ATTY. EDWIN BETGUEN, ET AL., COMPLAINANTS, VS. DOMINGA P. MASANGCAY, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Betguen versus Masangcay
The Case
This is an administrative complaint for dishonesty, grave misconduct, conviction of an offense, and unauthorized absences, filed by Atty. Edwin Betguen, the Clerk of Court of the Regional Trial Court of Cabarroguis, Quirino, together with the other complainants, against Dominga Masangcay, a Clerk IV in the same Office of the Clerk of Court. The charge at the heart of the case is that Masangcay concealed the records of her own appealed criminal case after those records were remanded by the Court of Appeals to the trial court. The case matters because it shows how the Supreme Court treats a court employee who abuses her position over court records to serve her private interest, and it fixes the quantum of proof and the penalty for such conduct.
Procedural History
The matter began as an administrative complaint filed with the Supreme Court against Masangcay. Before that, her criminal case for grave oral defamation, later resolved as intriguing against honor, had run its course: the Municipal Trial Court of Cabarroguis found her guilty, the Regional Trial Court affirmed the conviction in full, and the Court of Appeals likewise affirmed it. The records of that appealed case were then remanded to the Regional Trial Court of Quirino. When the records could not be found, Atty. Betguen issued a memorandum requiring Masangcay to explain, and she denied responsibility. The Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court informed the Court Administrator that Masangcay had been declared absent without leave and recommended her dismissal. The administrative complaint was resolved by the Supreme Court itself as an original administrative matter, decided by the Court en banc.
Facts
Sometime in 1986, Jovita Cabanag and Luz Ancheta filed separate criminal complaints for grave oral defamation against Masangcay before the Municipal Trial Court of Cabarroguis, Quirino. After a joint trial, Masangcay was found guilty of intriguing against honor under Article 364 of the Revised Penal Code and was fined 200 pesos, with an order to indemnify each complainant in the amount of 5,000 pesos. The Regional Trial Court affirmed the conviction in full, and the Court of Appeals likewise affirmed it. The records of the appealed case were remanded to the Clerk of Court of the Regional Trial Court of Quirino on November 18, 1991, by registered mail.
On November 27, 1991, Masangcay received from Betty Nastor, an employee of the Post Office of Cabarroguis, the parcel from the Court of Appeals containing those records. Her receipt was attested by the Acting Postmaster and evidenced by her own signature on the registry book of the Post Office. Yet the records were nowhere to be found in the Regional Trial Court, and there was no entry of their receipt in the court's logbook. The loss was discovered only when Cabanag and Ancheta, tired of waiting for the outcome of the appeal, inquired at the Office of the Clerk of Court and then at the Court of Appeals, where they learned that the records had already been transmitted back. Investigation pointed to Masangcay as the last person in possession of the records.
When first confronted, Masangcay absolutely denied receiving the parcel. After the registry book bearing her signature was presented, she changed her position, admitted receipt, but claimed she did not know the parcel contained the records of her own case and that she had indorsed them to Atty. Betguen, who denied it. Weeks before the decision was promulgated on April 29, 1993, using certified copies from the Court of Appeals, Masangcay had already been continuously absent from work. Her belated applications for sick leave were addressed to the Executive Judge rather than to her immediate supervisor, and the attending physician denied advising her to rest for three months. She was declared absent without leave, and the personnel of the Municipal Trial Court of Cabarroguis refused to accept her detail to their office, considering her a person not welcome there.
Issues
- Whether or not Masangcay is guilty of dishonesty and gross misconduct in concealing the records of her appealed case.
- Whether or not her conviction for intriguing against honor is a conviction for a crime involving moral turpitude warranting separation from service.
- Whether or not she is liable for unauthorized absences.
- Whether or not the penalty of dismissal is the proper penalty.
