, Region IX, in Zamboanga City, procured various goods: seeds of various vegetables and garden tools, and office supplies, construction materials, cellular battery and computer supplies, and polyethylene bags. Pacardo sat as a member of the Bids and Awards Committee that handled these procurements.
The Commission on Audit's investigation, reported on 07 July 1999, found that biddings were simulated in at least four instances and that five Requests for Quotations of one participant were falsified, giving undue advantage to favored suppliers and facilitating the jacking up of prices. It also found that purchases from Hundred Years Trading and General Merchandise were higher than independent canvasses by other government agencies from the same store.
The Ombudsman initially found dishonesty and imposed dismissal, but on reconsideration held Pacardo and her co-members of the Bids and Awards Committee liable only for Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service and suspended them for one year. Pacardo brought the matter to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether or not Pacardo was in bad faith or acted with malice in performing her added duties as a member of the Bids and Awards Committee.
- Whether or not there is substantial evidence to hold Pacardo administratively liable for Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service, that is, whether the falsification of public documents, the simulated biddings, and the overpricing were actually proved.
Applicable Provisions
Section 3 of Executive Order No. 302, issued in 1996, provides:
To ensure efficiency and equitable treatment, awarding of contracts shall be done through public/open competitive bidding unless another type of procurement method is necessary as prescribed under the implementing rules and regulations of this EO.
This is the governing procurement rule for the 1998 transactions, and it anchors the finding that the biddings should have been open and competitive.
Section 4 of the same Executive Order provides:
There shall be a Prequalification, Bid and Award Committee which shall be responsible for the c
This provision identifies the committee to which Pacardo belonged and from which her duties flowed.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the records supported the finding of bad faith. The audit report showed that the Bids and Awards Committee members awarded contracts to favored suppliers despite falsified bid documents and simulated biddings, and that they allowed the falsified bids. The Court noted that the falsification happened at least four times and should have been known to the committee members during the delivery of the requests for quotation, the opening of the bids, or the committee deliberations.
On the second issue, the Court ruled in the affirmative: substantial evidence established Pacardo's culpability. The Court first determined the governing law, since the transactions took place in 1998 and were reported in 1999. Applying Executive Order No. 302, the Court found that the biddings were not conducted through open competitive bidding as required, and that the committee awarded contracts in bad faith. The Court held that the Ombudsman's finding of Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service was supported by substantial evidence, and upheld the one-year suspension.
Doctrine
A public office is a public trust, and public officers must at all times be accountable to the people, serve them with utmost responsibility, integrity, loyalty, and efficiency. But this strict accountability is balanced by the constitutional requirement that there be a cause and due process before disciplinary authority may be validly exercised.
Administrative liability for Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service may be established by substantial evidence. Where the audit report shows simulated biddings, falsified bid documents, and overpriced purchases, the members of the Bids and Awards Committee who awarded the contracts cannot escape liability by claiming good faith, because the irregularities should have been known to them during the bidding process.
For transactions made in 1998, the governing procurement rule is Executive Order No. 302, which requires public or open competitive bidding, not the later Government Procurement Reform Act.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petitions and affirmed the finding of the Office of the Ombudsman-Mindanao holding Pacardo liable for Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service and imposing one year of suspension from the service.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing: members of a Bids and Awards Committee are liable for Conduct Prejudicial to the Best Interest of the Service when simulated biddings and falsified bid documents are shown by substantial evidence, because these irregularities should have been known to them. Examiners use this case to test the substantial evidence standard in administrative cases and the rule that Executive Order No. 302, not the Government Procurement Reform Act, governs 1998 procurements.