🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ROBUST ROCKS RESOURCES CORPORATION, PETITIONER, VS. HON. ENRIQUE T. GARCIA, JR., IN HIS PERSONAL CAPACITY AS THE GOVERNOR OF THE PROVINCE OF BATAAN, AND EMERLINDA S. TALENTO IN …

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Robust Rocks Resources Corporation versus Garcia

The Case

This is a special civil action for prohibition and mandamus with a prayer for injunctive relief, brought by Robust Rocks Resources Corporation against the Governor of Bataan, Enrique T. Garcia, Jr., in his personal capacity, and Emerlinda S. Talento. Robust Rocks is a quarry operator holding a quarry permit over an area in Bataan. It asks the Court to stop the province from collecting the sand and gravel tax and the real property tax it has assessed, to compel the issuance of renewed quarry permits, and to restrain the closure of its operations. The case matters to a reviewee because the Court never reaches the merits of the tax and permit questions. It disposes of the petition on a single procedural ground, forum shopping, and in doing so restates the elements of that rule with unusual clarity.

Procedural History

Robust Rocks first went to the Regional Trial Court of Balanga, Bataan, Branch 4, filing a petition for prohibition and mandamus with a prayer for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. That case was docketed as Special Civil Action No. 045-ML. Its object was to enjoin the provincial treasurer from proceeding with a notice of sale of the company's properties for unpaid assessments, and to stop the collection of the assessed taxes. A seventy-two hour temporary restraining order was issued to preserve the status quo, and the parties agreed to comply with that status quo order.

Separately, Robust Rocks filed the present petition directly with the Supreme Court, again seeking to restrain the collection of the same taxes and to compel the issuance of quarry permits. The Court issued a temporary restraining order in May 2005 directing the respondents to refrain from stopping the quarry operations by dispatching armed men to intimidate employees. The respondents filed their comment, raising, among other defenses, that Robust Rocks was not the real party in interest, that the renewal requirements had not been complied with, that the company had extracted more than the allowable volume, and that it was guilty of forum shopping. The Court resolved to give priority to the forum shopping question.

Facts

Robust Rocks Resources Corporation is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission and operates rock quarrying in Bataan under Quarry Permit No. QP-B-97-001, which was periodically renewed. In 2002, the province of Bataan, through then Governor Leonardo Roman, imposed on the company a sand and gravel tax at ten percent of the fair market value of the quarry resources extracted, and a real property tax on its machineries without any depreciation allowance, which the company pegged at five percent of the machineries' original cost for each year of use.

Robust Rocks disputed the impositions. Despite the dispute, the provincial treasurer issued on November 14, 2002 a notice of sale of the company's properties for the unpaid assessments. On December 5, 2002, the company filed the prohibition and mandamus petition with the Balanga trial court, docketed as Special Civil Action No. 045-ML, to enjoin the sale and the collection of the assessed taxes.

The company also complained that Governor Garcia, Jr. refused to issue the corresponding quarry permits despite payment of the required fees and the approval of previous renewal applications, and that he issued a closure order through Executive Order No. 14. It alleged that armed men in civilian clothes were used to threaten its officers and employees. It prayed that the closure order be declared invalid, that the Governor be ordered to issue the permits, that the respondents cease and desist from implementing the closure order and from collecting the taxes, and that damages be paid. The prayer to declare Executive Order No. 14 invalid was later removed by amendment.

Issues

  • Whether or not Robust Rocks committed forum shopping in filing the present petition in the Supreme Court while Special Civil Action No. 045-ML was pending before the Regional Trial Court of Balanga, Bataan.
  • Whether or not the Court may still resolve the other issues raised, including the propriety of the tax assessments and the prayer for mandamus to issue the quarry permits.

Applicable Provisions

The decision does not quote a statutory text. It applies the settled rule against forum shopping, which it states as follows:

Forum shopping is the filing of multiple suits involving the same parties for the same cause of action, either simultaneously or successively, for the purpose of obtaining a favorable judgment.

This definition is the test the Court applies to the company's two petitions.

The Court then lays down the elements, drawn from its own jurisprudence:

There is forum shopping when the following elements are present: a) identity of parties or at least such parties as represent the same interests in both actions; b) identity of rights asserted and relief prayed for, the relief being founded on the same facts; and c) the identity of the two preceding particulars, is such that any judgment rendered in the other action will, regardless of which party is successful, amount to res judicata in the action under consideration, said requisites [are] also constitutive of the requisites for auter action pendant or lis pendens.

These elements are the measure against which the two petitions are compared.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that Robust Rocks committed forum shopping. It compared the two petitions and found that the issues raised in Special Civil Action No. 045-ML and in the present petition boil down to one question, the propriety of the imposition of the tax assessments made by the respondents upon Robust Rocks. The parties in both cases are the same, or at least represent the same interests: the petitioner in both is the party upon which the assessments are imposed, and the respondents are those who effected and are attempting to collect the assessments. The reliefs prayed for in both petitions are founded on the same facts. And the identity in these two particulars is such that any judgment rendered in Special Civil Action No. 045-ML will, regardless of who succeeds, amount to res judicata in the present action.

On the second issue, the Court held that there was no necessity to dwell on the other issues. Having found forum shopping, it dismissed the petition outright and quashed any ancillary remedy it had issued.

Doctrine

A Bar candidate should retain the following rules. First, forum shopping is the filing of multiple suits involving the same parties for the same cause of action, either simultaneously or successively, for the purpose of obtaining a favorable judgment. Second, a party violates the rule against forum shopping if the elements of litis pendentia are present, or if a final judgment in one case would amount to res judicata in the other. Third, the elements are identity of parties or of parties representing the same interests; identity of the rights asserted and the relief prayed for, the relief being founded on the same facts; and an identity of these two particulars such that any judgment rendered in the other action will, regardless of which party is successful, amount to res judicata in the action under consideration. These are the same requisites as those of auter action pendant, or lis pendens. Fourth, where forum shopping is established, the Court need not resolve the merits, and the petition is dismissed with its ancillary remedies quashed.

Disposition

The petition was dismissed and any ancillary remedy issued in it was quashed, so the respondents prevailed on procedural grounds.

Remember This

Memorize the three elements of forum shopping as the Court states them, because they are also the requisites of lis pendens. Examiners use this case to test whether a student can spot forum shopping from the identity of parties, rights, and reliefs, and whether the student knows that a finding of forum shopping ends the inquiry without reaching the merits.