MACDONALDO LICLICAN, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, VS. HEIRS OF MANUEL MAGNO, DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Liclican versus Heirs of Magno
The Case
This is a lecture on Liclican versus the Heirs of Magno, a decision of the Supreme Court through Justice Mendoza. Macdonaldo Liclican sued the heirs of Manuel Magno, asking the court to compel Magno to accept his tender of 275,000 pesos and to discharge a real estate mortgage, and to declare the foreclosure sale of the mortgaged lot void. The case matters because it gathers in one place the rules every reviewee must know on the real nature of a mortgage, the effect of registration against later transferees, the one year redemption period in extrajudicial foreclosure, and the power of the courts to reduce iniquitous interest rates.
Procedural History
Two cases were filed before the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 21, and were consolidated. The first was Civil Case Number 94-69096, an action for specific performance, consignation and damages filed by Liclican against Manuel Magno. The second was Civil Case Number 94-70530, an action by Ronaldo Vasquez to declare the nullity of the attachment and the sheriff's sale of a family home, with damages. Magno died during the pendency of the case and was substituted by his heirs.
On August 30, 1999, the trial court rendered a consolidated decision dismissing both cases for lack of merit, and likewise dismissing the defendants' counterclaims, without pronouncement as to costs. Liclican appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning three errors: that the trial court failed to hold that he, as junior encumbrancer, was entitled to discharge the mortgage for 275,000 pesos; that Magno failed to prove that the 1,239,121 pesos was secured by the mortgage; and that the foreclosure sale was void because the consideration was excessive.
Facts
On May 24, 1989, the spouses Rodolfo and Amelia Vasquez executed a promissory note in favor of Manuel Magno for 275,000 pesos, payable on or before June 24, 1989, with interest at five percent per month and an additional one percent per month as penalty if the interest was not paid on time. On the same date they constituted a real estate mortgage over a parcel of land covered by Transfer Certificate of Title Number 186582. The mortgage was registered on May 26, 1989.
Earlier, Liclican had sued Vasquez for a sum of money, and the parties signed a compromise agreement which the court approved. When Vasquez failed to pay, a writ of execution issued, and the same lot was levied upon and sold at public auction, with Liclican as the highest bidder for 200,000 pesos. Vasquez did not redeem the property within one year from registration of the certificate of sale.
Liclican then offered to pay Magno 275,000 pesos to discharge the mortgage, but Magno refused, insisting that the total mortgage obligation was 1,239,121 pesos, and warned that he would foreclose. Liclican did not pay, and Vasquez did not pay either. Magno instituted extrajudicial foreclosure proceedings and emerged as the sole and winning bidder for 1,482,461 pesos. The certificate of sale was registered on May 5, 1994. Liclican never redeemed the property within the one year period, and ownership was consolidated in Magno on May 5, 1995.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in dismissing the action for specific performance, consignation and damages, and in not ordering Magno to accept the 275,000 pesos to discharge the mortgage.
- Whether or not Magno failed to prove that the 1,239,121 pesos was secured by the real estate mortgage.
- Whether or not the foreclosure sale was void because the consideration was excessive and unreasonable.
Applicable Provisions
Article 2126 of the Civil Code provides:
Article 2126. The mortgage directly and immediately subjects the property upon which it is imposed, whoever the possessor may be, to the fulfillment of the obligation for whose security it was constituted.
This is the provision that makes the mortgage a real right that follows the property into the hands of Liclican as transferee.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the mortgage is merely an accessory contract; the principal contract is the promissory note of May 24, 1989. Hence the liability of the spouses Vasquez, and of Liclican who stepped into their shoes, is not limited to the amount reflected in the mortgage deed. Liclican, as transferee, is necessarily bound to respect the mortgage, which is a right in rem, a lien on the property whoever its owner may be. Magno committed no bad faith in foreclosing, for foreclosure is the mortgagee's right upon non-payment. Liclican had one year from the registration of the certificate of sale on May 5, 1994 to redeem, and he did not; ownership was therefore consolidated in Magno.
On the second issue, the Court held that Magno could not be compelled to accept the tender of 275,000 pesos free from interest and charges, because Liclican himself was remiss in paying the amount due. The Court, however, found the stipulated interest of six percent per month, or seventy-two percent per annum, to be excessive and unreasonable, and reduced it equitably to twelve percent per annum, following its rulings that the lifting of the usury ceiling grants lenders no carte blanche to impose enslaving rates. The alleged additional loan of 10,000 pesos was excluded because it was not covered by the mortgage.
On the third issue, the Court agreed that the interest and charges added to the principal were unreasonably excessive, but this did not void the sale; instead, Liclican has a right to share in the excess proceeds of the foreclosure sale under applicable rules and jurisprudence.
Doctrine
- A real estate mortgage is an accessory contract; the principal contract is the loan, such as a promissory note, and the debtor's liability is measured by the principal obligation, not by the amount stated in the mortgage deed alone.
- Under Article 2126 of the Civil Code, a registered mortgage is a real right, a lien inseparable from the property, which follows it into the hands of subsequent purchasers, whether the transfer be with or without the consent of the mortgagee.
- The mortgagee may foreclose upon non-payment; foreclosure is an exercise of a right, not an act of bad faith.
- The debtor or his successor-in-interest has one year from the registration of the certificate of sale to redeem in extrajudicial foreclosure under Act 3135; failure to redeem consolidates ownership in the buyer.
- Even with the lifting of the usury ceiling, courts may equitably reduce iniquitous and unconscionable interest rates; twelve percent per annum is deemed fair and reasonable.
Disposition
The Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the trial court in all respects, except that the rate of interest was reduced to twelve percent per annum, with Liclican entitled to share in the excess proceeds of the foreclosure sale.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a registered real estate mortgage is a right in rem that follows the property, and the transferee merely steps into the shoes of the mortgagor. Examiners use this case on the accessory nature of a mortgage, the one year redemption period, and the equitable reduction of excessive interest.