BENJAMIN Z. LIBAN, SUBSTITUTED BY THE OFFICE OF THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR, COMPLAINANT, VS. JUDGE PLARIDEL L. VILLACETE, RTC, BRANCH 4, TUGUEGARAO, CAGAYAN, ACTING PRESIDING JUDGE…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Liban versus Villacete
The Case
This is an administrative case filed by Benjamin Z. Liban against Judge Plaridel L. Villacete, the acting presiding judge of a regional trial court branch in Tuguegarao, Cagayan. Liban accused the judge of graft practices, grave misconduct, grave abuse of authority, and unethical practices prejudicial to the image of the judiciary, all arising from a replevin case pending in the judge's sala. The case matters because it shows how the Supreme Court treats a magistrate who steps out of his judicial role and places himself, extra-judicially, at the service of one party, and who borrows a litigant's property while that litigant's case hangs over him. It is a study in the canons of judicial ethics applied with full force.
Procedural History
Liban filed a verified complaint on February 23, 1993. The Supreme Court, by resolution dated August 9, 1993, referred the case to the Court of Appeals for investigation, report, and recommendation. The investigation was conducted by Justice Bernardo P. Pardo, who submitted his final report on August 22, 1994. The case then came before the Supreme Court as an administrative matter, and the Court resolved it in its own name, adopting the investigating justice's findings and recommendation.
Facts
Liban and a certain Buenaventura were parties in a replevin case pending before Judge Villacete. Liban alleged that the judge demanded around 30,000 pesos from Buenaventura and 27,000 pesos, plus two goats and one big lechon, from him. He further alleged that the judge borrowed his jeep during the pendency of the case and refused to return it despite demands until the complaint was filed. Liban also charged that some cases in the judge's sala remained unresolved even after one year from submission, and that the judge, whose legitimate family is in Manila, maintained a paramour in Tuguegarao with whom he had two children and another on the way.
In his answer, the judge denied the charges. He explained that Liban and Buenaventura had asked him to summon Governor Vargas after the governor's armed men forcibly took a payloader from Buenaventura. He declined but suggested he would provide an intermediary, a close friend of the governor in Manila, and the parties agreed to reimburse his expenses. Upon his return he issued a note to Liban asking for reimbursement. As to the jeep, he claimed it was lent to the deputy sheriff to be used in locating the payloader.
At the hearing before the Ad Hoc Committee on March 2, 1993, Liban added that the judge actually borrowed two jeeps, returned the first when it would not start, and asked for a replacement red jeep which the judge repainted black. He said the judge promised to return the jeep and the money advanced, totalling almost 30,000 pesos, if nothing happened to his case. The investigating justice found that the judge went out of his way to accommodate the parties extra-judicially, and that he borrowed the jeep for his own use, returning it only after the complaint was filed and Liban had testified.
Issues
- Whether or not respondent judge is guilty of grave misconduct in office for asking reimbursement from a litigant for his trip to Manila to contact an intermediary he himself suggested.
- Whether or not respondent judge is guilty of grave misconduct for borrowing and keeping the jeep of a litigant during the pendency of that litigant's case.
- Whether or not the penalty of dismissal from the service with forfeiture of retirement benefits and accrued leave credits is the proper sanction.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote a specific codal provision; it applies the canons of judicial ethics, which the investigating justice invoked when he found that the judge's conduct violated them. The Court adopted that finding. The governing principle is that a judge must avoid conduct that generates suspicion and must devote himself fully to his judicial duties, as the decision stresses through the rule that a court employee must render full time devoted service to the court, not to the parties.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court agreed that the judge's act of asking reimbursement from the complainant for his trip to Manila to contact the intermediary he himself suggested constituted grave misconduct. The investigating justice reasoned that the judge could have sent a wire or a letter, or contacted the governor directly in Cagayan, without travelling to Manila at the parties' expense, and that the trip generated the lingering doubt that it was actually to visit his lawful family in Manila.
On the second issue, the Court found no doubt that the judge borrowed the jeep for his own use and returned it only after the complaint was filed. The claim that the sheriff was using it to locate the payloader was rejected, since the sheriff is not an agent of the parties but a court employee who must render full time devoted service to the court.
On the third issue, the Court found the findings legally and morally sound and adopted the recommendation of dismissal with prejudice to re-employment, forfeiture of retirement benefits and accrued leave credits, effective immediately.
Doctrine
A judge who, extra-judicially, agrees to provide an intermediary between a litigant and a powerful third party, and who asks the litigant to reimburse his travel expenses for that purpose, commits grave misconduct in office prejudicial to the service and violates the canons of judicial conduct. A judge who borrows and keeps the property of a litigant during the pendency of that litigant's case commits grave misconduct, and the excuse that a court employee was using the property is no defense, because a sheriff is not an agent of the parties but a court employee who must render full time devoted service to the court. Grave misconduct of this character warrants dismissal from the service with prejudice to re-employment in any branch or instrumentality of the government, including government-owned or controlled corporations, with forfeiture of all retirement benefits and accrued leave credits.
Disposition
The Court dismissed Judge Plaridel L. Villacete from the service with prejudice to re-employment in any branch or instrumentality of the government, including government-owned or controlled corporations, forfeited all his retirement benefits and accrued leave credits, and made the resolution immediately executory.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a judge who borrows a litigant's property or asks a litigant to fund his personal trip commits grave misconduct, and the sheriff-is-using-it excuse fails because the sheriff serves the court, not the parties. Examiners use this case to test the canons of judicial ethics and the penalty of dismissal with forfeiture of benefits for grave misconduct by a magistrate.