🎧 Case Brief Lecture

REYNALDO MORALIDAD, PETITIONER, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, ASIAN TERMINALS, PROMULGATED: INC. AND/OR RICHARD BARCLAY, RESPONDENTS.

May 27, 2002

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Moralidad versus National Labor Relations Commission

The Case

This is a petition for certiorari brought by Reynaldo Moralidad against the National Labor Relations Commission, Asian Terminals, Incorporated, and Richard Barclay. Moralidad asks the Supreme Court to set aside the labor commission's reversal of a labor arbiter's finding that he was illegally dismissed. The case matters because it gathers in one place the two pillars every illegal dismissal answer must stand on: the employer's burden of proof, and the twin notice rule. It also teaches what quality of evidence may support a dismissal, and what a plain photocopy of an unsworn statement is worth.

Procedural History

Moralidad filed a complaint for illegal dismissal, illegal deductions, service incentive leave pay, damages, and attorney's fees against the respondents. The labor arbiter rendered a decision declaring him illegally dismissed and ordering the payment of backwages and separation pay, while dismissing the rest of his claims. Asian Terminals appealed, and the National Labor Relations Commission reversed and set aside the labor arbiter's decision, rendering a new one dismissing the complaint for lack of merit. Moralidad moved for reconsideration, and the commission denied it. He then came to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari, assigning grave abuse of discretion to the commission.

Facts

Moralidad alleged that from May 1990 until April 1997 he was an employee of Asian Terminals, holding the position of Supervisor III. Sometime in November 1996, the company summoned him to a meeting to explain and give his side on an alleged anomaly in connection with its incentive pay report. Moralidad denied any knowledge of or involvement in the anomaly. On April 11, 1997, the company dismissed him by a termination letter.

Moralidad insisted that there was no basis for his dismissal because he was innocent of the charges, and that he was denied due process because he was never given the chance to defend himself or to confront the witnesses against him. The company answered that its officers had uncovered several anomalies, including payroll padding, falsification, alteration of entries in company records, and inexcusable negligence, and that Moralidad actively participated in the incentive pay anomaly. It pointed to Alberto Montevirgin, a fellow supervisor, as its witness, and claimed Moralidad had been apprised of his rights and heard in an administrative investigation.

What the records showed, however, was that the company submitted only a plain photocopy of an unsworn and unnotarized statement of Montevirgin, nothing more. The labor arbiter found the alleged participation not clearly proven. The commission, on the other hand, upheld the dismissal on the strength of that statement, which it said was corroborated by other witnesses.

Issues

  • Whether or not the unsworn statement of witness Alberto Montevirgin could be used as evidence in holding the dismissal of the petitioner valid.
  • Whether or not there exists a valid ground for the petitioner's dismissal.

Applicable Provisions

The decision applies the rule that the burden of proving a valid dismissal rests on the employer, as settled in Azcor Manufacturing versus the National Labor Relations Commission:

In illegal dismissal cases like the present one, the onus of proving that the dismissal of the employee was for a valid and authorized cause rests on the employer and failure to discharge the same would mean that the dismissal is not justified and therefore illegal.

This fixes who must prove what, and tells us that failure to discharge the burden means the dismissal is illegal.

The decision also applies the rule on the admissibility of evidence before the labor tribunals, as stated in Uichico versus the National Labor Relations Commission:

While the rules of evidence prevailing in the courts of law or equity are not controlling in proceedings before the National Labor Relations Commission, the evidence presented before it must at least have a modicum of admissibility for it to be given some probative value.

This governs whether the photocopied unsworn statement can carry any probative weight at all.

Finally, the decision applies the twin notice rule, as laid down in Rodriguez, Junior versus the National Labor Relations Commission:

Two notices are required before an employee may be validly dismissed: (a) written notice containing a statement of the cause for termination, to afford the employee an opportunity to be heard and defend himself with the assistance of his representative, if he desires; and (b) if the employer decides to terminate the services of the employee, written notice must be given to the employee stating clearly the reason therefor.

This supplies the procedural yardstick against which the company's termination letter is measured.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the unsworn statement could not sustain the dismissal. The commission relied on Montevirgin's statement implicating Moralidad, and said it was corroborated by other witnesses. But the records showed that the company submitted only a plain photocopy of an unsworn and unnotarized statement, nothing else and nothing more. That is insufficient and inadequate to uphold a dismissal. The Court stressed that while the rules of evidence prevailing in courts of law or equity are not controlling in labor proceedings, the evidence must at least have a modicum of admissibility before it may be given probative value. The labor arbiter was therefore correct in holding that Moralidad's alleged participation was not clearly proven, the company's only witness having made a mere sweeping allegation that the company's foremen were involved.

On the second issue, the Court held that there was no valid ground for dismissal, and that due process was wanting as well. The burden of proving a valid and authorized cause rested on the employer, and the company failed to discharge it. Beyond that failure, the company also failed to serve the first required notice, the written notice stating the cause for termination that would have apprised Moralidad of the particular acts or omissions for which his dismissal was sought. That failure, taken together with the lack of just cause, rendered the dismissal illegal. The commission therefore acted with grave abuse of discretion correctible by certiorari.

Doctrine

First, in illegal dismissal cases the employer bears the onus of proving that the dismissal was for a valid and authorized cause; failure to discharge it means the dismissal is not justified and therefore illegal.

Second, although the technical rules of evidence do not control labor proceedings, the evidence offered must at least have a modicum of admissibility to be given probative value. A plain photocopy of an unsworn and unnotarized statement falls short, and cannot by itself support a dismissal.

Third, two notices are required before an employee may be validly dismissed: a written notice stating the cause for termination, affording the employee an opportunity to be heard and to defend himself with the assistance of a representative if he desires; and, if the employer decides to terminate, a written notice stating clearly the reason therefor. Failure to serve the first notice renders the dismissal illegal.

Disposition

The petition was given due course and granted. The commission's decision and its resolution denying reconsideration were set aside and vacated, and the labor arbiter's decision finding Moralidad illegally dismissed was reinstated.

Remember This

Memorize this line: a plain photocopy of an unsworn and unnotarized statement is not even a modicum of admissible evidence, and the employer who fails to serve the first notice dismisses illegally. Examiners like to use this case on the employer's burden of proof, on the quantum and quality of evidence in labor cases, and on the twin notice rule.