ACR FURNITURE MANUFACTURING CORPORATION, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, VS. ZENAIDA JUNTO, DOING BUSINESS UNDER THE TRADE NAME “MARZEN WOODS AND GREEN CLASSY FURNITURE HOME DECOR ENTER, D…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
ACR Furniture Manufacturing versus Junto
The Case
This is a civil action for collection of a sum of money, brought by ACR Furniture Manufacturing Corporation against Zenaida Junto, who does business under the trade name Marzen Woods and Green Classy Furniture Home Decor Enterprise. The plaintiff sold and delivered furniture on credit and now sues for the unpaid balance, asking as well for a writ of preliminary attachment. The case matters for two reasons. First, it is a clean teaching case on the burden of proof in civil actions, on preponderance of evidence, and on the deference appellate courts give to the trial court's assessment of the evidence. Second, and more importantly for procedure, it is a case on the provisional remedy of preliminary attachment, on how the sheriff must keep attached personal property in his own custody, and on why a court cannot dissolve a valid attachment before the judgment is satisfied.
Procedural History
The plaintiff filed its complaint for collection in the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 20, and later amended the complaint to reduce the amount claimed. The trial court ordered a writ of preliminary attachment issued upon a bond, and the sheriff levied on the defendant's Toyota Hi-Ace Commuter Van and on a parcel of land in Dagupan City covered by a transfer certificate of title. After trial, the Regional Trial Court rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiff for a reduced amount, after deducting a payment of 100,000 pesos which it found the defendant had made. The same judgment dissolved the writ of attachment and ordered the plaintiff to return the van and to pay 5,000 pesos a month for its use from October 1997 until possession is turned over. The plaintiff appealed, assigning three errors: the deduction of the 100,000 pesos, the dissolution of the attachment without first satisfying the claim, and the order to return the van and pay rentals. The appeal reached the Supreme Court, which decided it through its then First Division.
Facts
From October 1996 to May 1997, Zenaida Junto obtained various furniture products on credit from ACR Furniture, with a total value of 288,435.69 pesos. The deliveries were covered by sales invoices, and the goods were received by the defendant's personnel. They were payable within ninety days but remained unpaid. A demand letter was sent, but it was returned with the remark that the addressee was unknown.
The plaintiff sued for collection and obtained a writ of preliminary attachment upon a bond. Pursuant to the writ, the sheriff attached the defendant's Toyota Hi-Ace Commuter Van and a parcel of land in Dagupan City. The sheriff, however, transferred custody of the van to the plaintiff. In her answer, the defendant pleaded payment and return of goods, and claimed that her check payment of 100,000 pesos had never been credited. She admitted the rest of the deliveries but denied several of the invoices.
At trial, the plaintiff's regional salesman testified to the deliveries and the unpaid account. The defendant testified that she had issued a check for 100,000 pesos which was encashed but never credited, although only a photocopy of the check could be presented because the original was misplaced. The trial court found that this assertion of payment was not rebutted by the plaintiff, and deducted the 100,000 pesos from the claim. It also dissolved the attachment and ordered the return of the van with monthly rentals. Hence the appeal.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in finding that the defendant had paid 100,000 pesos, and in deducting that amount from her total obligation.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in dissolving the writ of preliminary attachment without first satisfying the claim sought to be enforced.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in ordering the plaintiff to return the Toyota Hi-Ace Commuter Van and to pay 5,000 pesos a month for its use until possession is turned over to the defendant.
Applicable Provisions
Section 5 of Rule 57 of the Revised Rules of Court provides:
Section 5. Manner of attaching property. The sheriff enforcing the writ shall without delay and with all reasonable diligence attach, to await judgment and execution in the action only so much of the property in the Philippines of the party against whom the writ is issued, not exempt from execution, as may be sufficient to satisfy the applicant's demand.
This fixes the sheriff's duty to attach only so much of the debtor's property as is needed to satisfy the demand, and it anchors the Court's discussion of how attached property must be kept.
Section 7 of the same Rule provides:
Section 7. Attachment of real and personal property; recording thereof. Real and personal property shall be attached by the sheriff executing the writ in the following manner: b) Personal property capable of manual delivery, by taking and safely keeping it in his custody, after issuing the corresponding receipt therefor.
This is the provision the sheriff violated when he left the attached van in the possession of the plaintiff instead of keeping it safely in his own custody.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that there was no error in deducting the 100,000 pesos. The trial court found that the defendant's assertion of payment was not rebutted by the plaintiff, and the appellate court gives full weight and respect to the trial court's determination of the credibility of witnesses, since the trial judge had the opportunity to observe their demeanor. The defendant established by preponderant evidence that she paid that sum. The Court explained that preponderance of evidence is the weight, credit, and value of the aggregate evidence on either side, and means the probability of the truth. It is evidence more convincing to the court as worthy of belief than that offered in opposition.
On the second and third issues, which the Court discussed jointly, it held that the trial court erred in dissolving the attachment and in ordering the return of the van with rentals. Attachment is a juridical institution intended to secure the outcome of the trial, that is, the satisfaction of the pecuniary obligation. Its overriding purpose is to secure a contingent lien on the defendant's property until the plaintiff can obtain a judgment and have the property applied to its satisfaction. A preliminary attachment may be discharged only on the grounds the Rules allow, such as the posting of a counterbond, an improper or irregular issuance, an excessive attachment, property exempt from execution, or a judgment rendered against the attaching creditor. None of these circumstances attended this case, and the defendant never moved to discharge the attachment. The Court stressed that an attachment lien continues until the debt is paid, or sale is had under execution, or the judgment is satisfied, or the attachment is discharged or vacated in the manner provided by law.
The Court then turned to the sheriff's conduct. The sheriff attached the van but transferred custody of it to the plaintiff. Under Section 7 of Rule 57, personal property capable of manual delivery must be attached by taking and safely keeping it in the sheriff's custody, after issuing a receipt. The sheriff's act of leaving the attached property in the possession and control of the creditor did not satisfy the requirements of the Rules. The duty of sheriffs to execute a writ is purely ministerial, not discretionary, and they must keep the levied property safely in their custody, not in that of any of the parties. Leaving the attached property in the possession of the attaching creditor makes a farce of the attachment. The Court therefore found no legal basis for holding the plaintiff liable to pay monthly rentals for the use of the van.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, in civil cases the party having the burden of proof must establish his case by a preponderance of evidence, which means the greater weight of the credible evidence, or the probability of the truth. Second, appellate courts give full weight and respect to the trial court's findings on the credibility of witnesses, because the trial judge observed their demeanor. Third, a preliminary attachment may be discharged only on the grounds provided by the Rules, and an attachment lien continues until the debt is paid, the judgment is satisfied, or the attachment is validly discharged or vacated in the manner provided by law. Fourth, under Section 7 of Rule 57, personal property capable of manual delivery is attached by the sheriff taking and safely keeping it in his custody, and leaving it in the possession of the attaching creditor does not satisfy the Rules. The sheriff's duty to execute a writ is purely ministerial, not discretionary.
Disposition
The appeal was granted in part. The Court affirmed the award to the plaintiff of 188,435.90 pesos with interest from the filing of the complaint until full satisfaction, but recalled and set aside the discharge of the attachment and the order to pay rentals, and reinstated the writ of attachment until full satisfaction of the judgment.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that the sheriff must keep attached personal property safely in his own custody, and leaving it with the attaching creditor makes a farce of the attachment. Examiners like to use this case on preliminary attachment, on the ministerial duty of sheriffs, and on preponderance of evidence in collection suits.