Applicable Provisions
Article 364 of the Revised Penal Code defines the offense of which Masangcay was convicted:
Article 364. Intriguing against honor. The penalty of arresto menor or fine not exceeding 200 pesos shall be imposed upon any person who shall make any intrigue which has for its principal purpose to blemish the honor or reputation of another person.
This definition anchors the Court's holding that her offense is a crime involving moral turpitude.
Section 22, paragraph (e) of the Omnibus Rules Implementing Executive Order Number 292, the Administrative Code of 1987, treats conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude as a grave offense:
Section 22. Grave Offenses. The following are grave offenses with their corresponding penalties: (e) Conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude, penalty of dismissal.
This provision supports dismissal on the strength of her conviction alone.
Section 22, paragraphs (a) and (c) of the same Omnibus Rules govern dishonesty and gross misconduct:
Section 22. Grave Offenses. The following are grave offenses with their corresponding penalties: (a) Dishonesty, penalty of dismissal; (c) Gross misconduct, penalty of dismissal.
These are the provisions under which her concealment of the records is punished.
Section 17, Rule XIV of the same Omnibus Rules fixes the penalty where several charges are proven:
Section 17. If the respondent is found guilty of two or more charges or counts, the penalty imposed should be that corresponding to the most serious charge or count and the rest may be considered aggravating.
This provision explains why the lesser charge of unauthorized absences no longer affects the result.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found Masangcay guilty of dishonesty and gross misconduct. Her guilt was established by substantial evidence, which the Court defined as such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion. The postal employee testified that she personally handed the parcel to Masangcay, and Masangcay's own signature appeared on the registry book. The Court found her not credible when she claimed she did not know the parcel contained the records of her own case, since the Court of Appeals places the docket number of the remanded case outside the parcel, and having been employed with the court since 1983, she was presumed to know this procedure. Her claim that she indorsed the records to Atty. Betguen was unsubstantiated, while she alone had an evident motive to conceal the records affirming her conviction. The Court also noted that she concealed the records of another civil case that arrived with her own, and that those records were later found in an old cabinet with the acknowledgement receipt unsigned.
On the second issue, the Court held that intriguing against honor is a crime involving moral turpitude, which it defined as an act of baseness, vileness, or depravity in the private and social duties which a man owes his fellow man, or to society in general, contrary to the accepted and customary rule of right and duty between man and man. On this score alone, the Court said, her dismissal was warranted.
On the third issue, the Court found her liable for unauthorized absences. Her applications for sick leave were belatedly filed and addressed to the Executive Judge instead of her immediate supervisor, in violation of civil service rules, and the medical certificate covered only one day of treatment and could not excuse an absence of two and a half months.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that dismissal was the proper penalty. Since she was found guilty of more serious violations meriting dismissal, the suspension for unauthorized absences became superfluous, and under the rule on multiple charges, the penalty for the most serious charge governs while the rest are considered aggravating.
Doctrine
A court employee who conceals court records to serve a private purpose is guilty of dishonesty and gross misconduct in office, punishable by dismissal. Court records are confidential documents which may not be taken out of court without proper authority and without the necessary safeguards to ensure their confidentiality and integrity. Intriguing against honor under Article 364 of the Revised Penal Code is a crime involving moral turpitude, and conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude is a grave offense punishable by separation from service. In administrative proceedings, the quantum of proof is substantial evidence, meaning such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion. Where a respondent is found guilty of two or more charges, the penalty imposed is that corresponding to the most serious charge, and the rest may be considered aggravating.
Disposition
The Court dismissed Dominga Masangcay from the service, with cancellation of eligibility, forfeiture of leave credits and retirement benefits, and disqualification to hold office in any public office including government-owned or controlled corporations, without prejudice to any other liability.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that intriguing against honor is a crime involving moral turpitude, and a court employee who conceals court records to hide her own conviction commits dishonesty and gross misconduct warranting dismissal. Examiners like to use this case on the definition of moral turpitude, on substantial evidence as the quantum of proof in administrative proceedings, and on the rule that the most serious charge controls the penalty.