RODOLFO DE GUZMAN, LUZ VERCELES, ALFONSO GARCIA, VIRGILIO SANCHEZ, LITO LABIO, GINA CABASA-RES, AIDA FERNANDEZ, MARISSA ELIZARES, JOSE LOPEZ, RUMUALDO ANCA, CATALINA TASARA, EMI…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
De Guzman versus Verceles
The Case
This is a petition for review brought by Rodolfo de Guzman and his co-petitioners against Luz Verceles and the other private respondents, arising from an ejectment action over the premises the petitioners were occupying. The respondents sued for ejectment before the Metropolitan Trial Court, won, and the petitioners appealed. When the petitioners failed to file their memorandum on appeal, the Regional Trial Court dismissed the appeal. The petitioners then came to the Supreme Court asking it to annul that order of dismissal. The case matters because it teaches a hard, practical rule of remedial law: an order dismissing an appeal is not itself appealable, and once the trial court's decision becomes final, the Supreme Court will not revive it.
Procedural History
The respondents filed an action for ejectment before the Metropolitan Trial Court of Metro Manila, Branch 42, Quezon City. The petitioners filed their answer with counterclaims, the parties submitted their pre-trial briefs and other pleadings, and the trial court rendered judgment in favor of the respondents. The petitioners then filed a notice of appeal.
Four months after the appeal was taken, the Regional Trial Court, Branch 217, Quezon City, issued an order dismissing the appeals of the petitioners, because they failed to file their respective memoranda as required by the Rules. The petitioners did not stop there. They filed with the Supreme Court this petition for review under Rule 42 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, seeking to annul the Regional Trial Court's order of dismissal.
Facts
On the second of April, 2004, the respondents filed with the Metropolitan Trial Court of Quezon City an action for ejectment against the petitioners. The petitioners answered, raising counterclaims, and the case proceeded through pre-trial briefs and other pleadings.
The trial court rendered judgment in favor of the respondents. It ordered the petitioners and all persons claiming rights under them to vacate the premises and to demolish whatever structures they had introduced, to pay attorney's fees of 50,000 pesos and 3,000 pesos per court appearance, and to pay the costs of suit. The judgment was rendered pursuant to Section 17, Rule 70 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure.
Unconvinced, the petitioners filed a notice of appeal. But on appeal, they failed to file their respective memoranda as required by the Rules. Four months after the appeal was taken, the Regional Trial Court issued an order dismissing their appeals. The petitioners then filed this petition for review, asking the Supreme Court to annul that order of dismissal.
Issues
- Whether or not a petition for review may be entertained to annul an order of the Regional Trial Court dismissing an appeal for failure to file the memorandum on appeal.
- Whether or not the decision of the Metropolitan Trial Court, which had become final and executory for failure to seasonably appeal, may still be the subject of an appeal.
Applicable Provisions
Section 1, paragraph D of Rule 41 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure provides:
No appeal may be taken from an order dismissing an appeal.
This is the provision that directly bars the petition, because the petitioners are seeking to annul precisely an order dismissing their appeal.
Section 7 of Rule 40 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure is the provision the Regional Trial Court enforced when it dismissed the appeal, as the order itself recites:
Defendants-appellants having failed to file their respective memorandum as mandated under Section 7, Rule 40 of the Rules of Procedure, the separate appeals taken from the decision rendered by the court a quo by defendants-appellants Pacita Ragacho, et. al. Through counsel Atty. Evaristo Urbina and by the rest of the defendants-appellants, represented by Atty. Juan Moreno are hereby dismissed.
This is the memorandum requirement whose violation sealed the fate of the petitioners' appeal.
Section 17 of Rule 70 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure is the basis of the trial court's judgment, as its decretal portion states:
WHEREFORE, pursuant to Section 17, Rule 70, 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, judgment is hereby rendered in favor of the plaintiff and against the defendants and all persons claiming rights under them ordering the latter.
This identifies the ejectment judgment that became final and executory once the appeal was dismissed.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court dismissed the petition. It held that Section 1, paragraph D of Rule 41 clearly mandates that no appeal may be taken from an order dismissing an appeal. Since the petition for review sought the annulment of the Regional Trial Court's order dismissing the petitioners' appeal, the petition must perforce be dismissed pursuant to that rule.
On the second issue, the Court held that since the order of the Metropolitan Trial Court had become final and executory for failure to seasonably appeal from it, that decision could no longer be the subject of an appeal. The Court found the petition to have no merit in fact and in law.
Doctrine
Three rules every Bar candidate should be able to write. First, an order dismissing an appeal is not appealable. Section 1, paragraph D of Rule 41 states the rule flatly: no appeal may be taken from an order dismissing an appeal. A party who loses an appeal by failing to comply with the Rules cannot convert the dismissal order into a fresh appealable judgment.
Second, the failure to file the memorandum on appeal as required by Section 7 of Rule 40 is a ground for the dismissal of the appeal by the Regional Trial Court. The Rules impose the memorandum as a mandatory step, and non-compliance carries the sanction of dismissal.
Third, once the decision of the trial court becomes final and executory because no timely appeal was perfected, it can no longer be the subject of an appeal. Finality closes the door, and the Supreme Court will not reopen it through a petition that attacks the order of dismissal itself.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed for lack of merit, with costs against the petitioners, and the order of the Regional Trial Court dismissing the appeal stood.
Remember This
Memorize this line: no appeal may be taken from an order dismissing an appeal, and a judgment that has become final and executory can no longer be appealed. Examiners use this case to test the rule on the non-appealability of dismissal orders and the effect of finality of judgment in ejectment cases.