CONTRACT RAISER NO. 2- SIERRADILE/RACHEL D. FLORENCIO, CONTRACT RAISER NO. 4-RIVERBEND POULTRYVILLE/ MERCEDES D. FLORENCIO AND FADCOR INC. AND/OR ROSENDO “RANDY” O. FLORENCIO, P…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Rebellon versus Sierradile
The Case
This is a labor case about the limits of res judicata — the rule that forbids the reopening of a matter once judicially determined by a competent authority. The private respondents, led by Bernadette Rebellon and Charlito Rebellon together with several farm workers, sued the contract raisers, Fadcor Incorporated and Rosendo Florencio, for unfair labor practice, illegal dismissal, and money claims. The petitioners came to the Supreme Court on a petition for certiorari, insisting that a prior dismissal of an earlier complaint — one that had already become final and executory — barred the second complaint. The case matters because it teaches that res judicata requires a substantial identity of parties, and that the same corporation sued once as a direct employer and later as an indirect employer is not sued in the same capacity. The identity of parties is measured by identity of interest, not merely by identity of names.
Procedural History
The first complaint was filed before the Labor Arbiter and docketed as a case for unfair labor practice, illegal dismissal, underpayment of salary, and related money claims against Fadcor Incorporated and Rosendo Florencio. Labor Arbiter Gerardo Yulo dismissed the complaint after finding that no employer-employee relationship existed between the parties. On appeal, the National Labor Relations Commission affirmed the dismissal. The respondents did not challenge that ruling, so it became final and executory.
Instead, the respondents filed a second complaint before the Labor Arbiter, this time impleading not only Fadcor and Rosendo Florencio but also Contract Raiser Number 2, Sierradile, through Rachel Florencio, and Contract Raiser Number 4, Riverbend Poultryville, through Mercedes Florencio. The petitioners moved to dismiss on the ground of res judicata. Labor Arbiter Nieves de Castro denied the motion, observing that the respondents were being sued in different capacities distinct from the earlier case. On the merits, Labor Arbiter de Castro ruled against the petitioners, holding all respondents jointly liable for illegal dismissal, ordering reinstatement, and awarding backwages and salary differentials.
The petitioners appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission, which affirmed the Labor Arbiter's decision in a resolution dated 4 September 2003 and denied the motion for reconsideration on 16 December 2003. The petitioners then elevated the matter to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari, assigning grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack of jurisdiction.
Facts
Fadcor Incorporated is engaged in selling eggs, grains, animal feeds, feed ingredients, livestock, and agricultural goods. It does not itself operate poultry farms. Instead, it purchases eggs on a wholesale basis from different farms in San Mateo, which are operated by contract growers. These contract growers, in turn, hire caretakers and workers to maintain the farm. Fadcor supplies the chickens and feeds to these farms.
The Rebellon spouses were caretakers of one such contract raiser. The workers filed a first complaint against Fadcor and Rosendo Florencio, but Labor Arbiter Yulo dismissed it, finding that the documentary evidence — the supervisory reports, daily reports, audit reports, and disbursement vouchers — showed only business transactions and not an employer-employee relationship. The National Labor Relations Commission affirmed, and no appeal was taken.
Relying on that very finding — that Fadcor and Florencio were not the direct employers — the respondents filed a second complaint. This time they sued the contract raisers as the direct employers, and impleaded Fadcor and Florencio as indirect employers. The petitioners resisted, arguing that the first judgment barred the second complaint under res judicata.
Issues
- Whether or not the second complaint is barred by res judicata in light of the final and executory decision in the first case.
- Whether or not the National Labor Relations Commission gravely abused its discretion in sustaining the Labor Arbiter's decision despite the petitioners' claim that the private respondents' allegations were bare and self-serving.
Applicable Provisions
Article 217 of the Labor Code of the Philippines, on the jurisdiction of the Labor Arbiter, provides:
The Labor Code vests upon the Labor Arbiter the jurisdiction to hear and decide, inter alia, cases on unfair labor practice, termination disputes and money claims.
