MARIANETTE VILLAREAL, COMPLAINANT, VS. ROLANDO T. RARAMA, RESTITUTO MADRAZO, FIDEL CASUYON, AND AGUINALDO DEL CAMPO, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Villareal versus Rarama
The Case
This is an administrative case brought by Marianette Villareal against four deputy sheriffs of the Municipal Trial Courts in Cities of Davao City — Rolando Rarama, Restituto Madrazo, Fidel Casuyon, and Aguinaldo del Campo — for allegedly conniving and confederating in maliciously serving a writ of execution intended for another person living in another place. The case matters because it fixes the outer limits of a sheriff's authority: he executes the writ according to its letter, and he may not levy on the property of anyone other than the judgment debtor. It is a staple in examinations on the conduct and liability of court officers.
Procedural History
The complaint was sworn and filed directly with the Supreme Court. By First Indorsement of Deputy Court Administrator Reynaldo Suarez, it was referred to respondent Rarama, through Judge Roberto Canete of the Municipal Trial Court, Branch 5, Davao City, for comment. Respondents filed a joint counter-affidavit; complainant filed a reply; respondents filed a rejoinder. The Court then issued a resolution referring the case to Executive Judge Augusto Breva of the Regional Trial Court of Davao City for investigation, report, and recommendation. Judge Breva submitted his report, recommending that Rarama be declared guilty of an administrative offense and suspended for three months with a stern warning, and that the three other respondents be exonerated. The case then came before the Supreme Court for final action.
Facts
The Cooperative Rural Bank of Davao City sued the spouses Marianette and Roy Villareal, Lito Lacorda, and Felimon Cangrejo for collection of a sum of money before the Municipal Trial Court, Branch 5, Davao City. Summons was served on Cangrejo, who failed to answer and was declared in default. Judgment was rendered against Cangrejo alone, without prejudice to his right to proceed against his co-debtors. On March 29, 1994, an alias writ of execution was issued against Cangrejo.
On April 25, 1994, Rarama went to Digos, Davao del Sur, with the other respondents and three bank employees, including collector Vic Belo. According to complainant, Rarama introduced himself as a sheriff, told her they would attach her properties because she lost a case, and when she protested, showed her the writ. She objected that the writ was addressed to Cangrejo, not to her. The respondents nonetheless pulled out a VHS player, a Singer sewing machine, and two Chinese cabinets. She was made to sign an inventory receipt. Two days later, after paying 10,000 pesos and signing a promissory note, she recovered the items.
Respondents claimed they went to her house only to ask for Cangrejo's address, and that she voluntarily deposited the items as security after begging that the writ not be enforced against her co-maker. The investigating judge rejected this defense, noting that the writ bore her signature and the date of the taking, that the receipt was prepared in advance with her name typewritten, that it recited levy and attachment rather than deposit, and that the items were brought to the court, not the bank.
Issues
- Whether or not respondent Rarama is administratively liable for levying on the property of a person who is not the judgment debtor.
- Whether or not respondents Madrazo, Casuyon, and del Campo are equally liable for the acts complained of.
- Whether or not the recommended penalty of suspension for three months is proper.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote a specific statutory provision; it rests on the settled rule governing execution, which the Court states as follows:
Hence, a sheriff has no authority to levy on execution upon the property of any person other than that of the judgment debtor.
This rule bears directly on the case because the writ was directed only against Cangrejo, and the levy was made on the property of complainant, against whom no judgment had been rendered.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held Rarama guilty of serious misconduct. Although complainant was the principal borrower and Cangrejo merely a co-maker, Cangrejo was the sole debtor adjudged liable, and the alias writ was directed only against him. Rarama therefore had no authority to implement it against complainant, since there was no judgment against her as of the date of the incident. The Court stressed that a sheriff must be circumspect and proper in his behavior, and that execution is the fruit and end of the suit and is the life of the law. When a writ is placed in his hands, it is his duty, absent contrary instructions, to proceed with reasonable celerity and promptness to execute it according to its mandate, strictly in accordance with its letter and without deviation. The Court added:
If he does so, the writ of execution affords him no justification, for such act is not in obedience to the mandate of the writ.
The Court also held that the fact that the title of the case named complainant as a defendant is of no moment, because execution must conform to what is directed in the dispositive portion and not to what appears in the title.
On the second issue, the Court dismissed the complaint against Madrazo, Casuyon, and del Campo for lack of merit. There was no clear positive evidence that they knew the writ was directed only against Cangrejo, and complainant failed to particularize the participation of each of them.
On the third issue, the Court found the recommended three-month suspension proper and commensurate, but pursuant to its policy, imposed instead a fine equivalent to his salary for three months, with some mitigation because the damages sustained were nominal and complainant herself contributed to the situation.
Doctrine
A sheriff has no authority to levy on execution upon the property of any person other than the judgment debtor. If he does so, the writ affords him no justification, for the act is not in obedience to its mandate. His duty is ministerial: to execute the writ strictly according to its letter, with reasonable celerity and promptness, and without deviation. Execution must conform to the dispositive portion of the decision, not to the title of the case. A sheriff who levies on the property of a non-judgment debtor is liable for serious misconduct.
Disposition
Rarama was declared guilty of serious misconduct and ordered to pay a fine of 10,000 pesos with a stern warning, while the complaint against Madrazo, Casuyon, and del Campo was dismissed for lack of merit.
Remember This
Memorize the line: a sheriff has no authority to levy on execution upon the property of any person other than that of the judgment debtor, and the writ affords him no justification if he does. Examiners use this case to test the ministerial duty of sheriffs, the limits of execution, and the rule that execution follows the dispositive portion, not the title of the case.