EMIGDIO L. ENJAMBRE, JR. PETITIONER, VS. LORETO C. POWAO RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Enjambre versus Powao
The Case
This is Enjambre versus Powao, a case that reached the Supreme Court by way of a petition for review filed by Emigdio L. Enjambre, Jr. against Loreto C. Powao. What makes this case worth studying is not a grand doctrinal pronouncement but a procedural event: the petitioner himself moved to withdraw his own petition, and the Court granted that motion. The decision is therefore a compact lesson on how the Supreme Court disposes of a pending appeal when the party who brought it chooses, voluntarily and knowingly, to abandon it. It matters to a reviewee because it shows the Court applying the settled rule that a motion to withdraw, when not contrary to law, custom, and public policy, will be granted, and that the consequence is the closure and termination of the case.
Procedural History
The case began in the Office of the Ombudsman (Visayas), which imposed upon the petitioner a penalty of nine months suspension. From that ruling, the petitioner elevated the matter by way of a petition for review, docketed as G.R. SP Number 07449, and filed with the Supreme Court. The petition remained pending before the Court for nearly two years. During that pendency, the petitioner filed a Motion to Withdraw Petition. The Supreme Court, finding the motion not contrary to law, custom, and public policy, granted it. There is no separate discussion in the decision of any intermediate appellate ruling; the path presented is from the Ombudsman directly to the Supreme Court by petition for review, and then to withdrawal.
Facts
Emigdio L. Enjambre, Jr. was met with a penalty of nine months suspension imposed upon him by the Office of the Ombudsman (Visayas). He responded by filing a petition for review before the Supreme Court, docketed as G.R. SP Number 07449, seeking relief from that penalty.
Nearly two years passed with the petition still pending. The petitioner then filed a Motion to Withdraw Petition. In that motion, he manifested that the decision to withdraw was voluntarily and knowingly made after careful consideration of the additional time, effort, and expenses he would have to incur in connection with the case, noting that he is a mere salaried government employee with children to support.
He further manifested that he had fully served the nine month suspension penalty imposed upon him by the Office of the Ombudsman (Visayas), and that the withdrawal was made with a view to reconciling with the respondent, Loreto C. Powao, in the spirit of forgiveness and Christian brotherhood. On these manifestations, he prayed that the petition for review pending before the Court be withdrawn.
Issues
- Whether or not the Motion to Withdraw Petition filed by the petitioner should be granted.
- Whether or not the withdrawal of the petition for review is contrary to law, custom, and public policy.
- Whether or not the withdrawal of the petition results in the closure and termination of the case.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote or construe any statutory or constitutional provision. It rests entirely on the Court's finding that the motion is not contrary to law, custom, and public policy, and on the petitioner's own manifestations in his Motion to Withdraw Petition. No verbatim provision is reproduced in the decision text, so none is quoted here.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court granted the Motion to Withdraw Petition. It began from the premise that the motion was before it, and it examined whether the relief prayed for could be allowed. Its controlling formulation was this:
Finding the instant motion not contrary to law, custom and public policy, the same is hereby GRANTED.
On the second issue, the Court answered that the withdrawal was not contrary to law, custom, and public policy. The petitioner had manifested that the decision to withdraw was voluntarily and knowingly made, after weighing the additional time, effort, and expenses the litigation would demand of a salaried government employee with children to support. He had also fully served the nine month suspension penalty imposed by the Office of the Ombudsman (Visayas), and he sought reconciliation with the respondent in the spirit of forgiveness and Christian brotherhood. Nothing in those manifestations offended law, custom, or public policy, and so the motion was granted.
On the third issue, the Court ordered the appeal withdrawn and declared the case closed and terminated. Its dispositive language was:
WHEREFORE, the appeal docketed as G.R. SP No. 07449 filed by herein petitioner is hereby ordered WITHDRAWN and the case is deemed CLOSED and TERMINATED.
The Court thus treated the withdrawal of the petition as ending the litigation, without reaching the merits of the Ombudsman's penalty.
Doctrine
First, a party who files a petition for review may withdraw it, and where the withdrawal is shown to be voluntary and knowing, and the motion is not contrary to law, custom, and public policy, the Supreme Court will grant it. The test the Court states is negative and cumulative: the motion must offend none of law, custom, and public policy.
Second, the grant of a motion to withdraw a petition carries a procedural consequence: the appeal is ordered withdrawn and the case is deemed closed and terminated. The Court does not proceed to adjudicate the merits once the petition is withdrawn.
Third, the Court will accept the petitioner's own manifestations, such as the voluntary and knowing character of the decision to withdraw, the full service of the penalty imposed by the Office of the Ombudsman, and the desire to reconcile with the respondent, as sufficient basis for allowing the withdrawal.
Disposition
The petitioner won his motion: the Supreme Court granted the Motion to Withdraw Petition, ordered the appeal withdrawn, and deemed the case closed and terminated.
Remember This
Memorize the line: a motion to withdraw a petition that is not contrary to law, custom, and public policy is granted, and the case is deemed closed and terminated. Examiners use this case for the procedural point that a petitioner may voluntarily withdraw a pending petition for review, and for the consequence that withdrawal ends the case without a ruling on the merits.