This provision establishes that the Labor Arbiter had jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties in the first case, satisfying the second element of res judicata.
Article 223 of the Labor Code of the Philippines, on the power of the National Labor Relations Commission, provides:
On the other hand, basic is the rule that the NLRC has the power to review cases passed upon by the Labor Arbiter.
This confirms that the decisions of the National Labor Relations Commission are clothed with a judicial character, since they are reviewable by the Supreme Court, and thus may serve as the basis of a final judgment for purposes of res judicata.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that res judicata does not apply because the fourth element — substantial identity of parties, subject matter, and causes of action — is wanting. The Court laid down the elements of res judicata:
(1) the previous judgment has become final; (2) the prior judgment was rendered by a court having jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties; (3) the first judgment was made on the merits; and (4) there was substantial identity of parties, subject matter and causes of action, as between the prior and subsequent actions.
The Court found the first three elements present. The first judgment became final and executory by operation of law upon the lapse of the reglementary period for appeal, since the respondents did not challenge it. The Labor Arbiter had jurisdiction under Article 217, and the National Labor Relations Commission had the power to review under Article 223. The judgment was on the merits, because it was rendered after argument and investigation, with the parties having submitted their respective affidavits and position papers.
But on the fourth element, the Court agreed with the National Labor Relations Commission that the parties do not represent the same interest. The contract raisers, Sierradile through Rachel Florencio and Riverbend Poultryville through Mercedes Florencio, were not parties in the first case at all, so res judicata cannot be invoked against them. As for Fadcor and Rosendo Florencio, who were parties in both cases, they were sued in different capacities: in the first case as direct employers, and in the second case as indirect employers. The Court stressed that the degree of liability of an indirect employer is completely different from that of a direct employer. Indeed, it was the finding in the first judgment — that no employer-employee relationship existed between the respondents and Fadcor and Florencio — that moved the respondents to file the second case against the actual direct employers.
The Court distinguished the case of Villa Esperanza Development Corporation versus Court of Appeals, which the petitioners cited, because that case involved a co-plaintiff in the first case who had identical interest with the plaintiff in the second case, both seeking the same relief of specific performance. No such identity of interest exists here. The Court quoted Macaraeg versus Court of Appeals:
[T]he [substantial] identity [of the parties] is an indispensable requisite of the doctrine of res judicata.
On the second issue, the Court upheld the National Labor Relations Commission's findings, there being no showing of grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack of jurisdiction.
Doctrine
A Bar candidate must retain these rules. First, res judicata forbids the reopening of a matter once judicially determined by a competent authority, and it requires four elements: a previous judgment that has become final; a prior judgment rendered by a court having jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties; a first judgment made on the merits; and a substantial identity of parties, subject matter, and causes of action.
Second, a judgment becomes final and executory by operation of law, not by judicial declaration — it becomes final upon the lapse of the reglementary period for appeal if no appeal is perfected. Decisions of the National Labor Relations Commission are clothed with a judicial character because they are reviewable by the Supreme Court.
Third, a judgment on the merits is one rendered after argument and investigation, and when there is a determination of which party is right.
Fourth, and most important for this case, substantial identity of parties is an indispensable requisite of res judicata. Identity of parties is not measured by identity of names alone but by identity of interest. The same entity sued once as a direct employer and later as an indirect employer is sued in different capacities, and the degree of liability is completely different, so res judicata does not bar the second action.
Disposition
The Supreme Court denied the petition and affirmed the challenged resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission in toto, holding that the second complaint was not barred by res judicata.
Remember This
Memorize this line: substantial identity of parties is an indispensable requisite of res judicata, and it is measured by identity of interest, not identity of names. Examiners like to use this case to test whether a student can distinguish a party sued as a direct employer from the same party sued as an indirect employer, and to test the four elements of res judicata in the labor setting.